A consumer-satisfaction survey reveals that small providers outscore the big boys.
PHONE calls answered on the first ring. A friendly, real-life person on the other end. Efficient service thereafter.
No, it's not some unattainable customer utopia, it's here, in Australia, today. Or the respondents to our annual SMILES survey - which stands for the Smart Investor League of Exceptional Service - say it is at 12 companies.
One of the 1400 Aussies who voted for their favourite providers of everything from savings accounts and insurance to mobile phones and utilities even said: "I feel they care about me."
Another enthused: "They truly deliver on their motto: happy banking."
They were both talking about BankWest, which scooped the pool in our survey this year.
Emanating from Western Australia and now owned by banking behemoth the Commonwealth Bank, the smaller regional player has preserved its own identity and apparently delivered on a three-year campaign to improve customer service.
It came top of the home lender and day-to-day banking categories, dethroning people's champion Bendigo Bank after four years at the top, to be named Australia's favourite provider (with a 72 per cent satisfaction rating).
It's also worth noting BankWest is Smart Investor's reigning Blue Ribbon Awards' Bank of the Year.
So what can you expect at BankWest that's better than the rest? Respondents said old-fashioned good manners, fast resolutions, competitive interest rates, conveniences such as "express" stores that are open longer hours and mobile banking iPhone and Android apps.
Meanwhile, the big boys are nowhere to be found. Of a potential four banking categories, not one of our largest institutions comes top. Westpac Online Investing was voted best online broker, though.
In other categories, many household names take a beating, too. Smaller companies, for example, polled highest for best internet provider (Internode) and best utilities provider (Integral Energy, which services Queensland and NSW).
In fact, it appears a lot of companies are scrimping on customer service as the economic downturn and cost-cutting bite. Across all categories, people are less satisfied on average with the service they receive than they were 12 months ago.
In a sign of the times, the biggest drops in overall ratings were for superannuation funds, down 8 per cent, and fund managers, down 7 per cent. Performance plays a big part in the perception of value for money and many funds sustained big losses in the global financial crisis and its ongoing ructions.
AustralianSuper, one of the country's largest funds with $42 billion of our money, topped the super category with a rating of 66 per cent versus the 63 per cent average.
Communication with members as to why balances have fallen is key but so too is the fact that the fund has responded to market turmoil by freezing administration fees.
Getting back to those providers that disappointed, mobile phone companies were docked 5 per cent in just a year (to 65 per cent).
Not many Vodafone customers are "smiling". But we are also 5 per cent less satisfied with our life insurers, taking the score down to 66 per cent, probably because we resent the premiums when times are tight and we've made no claims.
What's interesting is that despite controversy over non-payments for properties damaged in this year's floods, satisfaction with general insurers fell by only 3 per cent to stand well above life insurers at 72 per cent.
Health insurance, a purchase we are both enticed and induced to make by the government, polls on average just below at 70 per cent and has fallen only slightly in the year.
So what irks us most? Automated voice systems, waiting more than 10 minutes to be served, inefficient service, lack of communication, rudeness.
It's all very annoying but unless enough of us vote with our feet, it won't improve.
Good service is out there. You just have to switch to it.
Follow this writer on Twitter @NicolePedMcK
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
What is the SMILES survey and how many Australians took part in the customer satisfaction poll?
The SMILES survey (Smart Investor League of Exceptional Service) is an annual customer-satisfaction poll run by Smart Investor. This edition surveyed about 1,400 Australians on their experiences across categories like banking, superannuation, insurance, internet and utilities.
Which bank topped the survey for customer service and why did BankWest score so highly?
BankWest was named Australia’s favourite provider with a 72% satisfaction rating. Respondents praised BankWest for old-fashioned manners, fast problem resolution, competitive interest rates, convenient “express” stores with longer hours and mobile banking apps. BankWest is originally from Western Australia and is now owned by the Commonwealth Bank.
How did Australia’s big banks perform in the SMILES customer service rankings?
According to the survey, the largest institutions didn’t top any of the four banking categories this year — the smaller providers generally outscored the big banks. One exception: Westpac Online Investing was voted best online broker.
Which smaller providers did customers rate highly for internet and utilities?
Smaller companies led those categories: Internode was voted best internet provider, and Integral Energy (which services Queensland and New South Wales) was voted best utilities provider.
How did superannuation funds and fund managers fare in customer satisfaction and what drove the change?
Superannuation funds fell 8% in ratings and fund managers dropped 7% on average. The decline was largely driven by poor investment performance during the global financial crisis and ongoing market volatility. Despite that, AustralianSuper topped the super category with a 66% rating vs a 63% average and has responded by freezing administration fees and improving member communication.
What happened to satisfaction levels for mobile phone companies and different types of insurers?
Mobile phone companies were down 5 percentage points to 65% satisfaction, and Vodafone in particular received low marks. Life insurers also fell 5 points to 66%, while general insurers only slipped 3 points and still rated well at 72%. Health insurance averaged just below 70% and fell only slightly.
What service issues annoy customers most, according to the survey?
The top irritants cited by respondents were automated voice systems, waiting more than 10 minutes to be served, inefficient service, poor communication and rudeness. These operational failings drove much of the dissatisfaction across categories.
How can everyday investors use these customer satisfaction results when choosing banks, funds or insurers?
Use the survey as one input alongside fees and performance: look for providers that score well on service and communication (for example BankWest, Internode, Integral Energy and AustralianSuper in this survey), check how funds respond to market stress (fee freezes, member communication), and don’t hesitate to “vote with your feet” and switch to better service if it matters to you.