InvestSMART

Wesfarmers shares fall short of their Target

Wesfarmers shares suffered their biggest fall in almost two years after sharply lowering Target's earnings forecast.
By · 18 May 2013
By ·
18 May 2013
comments Comments
Wesfarmers shares suffered their biggest fall in almost two years after sharply lowering Target's earnings forecast.

The retail conglomerate said on Friday that Target's profits had been hit by a late start to winter, the clearing of excess stocks, shoplifting and restructuring costs.

The discount department store is now expected to report earnings before interest and tax for the 2013 financial year of between $140 million and $160 million, more than 40 per cent below the $244 million reported in the previous year.

"I don't think we would be particularly surprised that earnings are weak, but the size of the downgrade is probably a bit more than most of us were expecting," NAB analyst Michael Bush said.

"Target has been struggling for several years, partly a function of the broader consumer environment and some other Target-specific [issues]."

Wesfarmers shares closed 2.87 per cent lower at $42.93.

Managing director Richard Goyder said the earnings were "disappointing" but the retail chain would work on keeping Target competitive and maintaining its brand.

Target has performed poorly compared with its peers Kmart, which is also owned by Wesfarmers, and Big W, and has battled excess inventory and soft consumer sentiment.

Last month, the head of operations at the Coles supermarkets chain, Stuart Machin, replaced Dene Rogers as Target's managing director. Mr Rogers resigned only 18 months after taking on the role.

The Target announcement also pushed other retail stocks lower. The Reject Shop slipped by 3.3 per cent, JB Hi-Fi dropped by 2.9 per cent and Woolworths shrank 0.9 per cent.

The profit downgrade came as Australian Pharmaceutical Industries boss Stephen Roche said he could not see the retail sector improving for at least another two to three years. API has turned its focus away from wholesale drug delivery to its Priceline retail business.

Mr Roche said at an American Chamber of Commerce lunch on Friday that he expected consumer sentiment to remain fragile until or beyond 2015. "I can't see any systemic change in consumer behaviour for at least two to three years, and the consequence of that is ... we've got to learn and be good at operating in a very subdued and weak consumer environment," he said.
Google News
Follow us on Google News
Go to Google News, then click "Follow" button to add us.
Share this article and show your support
Free Membership
Free Membership
InvestSMART
InvestSMART
Keep on reading more articles from InvestSMART. See more articles
Join the conversation
Join the conversation...
There are comments posted so far. Join the conversation, please login or Sign up.

Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…

Wesfarmers shares suffered their biggest fall in almost two years after the group sharply lowered Target's earnings forecast. The downgrade signalled bigger-than-expected problems at Target and the shares closed 2.87% lower at $42.93 on the announcement day.

Wesfarmers said Target is now expected to report earnings before interest and tax (EBIT) of between $140 million and $160 million for the 2013 financial year, more than 40% below the $244 million reported in the previous year.

Wesfarmers cited a late start to the winter season, the need to clear excess stock, shoplifting and restructuring costs as key factors that hit Target's profits. The article also notes Target has battled excess inventory and soft consumer sentiment.

Analysts said the downgrade was larger than many expected. NAB analyst Michael Bush noted that while weak earnings weren't a surprise, the scale of the cut was greater than anticipated. The announcement pushed other retail stocks lower on the day as well.

Yes. The Target profit downgrade also weighed on other retailers: The Reject Shop slipped about 3.3%, JB Hi‑Fi dropped about 2.9%, and Woolworths fell around 0.9% following the news.

Wesfarmers managing director Richard Goyder described the earnings as “disappointing” but said the company would work on keeping Target competitive and maintaining its brand.

According to the article, Target has performed poorly compared with peers such as Kmart (also owned by Wesfarmers) and Big W, with Target specifically struggling with excess inventory and weak consumer demand.

Australian Pharmaceutical Industries boss Stephen Roche said he could not see the retail sector improving for at least another two to three years, and expected consumer sentiment to remain fragile until or beyond 2015. API has shifted more focus to its Priceline retail business as a result.