Guardian looks for novel entry points into US market
Newshounds have no shortage of resources, particularly on the web. And whether you define news as the latest updates on the Kardashians or the conflict in Syria, enough digital sources abound to satisfy every taste and to feed the incessant demands of social media. So how does a 192-year-old news organisation get people to pay attention to its online edition?
It advertises.
At least that's the plan for a new campaign to promote the venerable British newspaper The Guardian, which starts this week. The campaign hinges on controversial US topics that include women in the military, internet privacy, gun control and the use of condoms in the adult film industry.
Images created by graphic artist Noma Bar are meant to show both sides of each issue, with contents that change depending on your point of view. The images are meant to be shown side by side on footpath billboards in selected cities around the US and online.
To illustrate the topic of women in the military, for example, an image shows an outline of two navy blue tanks and a red helicopter encased in a white dome. "Military Liability", the headline says, above these words: "Women aren't as physically strong as men. We need our best soldiers on the front line."
When the image is flipped on its head, however, the red helicopter becomes red lips; the blue tanks, eyes; and the dome, the outline of a face. "Military Equality", the headline now says. "It takes more than brute strength to win today's wars. We all have the right to fight for our country."
For the ads depicting internet privacy, one image shows a person at a desk with an open laptop and the headline "Keep Out of My Stuff" - but when flipped, the man at the desk turns into a masked face with the headline "Keep Out the Terrorists".
The ads are meant to evoke a response from people who choose to take a side on the issues. "For us it's about telling the story through the editorial lens," says Jennifer Lindenauer, director of marketing and communications at Guardian US, in an interview at the publication's New York office.
"When you look at the debate in this country, at the core of it tends to be the government in our lives versus personal freedoms," said Lindenauer. "It's culture, it's news, it's technology. It allowed us to show the multifaceted areas of coverage that we provide for our readers."
Passers-by who see the footpath billboards will be asked to take a photograph of the ad that represents their point of view and upload the photo to Twitter or Instagram using the hashtag VoiceYourView. A website will collect the votes as they come in and will feature links to The Guardian's coverage of those issues.
Despite editorial successes - most notably its coverage of the phone hacking scandal that led to the closure of Rupert Murdoch's News of the World - The Guardian has had a rocky, albeit short, history in the US. In 2009, it laid off a handful of editors and reporters who had been hired to work on a US-focused website. In 2011, it opened offices in New York and has since hired notable journalists it hopes will attract American readers, including Naomi Wolf.
"Not very many people other than the news cognoscenti know about The Guardian," said Alan Mutter, a lecturer for the Graduate School of Journalism at the University of California, Berkeley, and a former newspaper editor. He added that The Guardian is "very much a new, marginal entrant into an already very busy, very fragmented US media market".
Instead of focusing on advertising, Mutter said, the company should focus on another tried-and-true technique: reporting.
"I would be looking for really big stories, gobsmacking stories that get people to tune in and get people to share that content," he said. "The kind of people they want to attract as customers are not going to stop and do a billboard poll."
The Guardian's website is well behind The Daily Mail, a British publication that has surged ahead in the past few years with headlines laden with celebrity gossip.
According to data from ComScore, the Mail has the largest online newspaper audience in the world, with 54.2 million unique visitors in January 2013.
The Guardian had the fourth-largest international audience that month, with 41.2 million unique visitors. Less than a third (29.7 per cent) of its web traffic comes from readers in the US, while the Mail counts 36.5 per cent of its audience from American readers.
New York Times
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
The Guardian has launched a US advertising campaign to promote its online edition and attract American readers. The campaign uses controversial US issues and eye-catching artwork to draw attention to the publisher's editorial coverage and encourage engagement with its website and social channels.
The campaign highlights polarising US topics such as women in the military, internet privacy, gun control and the use of condoms in the adult film industry to spark debate and show the breadth of The Guardian's coverage.
Graphic artist Noma Bar created images that show opposing viewpoints depending on how you view them — for example a design that reads 'Military Liability' one way and 'Military Equality' upside down, or an internet privacy ad that flips between 'Keep Out of My Stuff' and 'Keep Out the Terrorists'. The dual images are meant to provoke thought and discussion.
Passers-by are encouraged to photograph the footpath billboards and upload the picture to Twitter or Instagram using the hashtag #VoiceYourView. A campaign website will collect those submissions and link to The Guardian's reporting on the featured issues.
The Guardian has had a mixed history in the US — it laid off some US-focused staff in 2009, opened New York offices in 2011 and hired notable journalists like Naomi Wolf. It has had editorial successes such as coverage of the phone hacking scandal, but remains a relatively new and marginal entrant in the busy US media market.
According to ComScore data cited in the article for January 2013, the Daily Mail had about 54.2 million unique visitors while The Guardian had about 41.2 million. Less than a third (29.7%) of The Guardian's web traffic came from US readers versus 36.5% of the Mail's audience.
Media commentators such as Alan Mutter have argued The Guardian should prioritise producing big, attention-grabbing reporting rather than relying mainly on advertising campaigns, suggesting strong investigative stories drive sharing and long-term audience growth.
The Guardian says the campaign is about 'telling the story through the editorial lens' — showing the multifaceted nature of its coverage across culture, news and technology, and encouraging readers to take a side and engage with its journalism.

