InvestSMART

Rates may favour Rudd but China is the key to Australia's economy

Interest rates have been kind to Kevin Rudd the campaigner.
By · 27 Jul 2013
By ·
27 Jul 2013
comments Comments
Interest rates have been kind to Kevin Rudd the campaigner. They were going up when he first ran for PM in 2007. That year, the Reserve Bank took the controversial decision to lift rates during the election campaign, delivering an electoral blow to Rudd's opponent, John Howard.

Now, there is a good chance that rates will be cut in the prelude to Rudd's 2013 campaign to levels not seen in 50 years.

There is a strong case for the Reserve to reduce rates when it next meets on August 6. Business confidence is frail, unemployment is creeping higher and there are fresh concerns over China's economic outlook.

The latest inflation figures, released on Wednesday, left the door open for another cut. The underlying rate of inflation in the year to June was 2.4 per cent - in the middle of the Reserve Bank's target range of between 2 and 3 per cent.

"Things are a bit soft at the moment," says HSBC chief economist and former Reserve Bank official Paul Bloxham. "With inflation low, I think we will see the RBA deliver another rate cut as soon as they can."

If Bloxham is right, it will be the eighth cut in interest rates in 21 months.

An August rate cut would hand Rudd a useful economic narrative on the cusp of a tight election campaign. It would be especially valuable in the key electoral battleground of western Sydney, where levels of household debt are high.

Economist Stephen Koukoulas, an economic adviser to Julia Gillard in 2010 and 2011, says Labor has not made enough of the very low level of interest rates. "They didn't take ownership of low interest rates even though we know it's such a sensitive issue and the household sector is still carrying a fair amount of debt. They didn't thump the table about it the way John Howard and Peter Costello did."

Rudd and new Treasurer Chris Bowen are likely to campaign much more aggressively on low interest rates.

"My hunch is they will milk it for all it's worth," Koukoulas says.

But super-low interest rates are a sign of the difficult economic transition under way in Australia as the effects of the mining boom fade. Ideally, other economic drivers such as housing investment and consumer spending will emerge to sustain growth. But there are well-placed fears those alternative growth boosters will not be nearly strong enough to compensate for the minerals boom.

Rudd has already signalled managing this transition will be a key theme of the election campaign. He told the National Press Club earlier this month: "Australian Labor governments know how to manage the great transitions in our economy."

It is likely that economic figures released during the next few months, including gross domestic product and jobs data, will be weak and this could influence debate during the election campaign. They are also likely to underscore the economic challenges awaiting the incoming government.

Economic growth has been below par for more than 18 months, and the jobs market has been slowly deteriorating. Last month, the unemployment rate reached a four-year high of 5.7 per cent, and a survey that tracks consumer expectations of rising unemployment has reached the highest mark since the global financial crisis.

A report on Australia's business outlook by consultancy Deloitte Access Economics this week said "pretty much every sector" of the economy, from mining to governments, are in cost-cutting mode.

"This isn't a recession," the report said. "Coal and iron ore prices would need to fall a lot more for that to happen. Yet it hurts anyway: Australia's annual national income growth peaked at $115 billion in early 2011, but fell to a bare $49 billion in the past year."

Academic economist Ross Garnaut says the "accumulated decline" in Australia's potential economic output is quite large and "will continue to grow on current policy settings".

The Australian dollar's recent fall below parity with the US dollar is good news for export-oriented sectors, including manufacturing, farming, tourism and international education. But Professor Garnaut says the dollar needs to fall much further if a recession is to be avoided.

"If the real depreciation is too little too late, recession and possibly deep recession becomes inevitable, but we are not there yet," he says.

Meanwhile, there is lingering uncertainty about the economic health of Australia's most important trading partner, China. On Wednesday, China reported the slowest pace of manufacturing growth in nearly a year, while other recent economic indicators have been weaker than expected.

Chief economist of the Asian Development Bank Changyong Rhee said last week the whole region would feel the effects of slower Chinese growth.

"The drop in trade and scaling back of investment are part of a more balanced growth path for [China] and the knock-on effect of its slower pace is definitely a concern for the region," he said. "We are also seeing more subdued activity across much of developing Asia."

This followed an International Monetary Fund warning that the slowdown in emerging markets such as China could last longer than expected.

Nobel prize-winning economist Paul Krugman went much further this week when he pronounced: "China is in big trouble.

"We're not talking about some minor setback along the way, but something more fundamental," he wrote in The New York Times. "The country's whole way of doing business, the economic system that has driven three decades of incredible growth, has reached its limits. You could say that the Chinese model is about to hit its Great Wall, and the only question now is just how bad the crash will be."

Garnaut says the inevitable slowing and rebalancing of the Chinese economy will be a major challenge for whoever wins this year's election. He says the incoming government will need to involve the whole Australian community in a national effort "to raise productivity, keep government expenditure within sustainable limits and share sacrifices in an equitable way.

"It will test the cohesion of Australian society and it will test to the limit Australia's political leadership."
Google News
Follow us on Google News
Go to Google News, then click "Follow" button to add us.
Share this article and show your support
Free Membership
Free Membership
InvestSMART
InvestSMART
Keep on reading more articles from InvestSMART. See more articles
Join the conversation
Join the conversation...
There are comments posted so far. Join the conversation, please login or Sign up.

Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…

The article says there is a strong case for an RBA rate cut when it meets on August 6. Underlying inflation was 2.4% in the year to June (inside the RBA’s 2–3% target range), business confidence is frail, unemployment is rising, and economists such as HSBC’s Paul Bloxham expect the RBA to deliver another cut. If it happens, it could be the eighth cut in 21 months, according to the article.

According to the article, an August rate cut would create a useful economic narrative for politicians and be especially valuable in areas with high household debt (the article cites western Sydney). Low rates can ease mortgage costs for indebted households, and economists in the article note that Labor is likely to campaign on the benefits of very low interest rates.

The article reports the underlying inflation rate was 2.4% in the year to June, which sits in the middle of the RBA’s 2–3% target range. Economists quoted in the article say this relatively low inflation leaves the door open for another rate cut, as inflation isn’t running hot enough to rule out easier policy.

The article highlights several risks: the fading mining boom, more than 18 months of below‑par growth, a slowly deteriorating jobs market with unemployment at a four‑year high of 5.7%, widespread corporate cost‑cutting (per Deloitte Access Economics), and a significant slowdown in China that could reduce demand for Australian exports.

The article notes the Australian dollar has fallen below parity with the US dollar, which is positive for export‑oriented sectors — manufacturing, farming, tourism and international education are specifically mentioned. However, economist Ross Garnaut in the article warns the dollar may need to fall further to avoid recessionary pressures.

The article stresses that China is Australia’s most important trading partner. Recent indicators show slower manufacturing growth in China and weaker-than-expected data. Asian Development Bank chief economist Changyong Rhee and the IMF warn slower Chinese growth will have knock‑on effects across the region, and Paul Krugman is quoted as saying China faces more fundamental problems — all of which matter for Australian exporters and the broader economy.

The article reports that economic growth has been below par for over 18 months and the unemployment rate hit 5.7%, a four‑year high. A survey tracking consumer expectations of rising unemployment is at its highest level since the global financial crisis, suggesting weaker consumer confidence and potential pressure on consumer spending.

Per the article, many sectors are in cost‑cutting mode as mining eases — Deloitte Access Economics says “pretty much every sector” from mining to governments is trimming costs. The article also points out that export‑oriented industries such as manufacturing, farming, tourism and international education could benefit from a lower Australian dollar, while hopes that housing investment and consumer spending will fully replace mining‑related growth are uncertain.