InvestSMART

Lovelorn miners find job is the pits

Despite the huge wages, mines struggle to attract workers due to the locations and lonely lifestyle, writes Angus Whitley.
By · 3 Sep 2011
By ·
3 Sep 2011
comments Comments
Despite the huge wages, mines struggle to attract workers due to the locations and lonely lifestyle, writes Angus Whitley.

Ten minutes' walk from the country's largest open-pit gold mine, 35-year-old driller Matt Brown swigs a beer in the bar of the Rock Inn Hotel and laments one of the biggest problems of the mining boom: a shortage of girlfriends.

"You get lonely," Brown, who explores for gold and iron ore with Westralian Diamond Drillers in the dust-coated town of Kalgoorlie, 600 kilometres from Perth, says. "Relationships are the hardest thing about mining."

The heartache in places like Kalgoorlie and the Queensland coal town of Glenden, where there are 23 unmarried men in their 40s for each single woman, is a headache for companies such as Rio Tinto which are are trying to attract workers.

The biggest commodities boom since the 1850s gold rush has sapped the supply of Australians willing to adopt Brown's lifestyle, even with wages that are double the national average.

To persuade workers to join, companies offer extras such as seven-hour, round-trip flights to cities every few weeks, satellite phones to keep miners connected with loved ones, counselling services and even flying in families for employees who keep mines going over the Christmas holidays.

"It's a wonderful life for many people, but for many other people there's a crippling isolation," Gervase Greene, a Perth-based spokesman for Rio Tinto's iron-ore operations, said. "You've got to think outside the square to access workers and keep them in the workforce. There's still a labour shortage."

Higher labour expenses are raising expansion costs, Rio Tinto, the world's second-largest mining company, said after reporting its first-half profit last month. The company's workforce more than doubled in five years to 76,894 at the end of 2010. The country's unemployment rate was 5.1 per cent in July, almost half that of the US, Bloomberg data shows.

Rising wages are feeding inflation, forcing the Reserve Bank to keep its benchmark interest rate at 4.75 per cent, the highest in the developed world, even as domestic spending slows.

Miners' wages have risen 33 per cent in the past five years, to $2113 a week, or more than double the national average, according to data released two weeks ago by the Australian Bureau of Statistics. That's almost twice as much as miners in the US, who are paid an average of $1236 a week.

The Reserve Bank said "the widespread increase in cost pressures" was a threat to inflation, in the minutes of last month's meeting.

"It's not just a threat to inflation, it's a threat to business," Nigel Stapledon, a lecturer at the University of NSW's Australian School of Business, said. "What happens in mining feeds through to costs in all sectors."

The difficulty in holding down a relationship is one factor driving demands for further pay rises in mining, Stephen Smyth, a president in the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union, said.

Tim Douglas, a mining engineer with Macmahon Holdings, said his job is incompatible with a long-term relationship. He works eight-day stints at Rio Tinto's Argyle Diamond Mine in the East Kimberley region with six-day breaks in Perth, a 3?-hour flight away.

"You've got to pretty much give up your life," Douglas, 24, who split up with his girlfriend in February, said. "A lot of my friends have been eyeing some quick cash in the mines, but it's not all it's cracked up to be."

That's making it harder for Roger Edwards, the managing director of Acorn Recruitment in Kalgoorlie, to fill vacancies.

He has 120 roles open for electricians, welders, labourers and drillers paying as much as $5000 a week, and just 14 tradesmen in town qualified to do the work, he said. There may be a shortfall of 35,800 tradesmen by 2015 on resources projects, the National Resources Sector Employment Taskforce said in a 2010 report.

"The only thing that can keep us going is getting people from elsewhere," Edwards, who supplies workers for BHP and the nearby Super Pit, owned by Barrick Gold and Newmont Mining, said. "But the fly-in, fly-out workers destroy the community. They're the ones who go crazy. The number of breakups we see is unbelievable."

Kelly Quirke, a BHP spokeswoman, said the company wouldn't comment on what it's doing to attract workers.

A mile from the Super Pit, miners' fluorescent-orange safety shirts glow through the windows of bars along Burt Street, many served by barmaids dressed only in underwear.

Edwards isn't the only one struggling to get workers. Two blocks away, at Langtrees brothel, the manager, who calls herself Dylan Delights, is drafting in staff from as far as Ireland and New Zealand.

"Just come and have some fun and make as much money as you can," she said on the phone to a woman in Tasmania. "What was your name, sweetheart? My name's Dylan. I'm the madam."

Most clients are miners and many are married or in a relationship, Dylan said, sucking on a cigarette. An hour with a girl costs $350 and a prostitute with as many as six customers a night can earn $10,000 a week, Dylan, 23, said.

Some miners turn to the internet to find a partner. Web matchmaker eHarmony.com has identified "love hotspots", with mining towns such as Mount Isa atop the list.

RSVP, Australia's largest online dating service, said 14 per cent more users signed up in the past 12 months, taking its clients to 1.8 million. In Kalgoorlie, the number jumped 76 per cent.

Bernard Salt, the well-known demographer and a partner at KPMG, said the mining boom is exacerbating a history of gender isolation in Australia. The mining industry employed 214,000 workers as of May, government data shows, 86 per cent of them men.

"It's a uniquely Australian issue," Salt, whose books include Man Drought and Other Social Issues of the New Century, said

Women, who a generation ago tended to stay in remoter towns and marry in their early 20s, are adding to the imbalance by moving to cities for work and education, he said.

When they get there, they find a shortage of men. "I've got a bunch of single girlfriends and we're out there looking, but we've been scratching our heads wondering where all the decent men are," Lara Iacusso, a 41-year-old former Deloitte corporate-finance partner, who moved to Sydney from Perth more than three years ago, said.

"It's definitely tough."

Brett Gilbert, a chef at Fortescue Metals Group's Solomon iron ore project, plans to publish a book this year, The Fly-In Fly-Out Bachelor: A FIFO Bachelor's Guide to Success with Women, after overcoming his own depression. "This whole industry is plagued with guys who probably want to be more successful with women," Gilbert said.

At the Rock Inn Hotel, and without a girlfriend after two years in Kalgoorlie, Brown comforts himself with his pay packet. "For a lot of us, it's the money. If you want to work, there's a job here for you."

Google News
Follow us on Google News
Go to Google News, then click "Follow" button to add us.
Share this article and show your support
Free Membership
Free Membership
InvestSMART
InvestSMART
Keep on reading more articles from InvestSMART. See more articles
Join the conversation
Join the conversation...
There are comments posted so far. Join the conversation, please login or Sign up.

Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…

The article says the main problem is location and lifestyle: many mines are remote and the fly-in fly-out (FIFO) life can be lonely and hard on relationships. Even though miners' pay can be more than double the national average, companies still face a labour shortage and must offer extra perks to attract staff.

According to the article, miners' wages rose about 33% over five years to roughly $2,113 a week, which is more than double the national average. The piece also notes U.S. miners earn around $1,236 a week on average for comparison.

FIFO involves workers flying to remote mine sites for blocks of shifts and returning home for breaks. The article describes schedules such as eight-day stints with several days off, and notes FIFO can strain personal relationships, contribute to depression for some workers, and disrupt local communities as many workers don't live permanently in town.

Companies are using incentives like scheduled round-trip flights to cities, satellite phones to keep staff connected with loved ones, counselling services, and sometimes flying in families for holidays. Rio Tinto said employers have to 'think outside the square' to access and keep workers.

The article links rising mining wages to broader cost pressures. Higher labour expenses are raising expansion costs for miners and feeding inflation, which contributed to the Reserve Bank keeping its benchmark interest rate at 4.75% as it monitors widespread cost increases.

The article highlights severe gender imbalances in some towns—Glenden was cited as having 23 unmarried men in their 40s for each single woman—and notes the mining workforce is heavily male (about 86% men among 214,000 workers). Social effects reported include relationship breakdowns, loneliness, and increased use of dating services and other local services.

Yes. The article quotes a Kalgoorlie recruiter with about 120 open roles for electricians, welders, labourers and drillers paying up to $5,000 a week, but only 14 qualified tradesmen in town. A 2010 report cited a possible shortfall of 35,800 tradesmen on resources projects by 2015.

Many miners look to online dating and other services. The article says eHarmony identified mining towns as 'love hotspots' and RSVP saw a 14% increase in users overall and a 76% jump in Kalgoorlie. It also describes some workers using local social venues and, in extreme instances, other paid services to cope with isolation.