No shortage of suitors jostling for Virgin's attention
Luxon was spruiking a tourism deal at the "Toaster" building overlooking Circular Quay, while Hogan was a few hundred metres away at a high-end hotel, briefing investors. On this occasion, they did not manage to catch up.
But Luxon had met Hogan, an Australian who has steered Etihad for almost seven years, for the first time several weeks earlier at an airline conference in Cape Town.
The pair have every reason to be sizing each other up. Besides their code-share agreements, Air New Zealand and Etihad are bedfellows in Virgin Australia. And it is their common shareholdings in Australia's second-largest airline that is again exercising minds.
In the short term, it has become a race to stake out their positions on Virgin's register. So far, Air New Zealand has been quickest to cement a 23 per cent stake (and lobby for approval to buy another 3 per cent), followed by Singapore Airlines at 20 per cent. In their wake, Etihad is doing its utmost to build on its 11 per cent holding.
But it is the long-term game that is sending strategists into overdrive.
Macquarie Equities analysts believe two of the three airline shareholders - or all three - could eventually launch a takeover offer for Virgin. However, the analysts are quick to emphasise the three airlines first need to improve their relationships before a takeover offer could become a reality.
The most likely parties in any deal-making are Air New Zealand and Singapore Airlines.
To date, Etihad has pursued a strategy of buying cornerstone stakes in airlines around the world, including Virgin, Air Berlin and Air Seychelles, as it attempts to narrow the gap with its nemesis, Emirates.
But in considering whether any takeover could get off the ground, industry insiders point to the substantial hurdles, including regulatory ones such as approval from the Foreign Investment Review Board.
Any push would also require a significant increase in capital investment and management time to gain control of an airline in a notoriously volatile sector.
While a takeover raises the potential rewards, it increases significantly the level of risk for predators in an industry littered with carcasses of failed airlines. In the case of Air New Zealand, memories of Ansett's demise still weigh heavily on the minds of its executives more than a decade on.
Even if two of the three airlines could agree to a deal, they would still need buy in from the other carrier left watching on the sidelines because of its blocking stake.
At present, the dance around Virgin is finely balanced.
The three airline shareholders appear willing to give Virgin chief executive John Borghetti time to focus on taking the fight to Qantas, and the difficult task of turning Tigerair Australia into a profitable airline. Takeover possibilities or not, it is shaping up to become an almighty tussle.
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
According to the article, Air New Zealand has cemented a 23% stake (and is lobbying for approval to buy another 3%), Singapore Airlines holds about 20%, and Etihad Airways has around an 11% holding in Virgin Australia.
Macquarie Equities analysts say two or all three airline shareholders (Air New Zealand, Singapore Airlines and Etihad) could eventually launch a takeover offer, but they emphasise this would be a long-term possibility that depends on much better relationships between the carriers before any bid could become realistic.
The article highlights regulatory hurdles such as approval from the Foreign Investment Review Board (FIRB), plus the need for significant increases in capital investment and management time to gain control of an airline in a volatile sector.
Etihad has pursued a strategy of buying cornerstone stakes in several carriers, including Virgin, Air Berlin and Air Seychelles, as part of efforts to narrow the competitive gap with rival carrier Emirates.
The article notes high industry risk: takeovers would increase exposure to a notoriously volatile sector, require large capital injections and active management, and carry the danger of failure — memories of past collapses like Ansett still influence executives' thinking.
In the short term the airlines are racing to stake out positions on Virgin’s register (Air New Zealand quickly secured 23%, Singapore Airlines holds 20% and Etihad 11%) while appearing willing to give CEO John Borghetti time to focus on competing with Qantas and turning Tigerair Australia profitable.
Yes — the article explains that even if two shareholders agreed to a deal they would still need buy‑in from the other carrier holding a blocking stake, so a single significant shareholder could prevent a takeover from proceeding.
Investors should monitor shareholder stake movements (who is increasing or seeking approval to increase holdings), any signs of improving relations between the airline shareholders, FIRB or regulatory developments, announcements about capital commitments, and progress on Virgin’s strategic priorities such as Tigerair Australia’s turnaround and John Borghetti’s competitive plans versus Qantas.

