BANK stocks generally underperform the market from November to March. The reasoning can be sheeted home to when bank dividends are paid.
Once Westpac, ANZ and NAB go ex-dividend in the first half of November, investors go elsewhere looking for returns, with the big miners the obvious target.
This trend has already started to unfurl, with BHP and Rio Tinto finding a bottom and heading north over the past month or so.
If you are hooked on bank dividends and want to have an exposure over summer, then the recent profit results all point to hiding out in Westpac.
NAB is the cheapest of the big four but continues to battle problems in the UK. ANZ's balance sheet and capital positioning are strong but investors need to be wary of its desire to drive further into Asia. Meanwhile, CBA is relatively expensive and won't garner too much excitement until the new year in preparation for its result and dividend in February.
Westpac beat market expectations on its profit result. More importantly, the company will sale into Basel III on January 1 with more than sufficient tier 1 capital.
We have mentioned previously the big banks in a low-growth environment have been able to flex considerable muscle and maintain margins and grow capital. Westpac is leading the charge and at this week's result refused to rule out active capital management in 2013.
This could come in the form of special dividends or a buyback of stock. With a payout ratio of 65 per cent once the dividend reinvestment plan is taken into account, it is quite conceivable Westpac could pay $1.74 in dividends in 2013, plus a special of between 20? and 30? a share. This scenario puts the stock on a fully franked yield of between 7.5 and 8 per cent, meaning the stock could easily trade close to $30 a share.
Capilano Honey (CZZ)
QUEENSLAND-BASED Capilano Honey only listed on the ASX in July after a stint on the Bendigo Exchange. Since then the company's share register has changed dramatically, with Saleslink Australasia grabbing 19.9 per cent.
Saleslink provides food and beverage companies with sales management services in dealing with large retailers.
Even though it is not an investment company, Saleslink has a history of taking minority ownership stakes in smaller retail food brands that it works for.
It seems unlikely that Saleslink will look to make a full takeover bid for Capilano, but is looking to have a representative, Bob Newey, join the board at the coming annual meeting.
No doubt Saleslink believes Capilano is an outstanding brand, with almost 50 per cent of Australia's $110 million honey industry. The brand would make a neat addition to a larger food group.
Capilano has a market capitalisation of $19 million and debt of $13 million. This values the group on an earnings before interest and tax multiple of 6.5 times. Capilano spent heavily on stock and equipment in 2012 and should produce strong free-cash flow in 2013 allowing it to cut debt levels and pay a dividend.
Infomedia (IFM)
A STOCK that has been out to pasture for a decade is Infomedia, an online publisher of car parts and prices.
The company went public in the tech boom of 2000, hitting a high of $2.65. Over the next 12 years the price slowly sank back to 17?. In recent months, the stock has sprung back to life, climbing to 38?.
The company has reintroduced itself to the market, following a big overhaul of the cost base and its suite of products.
Infomedia has forecast a profit of $8 million to $9 million for the year to June 2013, putting it on a price-earnings multiple of 12.5 times forward earnings.
While this is not cheap in the market, the company generates a return on equity of about 23 per cent, and the balance sheet has net cash, a good sign for a small company. It has experienced flat revenue for several years, battling a strong dollar. If the dollar stays steady or heads down, this could create a tailwind.
There are rumours that a big shareholder is preparing to sell down its stake, possibly providing an entry point into the stock.
matthewjkidman@gmail.com
The Age does not take responsibility for any stock tips.
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
Why do bank stocks often underperform between November and March and how does that affect dividend investors?
Bank stocks tend to underperform from November to March because the big banks (Westpac, ANZ and NAB) go ex‑dividend in the first half of November. After that payout date many investors rotate out of banks and into other sectors—particularly the big miners—seeking returns. For dividend investors this calendar effect is important to factor into timing and portfolio exposure over the summer months.
Is Westpac a good summer dividend pick after its recent profit result?
Westpac beat market expectations on its profit result and will meet Basel III capital requirements on January 1 with more than sufficient tier 1 capital. Management didn’t rule out active capital management in 2013 (special dividends or buybacks). Using a payout ratio of about 65% after the DRP, the article suggests a conceivable ordinary dividend of around $1.74 in 2013 plus a possible special dividend of roughly 20–30 cents, which could translate to a fully franked yield in the 7.5–8% range. That combination makes Westpac an attractive dividend exposure for summer, while still warranting usual investor caution.
How do NAB, ANZ and CBA compare as dividend or value choices right now?
According to the article: NAB looks cheapest of the big four but is still battling issues in the UK; ANZ has a strong balance sheet and capital position but carries execution and risk considerations as it pursues further growth in Asia; and CBA is relatively expensive and may be quiet until the new year as investors await its result and dividend around February. Each bank has different trade‑offs between valuation, growth risk and dividend prospects.
Are miners like BHP and Rio Tinto influencing investor flows away from banks?
Yes. The article notes that once banks go ex‑dividend investors often shift capital into sectors such as the big miners. Recent market action showed BHP and Rio Tinto finding a bottom and moving higher over the past month, illustrating that miners can attract investor interest once bank dividend dates pass.
What should investors know about Capilano Honey (CZZ) after its ASX listing?
Capilano listed on the ASX in July and has seen a significant shareholder change with Saleslink Australasia taking a 19.9% stake. Saleslink is likely to seek board representation rather than a full takeover. Capilano controls nearly half of Australia’s roughly $110 million honey market. The company has a market capitalisation around $19 million and $13 million of debt, valuing it at about 6.5 times EBITDA. After heavy spending on stock and equipment in 2012, Capilano is expected to generate strong free cash flow in 2013, which should allow it to reduce debt and potentially pay a dividend—facts investors should weigh against small‑company risks.
What are the key investment considerations for Infomedia (IFM) following its turnaround?
Infomedia, an online publisher of car parts and pricing, has restructured costs and its product suite and has seen a recent rebound in the share price. Management forecasts a profit of $8–9 million for the year to June 2013, implying about a 12.5x forward price‑earnings ratio. The company reports roughly a 23% return on equity and a net cash balance sheet. Revenue has been flat in recent years due to a strong currency, so a steady or weaker dollar could be a tailwind. There are also rumours a large shareholder may sell down, which could present an entry opportunity but also adds volatility.
How does Westpac’s compliance with Basel III affect the safety of its dividends?
The article states Westpac will enter under Basel III rules on January 1 with more than sufficient tier 1 capital. That stronger capital position gives the bank flexibility for capital management (including dividends, specials or buybacks) and provides investors more comfort about dividend sustainability—although any dividend outlook still depends on future profits, payout policy and regulatory guidance.
What risks should everyday investors watch when considering the stocks mentioned in the article?
Key risks highlighted include seasonal rotation away from banks after ex‑dividend dates, country‑specific problems (for example NAB’s UK issues), strategic risks (ANZ’s Asian expansion), and valuation risk (CBA being relatively expensive). For small caps like Capilano and Infomedia, watch balance‑sheet leverage, recent heavy capital spending, reliance on cash flow recovery, currency sensitivity, and the potential impact of major shareholder sales. These factors can affect dividend prospects, share price volatility and timing of any investment.