Korea needs to pause, take stock, and reinvent itself
As economists scour the earth for clues on which country is next headed for a crash, should they be worrying about South Korea?
An oddly timed question, perhaps, given Korea's resilience compared with its Asian compatriots. Even if the region is not on the verge of a 1997-style meltdown, scary drops in the Indian rupee, Indonesian rupiah, Malaysian ringgit and Thai stocks are fuelling anxieties.
Korea is a rare exception: a current-account surplus equal to 4.9 per cent of gross domestic product, a well-performing won the International Monetary Fund says is undervalued, and expectations for 4 per cent growth in 2014.
In fact, investors who bet against Korea over the last 15 years haven't done very well. In 2008, some wagered that Korea was the national equivalent of Bear Stearns - that, like an investment bank, a bubble in negativity would cause a run on the economy. Two years later, with Europe in a tailspin, short- sellers gambled that Korea would be the next Iceland. Korea confounded both sets of naysayers.
What worries me, though, is that officials in Seoul seem too busy popping champagne to address another crisis, this one domestic and of their own making: a mid-life one.
Korea surely deserves a pat on the back for overhauling an economy that crashed spectacularly in 1997. Efforts to upgrade the banking system and bolster its defences - such as reducing short-term external debt and building up foreign-exchange reserves to a record $US330 billion - are paying off.
As Timothy Moe at Goldman Sachs wrote, worries related to the US Federal Reserve altering its quantitative-easing program "are not likely to impact Korean equities as much" as the rest of Asia.
But Korea's real challenge is one of reinvention: to find a new economic model to replace its previous dependence on exports. For years, Koreans buzzed about catching up to the developed world. Now that they largely have, the question is "what comes next?" If Korea is having the economic equivalent of a midlife crisis, my conversations in Seoul this week suggest it is moving too slowly to address it.
President Park Geun Hye has said she wants to transform Korea into a "creative economy". That sounds like just what a nation sandwiched uncomfortably between high-tech Japan and low-cost China needs. If conservative Korea could become a mecca of innovation and risk-taking, scrappy start-ups and venture-capital buzz would, in theory, create loads of high-paying jobs and increase competitiveness.
Yet try finding a Korean who truly understands how Park intends to shake up Korea Inc in practice. "It's all very vague, and the definitions keep shifting," says Lee Jin-Woo, head of research at NH Investment & Futures Co. "The problem is, no one knows what the president means, or what she is doing."
Park can't just order her people to be more entrepreneurial using slogans and photo opportunities with Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg, who visited Seoul in June. That hasn't worked for Singapore. A real transformation requires clear goals and specific action plans.
One official says Park's "creative economy" campaign is looking a lot like Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's efforts to boost confidence without implementing a single structural reform.
Chaebol reform - or lack thereof - raises another warning flag. Park won last year's election pledging to rein in the family-run conglomerates that suck up all the oxygen in Korea's economy. Reducing their role is central to making Korea more dynamic, but Park's predecessor, Lee Myung-Bak, squandered his term broadening it - five years that Korea didn't have to waste.
A vibrant stable of smaller companies would also make Korea less export-dependent. The chaebol are largely focused on shipping goods overseas, and their outsize role impedes the creation of a thriving services sector. There's far more promise in expanding tourism, financial services, science, healthcare and education than loading ships.
But this week in Seoul came two ominous indications that the chaebol remain supreme. Park met tycoons she is supposedly working to sideline and asked them to increase investment to hasten economic growth. In return, Park promised she would prevent regulations from obstructing their business activities. Well played, tycoons!
Park also announced the government had scrapped a proposal to sell Korea Development Bank, a signal that she plans to use the nation's biggest policy lender to channel more funds to companies. You have to wonder if Korea plans to follow China's banking model, which is now shackled with bad debts run up by indiscriminate lending to favoured enterprises.
For the record, I don't think Korea is headed for its own lost decade.
Koreans have proved time and time again that doubting their tenacity is a sucker's bet. But I heard the topic come up too often in Seoul to ignore the risk. Korea has come much too far to grow complacent now; this is when it needs to act most boldly. Park must work faster to put some flesh on her ideas.
In the meantime, she should resist the urge to pop champagne over a couple of "likes" from the likes of Facebook and Goldman Sachs.
InvestSMART FORUM: Come and meet the team
We're loading up the van and going on tour from April to June, with events on the NSW central & north coast, the QLD mid-north coast and in Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney and Canberra. Come and meet the team and take home simple strategies that you can use to build an investment portfolio to weather any storm. Book your spot here.
Want access to our latest research and new buy ideas?
Start a free 15 day trial and gain access to our research, recommendations and market-beating model portfolios.Sign up for free