InvestSMART

CBD

Pilot boast giving Qantas cabin fever
By · 3 Aug 2011
By ·
3 Aug 2011
comments Comments
Pilot boast giving Qantas cabin fever

The ongoing industrial dispute between Qantas and its 1650 long-haul pilots has claimed its highest profile victim to date. The airline confirmed yesterday that it has started replacing a pre-flight safety video starring John Travolta.

Just five months since installing the clip hosted by the Saturday Night Fever star on its jets, Qantas has argued that it was never meant to be a permanent fixture.

"John Travolta's introduction to the in-flight safety video was an initiative to help draw attention to this vital safety information, building on his established relationship with Qantas," said an airline spokesman.

"It was always intended as a temporary feature and we are looking at working with other Qantas partners on similar initiatives in future."

But the pilots union sees another motive at play, given the similarity between Travolta's message in the video to its own.

In the safety video, Travolta says: "There's no one I'd rather have at the controls than a Qantas pilot."

The Australian & International Pilots Association's motto in its industrial campaign against Qantas sourcing lower-paid pilots from overseas is: "When you board a Qantas flight, you expect a Qantas pilot." The association's vice-president, Richard Woodward, said: "Admittedly, the John Travolta in-flight video had its fair share of detractors, but the one line I think everyone agreed with was that there was no one you would rather have at the controls than a Qantas pilot. In simpler times, this would be an uncontroversial remark, but with Alan Joyce now eager to outsource Qantas pilot jobs overseas, well, suddenly Travolta is out of step with the chief executive officer."

It is unclear whether the Qantas CEO Alan "Tony Manero" Joyce could star in a future Qantas safety clip.

MOORE IS LESS

The (relatively) lean times at Macquarie Group have continued to be felt at the top, with the investment bank's chief executive Nick Moore seeing a swag of 160,000 options lapse on Monday night.

With the Silver Doughnut's share price trading at $27, the options which were exercisable at $61.79 were well out of the money.

It is one year since Moore saw another swag of 170,000 options exercisable at $63.34 lapse.

POISON PENS

The word count battle between the Gennadiy Bogolyubov-controlled Consolidated Minerals [ConsMin] and the Bermuda-domiciled OM Holdings has stepped up a gear after the Ukrainian billionaire launched a blistering attack on the manganese miner whose board he is seeking to spill.

After seeing his requisition of meeting to topple OM chairman Low Ngee Tong and director Tan Peng Chin knocked back on a word count technicality, Bogolyubov yesterday hit out at their use of Section 79-1b of the Bermudan Companies Act.

This is the part of the act which requires notices of meeting to be less than 1000 words. "You would think the OM board would want their shareholders to form a view based on more information rather than less, however this is clearly not the case," Bogolyubov said in a statement.

"This is another example of how OM cherry picks - selectively choosing to rely on technicalities under Bermudan law when it suits the interests of the incumbent board."

Despite arguing its original 955 word statement in the requisition of meeting (which was added with a 366 word biography of the two directors it is seeking to install, the former NSW Liberal leader Peter Debnam and Malcolm McComas), ConsMin now plans to lodge a second requisition of meeting that will be less than 1000 words in total.

The next question could relate to where the requisitioned meeting could be held.

After holding its recent shareholder meetings in Singapore, there is always the possibility OM could choose Bermuda for its next meeting.

BOILING OVER

Macquarie Group's former head of property Bill Moss has not let his failed attempt to snare management control of the Charter Hall Office fund silence his campaign against the excessive fees charged across the real estate investment trust (REIT) sector.

"The industry is over-bloated and over-paid," Moss declared in the industry newsletter I&T News.

"If the industry wants a future it needs to clean up its corporate governance, its fee structure and needs to create a model that is desired by all asset classes," said Moss, who in his last 12 months at Macquarie received $30.6 million in remuneration.

The Moss Capital founder, who helped steer the Charter Hall fund (and help set in place its current fee structure) when it was previously managed by Macquarie, compared the REIT sector to a boiling frog.

"If you put a frog in cold water and slowly heat the water until it boils the frog won't jump out of the boiling water. It will die," Moss told the newsletter.

"The industry is so comfortable in its own environment. It's a club. But they're scared. Are they perpetuating a gravy train for themselves?"

Got a tip? Use our online tips box or email srochfort@smh.com.au

Google News
Follow us on Google News
Go to Google News, then click "Follow" button to add us.
Share this article and show your support
Free Membership
Free Membership
InvestSMART
InvestSMART
Keep on reading more articles from InvestSMART. See more articles
Join the conversation
Join the conversation...
There are comments posted so far. Join the conversation, please login or Sign up.

Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…

Qantas confirmed it has started replacing the pre‑flight safety video starring John Travolta. The airline says the Travolta clip was always intended as a temporary initiative to draw attention to safety information and to build on his relationship with Qantas. The change comes five months after the video was installed.

Pilots’ representatives see the timing and content of the Travolta clip as relevant to an ongoing industrial dispute. The Australian & International Pilots Association highlights a motto — “When you board a Qantas flight, you expect a Qantas pilot” — and noted Travolta’s line in the video (“There’s no one I’d rather have at the controls than a Qantas pilot”) conflicted with Qantas management’s perceived push to source lower‑paid pilots from overseas.

The article flags the dispute as high‑profile and reputational — centred on outsourcing and who operates Qantas flights. For investors, industrial relations issues like this can matter for brand perception and operations, but the piece reports the dispute and the video change without specific financial outcomes.

Nick Moore saw 160,000 options lapse because Macquarie’s share price was trading around $27 while those options were exercisable at $61.79, so they were well out of the money. The article notes a similar lapse of 170,000 options exercisable at $63.34 occurred about a year earlier.

When options are out of the money they lapse unexercised, which means the executives did not receive additional shares via those options. The article presents this as a direct consequence of the share price relative to option exercise prices, illustrating how option‑based pay depends on stock performance.

Gennadiy Bogolyubov‑controlled Consolidated Minerals launched a campaign to replace members of OM Holdings’ board and has publicly criticised OM for using a Bermuda Companies Act technicality to limit meeting notice length. After OM knocked back a requisition to topple OM’s chair Low Ngee Tong and director Tan Peng Chin on a word‑count technicality, ConsMin plans to lodge a second requisition that complies with the sub‑1,000‑word rule.

Section 79‑1b of the Bermuda Companies Act requires notices of meeting to be less than 1,000 words. OM relied on that provision to reject ConsMin’s original requisition on a word‑count technicality. ConsMin has criticised that approach and intends to submit a revised requisition that meets the word‑limit requirement.

Bill Moss, former Macquarie head of property and Moss Capital founder, said the REIT industry is “over‑bloated and over‑paid,” calling for cleaner corporate governance and fee structures. He used a boiling‑frog analogy to warn the sector is complacent. The article also notes Moss received $30.6 million in remuneration in his last 12 months at Macquarie. For investors, his comments highlight ongoing scrutiny of fees and governance in REITs such as the Charter Hall Office fund.