Toyota, GM, China in the race for EV dominance

Toyota and General Motors thought they had won the battle against sharing cutting-edge electric car technology with China, but the sale of US green battery maker A123 to a Chinese firm has ruffled feathers once more.

Foreign carmakers in China, including General Motors Co and Toyota Motor Corp, last year thought they had scored a victory over Beijing's efforts to strong-arm them into sharing cutting-edge electric car technology.

But that could prove compromised as leading Chinese auto parts firm Wanxiang Group Corp's $465 million investment in A123 Systems Inc, a struggling US maker of lithium-ion batteries, may help China unlock the secrets to critical and advanced green-car technologies.

The investment has ruffled feathers in the run-up to the presidential election in the United States as A123 receives government grants tied to it keeping production and jobs in the US during an economic downturn that has seen unemployment levels remain stubbornly above 8 per cent.

Some industry executives including engineering chiefs from two global automakers, who did not want to be named because of the sensitivity of the matter, expressed concern at the prospect that A123 could lose control of its fiercely guarded battery design and manufacturing know-how. They are particularly worried that Wanxiang might shift part of A123's research and development activities to China – if the deal wins US and Chinese government approval.

"I don't care if A123 manufactures more battery cells and packs in China. That wouldn't jeopardise its technological advantage," said a chief engineer at one global automaker. "But showing what's inside their black box ... the technology that makes those battery cells packed with energy, to its Chinese investor, which has its own battery business, is completely another matter."

There are several types of lithium-ion battery – an advanced energy-storage device that has made the electric car a possible alternative to gasoline-fueled vehicles. A123's technology, which uses iron-phosphate, is seen in the industry as having better chemical stability, making it safer for electric cars.

The enabling technology was in part developed by a Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) professor who is one of A123's founders, and is patented. The 'nano technology' involved, for instance, shrinks lithium particles to nano dimensions, helping boost a battery cell's energy density, and putting more power into a smaller box.

Wanxiang's lifeline to loss-making A123 could see it end up with around an 80 per cent stake in the Massachusetts-based battery maker, and four of the nine board seats.

Fears overblown?

Pin Ni, a son-in-law of Wanxiang's founder and head of the group's US operations, said his company would not do anything to harm A123, which listed on the Nasdaq stock exchange in 2009. "Obviously we're going to try to grow the company; we're going to do what's best for the company," Ni told Reuters by telephone, declining to elaborate.

People close to Wanxiang and familiar with its A123 investment, said the company would behave responsibly with A123's intellectual property, and noted the US firm already produces advanced batteries in China.

Fears of A123 losing control of its intellectual property are overblown, they said.

Wanxiang is a major auto parts supplier and has a relatively large presence in the United States having bought up distressed parts makers over the past decade. It formed a joint venture which bought and turned around Driveline Systems, an axle maker in Illinois, and has taken over parts operations from Ford Motor Co, among others in the US Midwest.

Wanxiang's existing joint venture in China with Ener1 Inc , a US company which this year emerged from a Chapter 11 bankruptcy restructuring, produces manganese-based lithium-ion batteries.

A person close to Ener1 said the company has been "extra cautious" not to allow Wanxiang engineers to interact with its US-based battery scientists and engineers because of fears of losing know-how to its Chinese partner.

Neither A123 nor Ener1 responded to requests for comment for this article.

Slow burn

A123 has battery contracts with BMW, China's SAIC and US startup Fisker Automotive, and is slated to provide batteries for GM's upcoming Chevrolet Spark EV. It was hit this year by a defective battery recall and warned last month that it had only about five months of cash left.

Two years ago, China, the world's biggest autos market, began drawing up plans to corral foreign brands into joint ventures that would give Beijing more access to the latest battery technology.

Fearing battery technology leaks, the auto giants complained, and China watered down its demands, allowing foreign automakers to own 50 per cent of local ventures, rather than just a minority stake – but not before foreign automakers such as GM, Toyota and Nissan Motor Co Ltd had taken steps to protect their advanced technology by making cars in China with cheaper one- or two-generation-old technologies.

The spread of green technology has been slow in part because of its high cost and the lack of public charging facilities.

And the expected boom in electric cars – which had prompted battery makers to build too much capacity – just hasn't materialised. In the United States, January-July electric vehicle and hybrid sales totalled 270,000, just 3 per cent of total car sales, according to green-car website

Want access to our latest research and new buy ideas?

Start a free 15 day trial and gain access to our research, recommendations and market-beating model portfolios.

Sign up for free

Related Articles