It was a year of red dust, red ink and red envelopes. But which business leaders have been naughty and which ones nice? CBD hands out the presents to 2012's big achievers.

It was a year of red dust, red ink and red envelopes. But which business leaders have been naughty and which ones nice? CBD hands out the presents to 2012's big achievers.


Gina Rinehart. From YouTube to the Pilbara, Her Roy Hill Highness was everywhere this year. If she wasn't provoking outrage by contracting Africans willing to work for $2 a day with feckless Aussies who spend all day in the pub, the poetical Pilbara princess was out on the town signing copies of her Little Red Dust Book, Northern Australia and Then Some. Pooping the party only slightly was her wrong bet on the fourth estate, in the shape of stakes in Fairfax Media and the Ten Network.


Nathan Tinkler. Like the Scarlet Pimpernel, they seek him here, they seek him there. However, there are signs the ability of the swashbuckling bogannaire to swoop in at the last moment and save his companies from the judicial guillotine is becoming stretched.

Creditors have already wound up his Mulsanne Resources and companies associated with his thoroughbred stable, Patinack Farm, while the taxman is circling the Hunter Sports Group, the vehicle through which he owns the Newcastle Knights and the Newcastle Jets.

And, of course, running things from Singapore, where readers have spotted Tinkler strolling by the river and applying for membership at the cricket club, must make things more difficult.

Especially when pesky financiers have seized your private jet and helicopter.


Clive Palmer. He said he would run for Parliament against Treasurer Wayne Swan, described the Greens as a CIA-funded plot, started a shipping business, announced plans to build a full-size replica of the Titanic, tried to start a rival soccer league to Frank Lowy's Football Federation Australia, became a national living treasure, was suspended from the LNP before being reinstated and resigning on the same day, got a passing mention in the failed sexual harassment case brought by James Ashby against Speaker Peter Slipper, was interviewed on Lateline from Tahiti wearing a tropical garland, took delivery of a mechanical T-Rex for his dinosaur park, toyed with buying into Fairfax, fought a legal battle with Hyatt Hotels over management of his Coolum Resort, got a speeding ticket, bought Bora Bora resort in Tahiti and the Sea Temple golf course in Port Douglas, said he wants to get drunk and wear a top hat to the Melbourne Cup after becoming governor-general, warned his Chinese business partners that Australia was not a communist country, fought with business partners CITIC over an iron ore mine in the Pilbara, and called for more lenient treatment of asylum seekers.

Phew! But wait. Just a fortnight ago Palmer was named joint secretary-general of something called the World Leadership Alliance, which according to the press release from his flack trumpeting the appointment "will be the major adviser to the G20 Summit" in Brisbane in 2014.

Never heard of the World Leadership Alliance? Palmer is closely involved in the global powwow, which features a troughload of ex-politicians and takes in a couple of other leadership organisations. Indeed, Palmer's company, Mineralogy, registered the trademark back in July.


Qantas boss Alan Joyce and the man who preceded him in the gig, Geoff Dixon. Their days lunching together seem over forever now that they are on opposite sides of the battle for the Flying Kangaroo.


Lachlan Murdoch, whose Ten Network gave his wife, Sarah, a gig hosting a talent show, Everybody Dance Now. It lasted just 10 days.

Lachlan's pick for host of the struggling network's new Breakfast show, Kiwi controversialist Paul Henry, did a little better. That show was canned last month after dismal ratings all year.


James Packer. He quit media in favour of gambling yonks ago, but jumped on the Ten Network register with mate Lachlan. Never mind that the pair of heirs did so poorly as directors of long-ago flop.com One.Tel - this time would surely be different.

Alas, the millionaire mates' media mission is yet to deliver, with the pair's stake shedding value at about the same speed as viewers turned off Everybody Dance Now. Perhaps Slim Jim's new Hollywood venture with director Brett Ratner will be more red carpet than red ink.


Mike Smith. The Asiaphilic ANZ boss was spotted on Google Earth with mysterious red bags and on endless video loop at Hong Kong Airport, while his ATMs kept the good people of Singapore's Orchard Towers, aka the Four Floors of Whores, supplied with ready cash. But it seems the Chevalier de l'Ordre du Merite Agricole is to call Australia home after all: this year he said he was considering becoming a citizen, and pooh-poohed suggestions he would replace the suddenly departed Bob Diamond at British bank Barclays. And, of course, he reiterated his dislike of London.

"If you live in central London you have to speak Russian and have a lot of roubles," he told a business breakfast.


Michael Harmer has plenty to meditate on during his summer holidays. It must have seemed a jolly lark back in April, filing paperwork on behalf of the aforementioned Ashby alleging he had been sexually harassed by the aforementioned Slipper. The lawsuit seemed a headline-grabbing echo of Harmer's efforts on behalf of Kirsty Fraser-Kirk against David Jones chief executive Mark McInnes back in 2010, which resulted in an $850,000 settlement.

The Ashby case brought many jolly japes - sexy texts, a jar of mussels, Slipper's slippery effort sneaking out the back door of the Federal Court - but it's all come rather unglued for the Gandhi-loving Harmer, with the Federal Court's Justice Steven Rares making adverse findings about his conduct as a lawyer and Slipper demanding Harmer's firm pay every cent of his costs.


Solomon Lew. The rag-trading billionaire demonstrated his taste for the courtroom early, entering the year already locked in furious litigation with the ex-partners of two of his children over stakes in a family trust fund worth tens of millions of dollars.

He followed up with a spectacular own goal while seeking to have coverage of the case suppressed: in open court, his own counsel decried the fourth estate for unfairly portraying Sol as a "greedy ogre". Cue fresh headlines.

Then there was the stoush over a pool built on Crown land beside his holiday home in Victorian coastal enclave Mount Eliza, which he was ultimately forced to demolish. Oh, and the US litigation sparked when one of his megayachts, the Maridome, clipped mobile phone billionaire Wendy McGraw's equally grand Calixe in a Florida shipyard, causing more than $500,000 of damage. All in all, a generous patron to practitioners of the world's second-oldest profession.


Geoffrey Edelsten. Can superduper internet arrive quickly enough to meet the web surfing needs of the disgraced former doctor, bankrupt and jailbird? In addition to maintaining his not-at-all creepy and misogynistic "Australia's Worst Journalist" contest website (CBD: winner, 2009), the not-doctor also found the time to hang out at the salubrious sugardaddyforme.com website (where "no communications regarding the exchange of sex for money are permitted"). Happily, he struck up a friendship with American lass Stacey da Silva through the website and lent her $5000.

Sadly, she failed to keep their contact confidential, and the whole thing ended up in court where both earned a kicking from Victorian Supreme Court judge David Beach. "The one piece of evidence that could confidently be accepted from each of them is when each of them said that, in respect of certain matters, the other was being untruthful," Justice Beach said.


Mark Bouris. The reality TV star, BusinessDay columnist and finance guru sacked employees of his struggling tech company TZ Limited in July after it missed out on an Australia Post tender in May. "You're fired," indeed. In other staff woes, his finance outfit, Yellow Brick Road, suspended the mortgage broker Andrew Kaidbay late last month after he admitted lying to the New South Wales Independent Commission Against Corruption to protect Paul Obeid. ICAC is investigating Paul's dad Eddie over allegedly corrupt mining deals worth tens of millions of dollars.

InvestSMART FORUM: Come and meet the team

We're loading up the van and going on tour from April to June, with events on the NSW central & north coast, the QLD mid-north coast and in Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney and Canberra. Come and meet the team and take home simple strategies that you can use to build an investment portfolio to weather any storm. Book your spot here.

Want access to our latest research and new buy ideas?

Start a free 15 day trial and gain access to our research, recommendations and market-beating model portfolios.

Sign up for free

Related Articles