Struggling brokers signal market bottom

A great game for stockbrokers is to look back at the top and bottom of the market with faultless wisdom and identify events that were in hindsight flashing "Top!" or "Bottom!" but were invisible to us at the time.

A great game for stockbrokers is to look back at the top and bottom of the market with faultless wisdom and identify events that were in hindsight flashing "Top!" or "Bottom!" but were invisible to us at the time.

In 1987, my first wife and I were working at the same broking house. We were '80s stockbrokers earning a small fortune between us and the broker we worked for announced that it was offering all its staff a subsidised mortgage rate on three times your salary.

We bought a double-thatched cottage dating from the 16th century in Henham, a quaint English village up the M1, for #230,000, 5 per cent down with a 95 per cent mortgage at 8 per cent a year subsidised to 6 per cent, and in doing so moved out of London where we had grown up. It was the top. Two years later we were paying 17 per cent, the property market had bombed and we were divorced. (The house is now selling for #630,000).

On the divorce front by the way (and a lesson to us all), one of my mate's wives explained moving out to the country by taking me into her pantry. There was a map of London on a cork board and a few hundred little blue pins stuck in wherever one of their friends lived. At the point of maximum density was one yellow pin.

"That's where we live," she said, "and that's why we chose to live here. You on the other hand, did this." She took the yellow pin out of the board, opened the top window and tossed it out with all her might. "No wonder you're divorced," she said.

It's a great lesson for any of you thinking of a sea change retirement in some far-off land, because what really matters is not where you live but whether your mates are there to meet you for a drink, have a game of golf and a chat. Without that you only have each other. God forbid!

Moving on with the tops and bottoms. In the tech boom in 2000, I remember a morning meeting when one of the partners stopped an analyst midflight and said to us: "I have just looked at the commission numbers for the month. Some of you have had

record months. I'd just like to say that in all my years of stockbroking, it has never, ever looked any better than this."

The day before I had done $11,000 of commission in one day and it hadn't gone past me that if I could keep that up I would be doing $2.75 million a year and taking home $1.23 million. It was the very top and the start of the tech wreck.

I used to work for, and own shares in, Tolhurst Noall, a listed stockbroker. In 2007, after 150 years of stockbroking, it decided to spend millions of dollars on investment banking businesses, changed to Tolhurst Limited and started calling itself a "leading independent investment bank". It was the top for the market and the top for them.

By early 2009 this leading independent investment bank had fallen from 54? to under 1?, sold its best assets at a bargain price and sent the value of my shares and those of many other employees close to oblivion.

Other signs of the top of the market included the broker Wilson HTM listing at 200? just before the GFC, in June 2007 and brokers Bell Financial Group and Austock listing at 200? in December 2007. Just over a year after listing, Wilson HTM hit 18?, Bell Financial Group was 37? and Austock, 15?. Who says brokers can't time the market? And fund managers can do it, too. Platinum Asset Management listed in May 2007, hit 911? and was 260? a year later.

So what about the market now? Austock has been plucked from oblivion by the broker, Intersuisse, and is now called Octa Phillip. Bell Financial is back to within a whisker of its all-time low. Baillieu's says its the toughest market since the 1960s and, if you needed any more convincing that we are close to the bottom, Wilson HTM is thinking of delisting with an $8-million loss on the cards for this year. A broker delisting. Surely a sign.

When our lack of confidence at the bottom matches our overconfidence at the top, that's when you buy.

Marcus Padley is a stockbroker with Patersons Securities and the author of the stockmarket newsletter, Marcus Today. His views do not necessarily reflect the views of Patersons.

InvestSMART FORUM: Come and meet the team

We're loading up the van and going on tour from April to June, with events on the NSW central & north coast, the QLD mid-north coast and in Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney and Canberra. Come and meet the team and take home simple strategies that you can use to build an investment portfolio to weather any storm. Book your spot here.

Want access to our latest research and new buy ideas?

Start a free 15 day trial and gain access to our research, recommendations and market-beating model portfolios.

Sign up for free

Related Articles