InvestSMART

Time to rethink 'boring' bonds

bIn times of sharemarket volatility and interest-rate fluctuation, the best thing for your cash is to lend it to the government, writes David Potts.
By · 30 Oct 2011
By ·
30 Oct 2011
comments Comments
bIn times of sharemarket volatility and interest-rate fluctuation, the best thing for your cash is to lend it to the government, writes David Potts.

It's the most unlikely of booms but it's producing double-digit returns, which is saying something.

Especially when the risk is as little as, and arguably even lower than, a term deposit.

There, that should give you a clue.

Give up? All right, the boom is in bonds and boring old government ones at that, not your fancy floating-rate hybrids that are all the rage.

Who'd have thought government debt might be good for something - but there you go.

Bonds are a sort of glorified term deposit you're lending to the government for a guaranteed interest rate, called a coupon.

The difference is that a bond can also be cashed in whenever you like because it trades like a share, though not on the ASX.

What's more, if rates are lower than the coupon on your bond when you sell you'll even make a nice profit.

Aberdeen Asset Management's inflation-linked bond fund returned 12.2 per cent after fees in the year to September 30, according to Morningstar. At the same time, share prices slumped 9 per cent.

And that was with inflation easing slightly.

The reason it did so well was that indexed bonds go as far out as 2030 - and the longer the duration, as they say in the trade, the bigger the price rise when interest rates drop.

Just as the yield from the dividend on a share goes up when the price drops, the same goes for the interest coupon on bonds. And prices have rallied recently as the market has come to expect the Reserve Bank will cut the cash rate.

The rally has even surprised fund managers, which just goes to show bond markets can be as crazy as the sharemarket.

"A 0.25 per cent rate cut has been factored in already," the head of fixed income at Tyndall Investment Management, Roger Bridges, says. "Bonds have overreacted in the last three months."

Foul-weather friends

You could almost say bonds thrive on adversity. Tough times usually result in lower interest rates, which are fodder for a bond boom.

"I see low growth in the world over the next few years, so sitting in cash or equities may not be the best idea," Bridges says.

Remember, if you hang on to them until maturity, it's impossible to lose money on Australian government bonds, something that can't be said for shares.

But what was that about cash? Can't go wrong there, surely, especially when it's in an online account or a term deposit fetching a decent return. Yes, it's safer than anything else, including gold, which can always fall in value, as it has done for long stretches.

Yet if you own any shares at all, blue-chip bonds are better protection than cash. How so? Because in a sharemarket meltdown, bonds will go the other way. Cash, however, just sits there. Worse, the return from it will drop.

The only time bonds and shares tumbled together was in 1994. Even then, bonds did better than shares.

Cash's victory lasted less than a year.

Mind you, the head of fixed interest at Aberdeen Asset Management, Victor Rodriguez, doesn't expect this year's double-digit returns to continue. But, he says, bonds are the best insurance for a share portfolio, especially in a DIY super fund.

"As soon as you're in equities, you want insurance for it," he says. "Term deposits won't rally when equities are falling 30 per cent. And if you move from bonds to cash, you've increased the overall risk of your portfolio." Not that they'll make you rich. The capital gains from bonds are normally modest, though these days even that's something.

A 0.25 per cent drop in rates, for example, would only lift the price of a $100 face-value one-year bond by about 25? and $2.50 for 10 years. So you'll need a lot of them for the return to stack up, which isn't such a problem for the managers of bond funds.

The pity is, having turned their noses up at bonds for so long, investors shell-shocked by the sharemarket are going into the wrong ones.

They're heading for floating-rate bank and corporate hybrids, which, admittedly, come with franking credits, rather than the real thing, paying a guaranteed rate.

Hybrid prices bob about with sharemarket sentiment, the very thing you're trying to escape. And did you know none of the popular bank hybrids even promise to return your cash?

Instead you get shares at a discounted price down the track.

How to buy

It's not easy to get your hands on government bonds. Although they trade in the market like shares, you need a specialist broker such as FIIG Securities and will need to invest a minimum $1000.

There's no brokerage because it gets the bonds for slightly less than it sells them to you. You can also buy bonds direct from the Reserve Bank if you're willing to go through the rigmarole, starting with what it's offering exactly each day.

Once you find that out, you have to fill in a purchase form and an identification reference form "together with certified copies of identity documents" and either take them to your nearest Reserve Bank branch (there are only two - in Sydney and Canberra) or post them. There's also an "administrative charge" of $2.50 per $1000 face value of bonds you buy.

If you want higher-yielding semi-government issues, too bad.

You'll have to buy those through a specialised broker or turn to a bond fund that at least provides instant diversification through different issuers and maturities at wholesale prices.

You can buy units in a bond fund from the manager, a financial adviser or discount sites such as investsmart.com.au. The minimum investment is usually $5000 and, these days, there are no entry or exit fees.

The management fee is usually 0.3 per cent or 0.4 per cent a year.

In the bond market it's not who you know but how much you have that counts, so fund managers also get first dibs at corporate issues that aren't available to mum-and-dad investors.

If you have a spare $100,000, FIIG Securities has 2020 issues, such as Telstra with a yield of 6.7 per cent a year, Stockland at 6.9 per cent and Sydney Airports at almost 8 per cent, available.

Shorter-dated bonds on offer include Leighton Holdings, yielding 7 per cent and maturing in 2014, and Mirvac at 7 per cent, maturing in 2016.

The pick of them, though, would have to be the 2014 bond from Rabobank, one of the few banks in the world that has a triple A rating. It's yielding almost 9 per cent a year.

The catch is you have to be a wholesale investor to get hold of one. And that's defined as someone who has at least $2.5 million in assets and is earning $250,000 a year.

See, money talking again.

Inflation-busting accounts key to future security

DESIGNER term deposits are the new black for pension-paying DIY super funds.

Some banks will let you set whatever term you want, link the return to inflation and mix and match between floating and fixed rates.

And how about having some of your capital returned with the interest rate?

The catch is you need to invest at least $100,000, no big hurdle for DIY super funds frantically trying to preserve their capital and earn a decent return. Westpac is the most amenable, in effect turning a term deposit into a government-guaranteed annuity without the fees, commissions and rigidity.

NAB also lets big savers and super funds select their own term as well as fixed and floating rate periods.

But it's Westpac's inflation-fighting retirement deposits that are a godsend for DIY super funds.

One version, called CPI Plus, pays a fixed rate plus whatever the inflation rate is. Since many super funds already have a CPI-plus target, this does the work for them.

For example, recently Westpac's 10-year CPI Plus deposit was paying 6.26 per cent a year based on the fixed margin of 3.51 per cent and an inflation rate of 2.75 per cent.

If inflation were to climb to, say, 5 per cent one year, the return would be 8.51 per cent.

The margin changes frequently but, just like ordinary term deposits, once you sign up, it is fixed. In fact at one point it was 4.5 per cent and since the Future Fund has a CPI-plus 4.5 per cent target, it could have stocked up on Westpac deposits that day and shut up shop.

"The average self-managed super fund in the last 12 years returned 0.1 per cent over the CPI according to APRA," the executive director of global markets at Westpac, David van Ryn, says.

Because the deposits qualify for the government guarantee on the first $250,000, they're as risk-free as a government bond.

The bank's alternative inflation-linked deposits have a base rate that increases by whatever the quarterly CPI is.

So for a 10-year deposit, based on a 2.75 per cent inflation rate, the annual return would be 7.34 per cent.

Not worried about inflation? Westpac has other designs that might appeal. The Coupon Select Deposit might interest sir or madam because you can fix, float or both. Last week a three-year with a two-year floating term was paying 6.84 per cent a year.

Or how about the Range Accrual where you can take a punt on interest rates by selecting a range and, if you hit the target, the banks pays a bonus? "You can do a portfolio of interest rates of short, medium and long terms, some fixed and some floating and inflation linked. They're all under a government guarantee," van Ryn says, adding the bank's longest-dated deposit so far is for 23 years.

The retirement deposits are ideal for tailoring cash flow in the draw-down stage of a DIY super fund, which doesn't pay tax, says Brisbane-based financial adviser Stephen Furness, head of investment of MGD Wealth.

"Retirees can't wait for the sharemarket to recover," he says. You don't want cash flow to be dependent on equities, which should be left as a long-term investment."

The retirement deposits can match liabilities with cash requirements. "Our clients don't care about the interest rate so long as it's guaranteed and outside the volatility of the sharemarket," he says. "This is a really good option as part of an investment strategy."

Google News
Follow us on Google News
Go to Google News, then click "Follow" button to add us.
Share this article and show your support
Free Membership
Free Membership
InvestSMART
InvestSMART
Keep on reading more articles from InvestSMART. See more articles
Join the conversation
Join the conversation...
There are comments posted so far. Join the conversation, please login or Sign up.

Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…

Australian government bonds are loans you make to the government in exchange for a guaranteed interest payment (a coupon). Like a term deposit they pay a fixed return, but bonds trade in a market so you can sell them before maturity and potentially make a capital gain if market interest rates fall. The article notes that if you hold an Australian government bond to maturity you won’t lose capital, making them as safe as term deposits but with the added potential upside from market price moves.

Bonds have rallied partly because markets expect the Reserve Bank to cut the cash rate; when interest rates fall, existing bonds with higher coupons become more valuable. Duration is a measure of how sensitive a bond’s price is to interest-rate changes: the longer the duration (longer-dated bonds), the bigger the price rise when rates drop. That’s why long-duration and inflation-indexed bonds delivered strong returns when rates eased.

Inflation-linked bonds (indexed bonds) adjust payments for inflation, protecting real returns. According to the article, Aberdeen Asset Management’s inflation-linked bond fund returned 12.2% after fees in the year to September 30, while share prices fell about 9% in the same period — an example of how these bonds can outperform equities during market stress.

You can buy government bonds through specialist brokers such as FIIG Securities (the article says a typical minimum is $1,000), or buy directly from the Reserve Bank — but the RBA route requires paperwork (purchase and ID forms, certified ID) and visiting or posting to one of only two branches (Sydney and Canberra) and paying an administrative charge (noted as $2.50 per $1,000 face value). Because of these practical hurdles, many retail investors use bond funds or specialist brokers.

Bond funds offer instant diversification across issuers and maturities and are easier to access for most investors. The article notes you can buy units from a manager, adviser or discount sites like InvestSmart, with typical minimums around $5,000 and management fees commonly around 0.3–0.4% a year. Bond funds can access wholesale pricing and issues that individual retail investors can’t easily buy.

The article warns that popular floating-rate bank and corporate hybrids are not the same as government bonds. Hybrids move with sharemarket sentiment, can be volatile, and many bank hybrids don’t promise to return your cash — sometimes converting to shares instead. For investors seeking guaranteed interest and lower correlation with equities, government bonds or government-guaranteed deposits are described as the "real thing."

Westpac offers ‘CPI Plus’ and other retirement-style deposits that link returns to inflation or combine fixed and floating periods. The article gives an example of a 10‑year CPI Plus paying about 6.26% (3.51% fixed margin + 2.75% inflation) at the time. These deposits qualify for the government guarantee on the first $250,000 and are recommended as a way for DIY super funds to match cashflow needs and preserve capital without exposure to sharemarket volatility.

Bonds typically move in the opposite direction to shares during market stress, so holding blue‑chip government or high‑quality bonds can protect a share portfolio — the article calls them the best insurance for equities, especially in DIY super funds. Key risks include interest-rate risk (bond prices fall if rates rise) and credit risk for corporate issues. However, the piece notes that holding Australian government bonds to maturity protects your capital, and fund managers emphasize bonds’ role as downside protection rather than a route to big capital gains.