InvestSMART

CBD

Full steam ahead despite bikie bust
By · 9 May 2013
By ·
9 May 2013
comments Comments
Full steam ahead despite bikie bust

His son has quit the business and bikies are being busted in front of him but for media salesman Harold Mitchell it's apparently business as usual.

On Wednesday Stuart Mitchell stepped down as deputy chairman of Aegis Media's Australian and New Zealand operations, a post he held since the Mitchell family sold its media buying company Mitchell & Partners to UK-based Aegis a couple of years ago.

The Mitchell family then reaped an estimated $200 million when Aegis was in turn swallowed by Japanese media giant Dentsu in a deal closed in late March.

The impending handover to Dentsu sparked rumours Stuart Mitchell had left the organisation, which his father denied at the time.

Mitchell snr told CBD the handover was "probably partly what brought it [Stuart Mitchell's resignation] all about. At the age of 42 he wants to do something different with his life."

While his son "will probably take a break, which is a good idea", the elder Mitchell is ploughing on as executive chairman of Aegis Australia and New Zealand. "It's a service industry, it's a bit like being a gynaecologist. You try to have a holiday and someone says, 'Don't you know my baby is due?"'

Mitchell had just witnessed the dramatic arrest of the Victorian president of the Bandidos outlaw motorcycle gang in South Melbourne.

Battle-scarred bikie Toby Mitchell - no relation - was picked up by police. "There were police cars screaming in from everywhere," Mitchell (the advertising one) said.

Forget peasants

Seniority has its privileges and if Seven West is any guide, one of them is not exchanging pleasantries with the peasantry.

On Wednesday megamogul Kerry Stokes and his new 24-carat consigliere John Alexander turned out along with the Seven West board to enjoy tea and bickies on the top-floor balcony of Sydney's Museum of Contemporary Art with assorted analysts and investors. But they largely left the talking to minions, with the amount of time spent selling the company's "new strategic methodology" of "building leadership in adjacent verticals" apparently inverse to seniority.

Managing director Don Voelte barely troubled the audience for more than five minutes in a marathon two-hour presentation.

Voelte did say the company "has identified even more opportunities for improvement". CBD wonders if those areas include Seven's struggling Melbourne news, helmed by former Herald Sun editor Simon Pristel.

Sharing the anger

Wednesday's item about the Takeovers Panel giving the Silman family a rap on the knuckles over goings-on at World Oil has brought angry shareholders in listed cashbox Lemarne Corporation out of the woodwork.

According to the panel, the family snapped up 30 per cent of World Oil without declaring an association or making a takeover bid. It ordered ASIC to seize and sell shares held by the family in excess of the 20 per cent threshold at which a takeover bid must be lodged.

Among findings made by the panel after delving into the family's spaghetti-like business interests was that Ariel Silman's Ariel Nominees was associated with his father Maurice's Rokeba Nominees. By sheer coincidence, last year the same two companies piled into Lemarne, building a combined stake of 30.9 per cent.

Rokeba became a substantial shareholder on September 28, declaring it held 11.16 per cent of the company and Ariel followed suit on October 22 with 19.75 per cent. Ariel Silman didn't return CBD's call to his office.

Lemarne doesn't have a business, having sold off its Malaysian electronics factory in November 2011. That left it with cash of $5.11 million, although by the end of March it had managed to reduce the pile to a more manageable $2.86 million.

Got a tip?

bbutler@fairfaxmedia.com.au
Google News
Follow us on Google News
Go to Google News, then click "Follow" button to add us.
Share this article and show your support
Free Membership
Free Membership
InvestSMART
InvestSMART
Keep on reading more articles from InvestSMART. See more articles
Join the conversation
Join the conversation...
There are comments posted so far. Join the conversation, please login or Sign up.

Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…

Stuart Mitchell stepped down as deputy chairman of Aegis Media's Australia and New Zealand operations. According to his father Harold Mitchell, Stuart — aged 42 — wanted to do something different with his life and will probably take a break after the handover to Dentsu.

When UK-based Aegis was acquired by Japanese media giant Dentsu in a deal that closed in late March, the Mitchell family is reported to have reaped an estimated $200 million from the series of transactions that began when they sold Mitchell & Partners to Aegis.

Yes. Harold Mitchell remains active as executive chairman of Aegis Australia and New Zealand and has said he is continuing in the business even after his son’s resignation, describing the media business as a service industry that often needs ongoing attention.

At a recent investor gathering, Seven West’s board — including Kerry Stokes and John Alexander — met with analysts and investors. Managing director Don Voelte spoke briefly and said the company 'has identified even more opportunities for improvement,' while the company promoted a 'new strategic methodology' of building leadership in adjacent verticals. The article also flagged questions about Seven’s struggling Melbourne news operation.

The Takeovers Panel found that members of the Silman family acquired about 30% of World Oil without declaring an association or making a takeover bid. The panel ordered ASIC to seize and sell any shares held by the family in excess of the 20% threshold that triggers a takeover bid obligation.

After investigating the Silman family’s interests, the panel found Ariel Silman’s Ariel Nominees was associated with his father Maurice’s Rokeba Nominees. Those two entities together built a combined stake of about 30.9% in Lemarne Corporation last year.

Lemarne is described as a listed cashbox with no operating business after selling its Malaysian electronics factory in November 2011. The article notes Lemarne had cash of $5.11 million after that sale, which had been reduced to $2.86 million by the end of March.

The article shows the Takeovers Panel and ASIC can enforce the 20% takeover threshold and require disclosure of associated parties. For everyday investors, it’s a reminder to watch for large share acquisitions, related-party declarations and regulatory actions in thin or cashbox-listed stocks, since those events can influence share ownership and corporate outcomes.