InvestSMART

Software sums it up

Tools ain't tools when it comes to complying with superannuation law.
By · 14 Nov 2012
By ·
14 Nov 2012
comments Comments
Tools ain't tools when it comes to complying with superannuation law.

Dismal superannuation returns and a renewed focus on costs have pushed more investors to start their own self-managed super funds, but technology is not keeping pace.

The complexity of the super system and onerous reporting requirements force all but the most diehard DIY investors to pay accountants, financial planners, auditors and fund administration services for help.

While people may feel they can do a better job of managing their investments than the professionals, they often lack the portfolio-management software and accounting tools to do so cheaply and effectively.

That leaves a big gap in the market between the tooled-up professionals and motivated individuals wrestling with spreadsheets in their home office.

One new market entrant is trying to break the stranglehold of high-fee-charging professionals with a free cloud-based, crowd-sourced portfolio-management service aimed squarely at individuals managing their own super (see story, right).

While internet-based solutions are making inroads, the head of the Australian Investors Association's IT committee, Graeme Bottrill, says most of the association's members still use spreadsheets.

"I give my accountant an Excel spreadsheet, with revenue, expenses, asset registers for shares, bonds [and] fixed interest all grouped, purchases and sales. I've not found another piece of commercial software that does what I want to do," he says.

"You can pay $1000 to about $7000 to service providers to do it for you. It's not about cost for me - I like doing it myself."

Investors without the skills to develop their own bespoke software are forced to take a patchwork approach. Share investors can track and manage their portfolio using free trading platforms offered by online brokers, such as CommSec and E*Trade.

You can buy portfolio-management software, but most is not designed for self-managed funds and few can handle multiple asset classes. In the shares camp, MAUS Stockmarket Plus ($299) handles shares, options, warrants, managed funds and contracts for difference.

Grant Abbott, of SMSF Strategies, says portfolio-tracking software is helpful, especially in the light of new regulations requiring self-managed funds to have all investments at market value when starting a pension.

Abbott, who is primarily a property investor, says most of the software that tracks property portfolios has to be paid for. He uses realestate.investar.com.au at a cost of $249 a month.

Self-managed funds need to manage pensions and tax and track assets in multiple accounts with taxable and non-taxable revenue. Often there is more than one member, and each person may have separate accumulation and pension accounts that are taxed differently.

"There's a large gap in the market for people who want to do it all themselves," the managing director of accounting-software group BGL Australia, Ron Lesh, says. BGL provides accounting software for 75 per cent of Australia's self-managed super funds, including more than 1000 individual trustees. Lesh says the typical customer is a former accountant or engineer.

Using BGL's Simple Fund package, trustees can produce a paper tax return with everything calculated for them. The product costs $649 in the first year, which includes training and support, and $431 in subsequent years. All that's left to pay for is an audit. Simple Ledger ($275) is designed for people with investments outside super.

Both of these products feature double-entry accounting and can handle shares, property, fixed interest and other investments.

Another provider of accounting software, OneVue, offers its professional portfolio-management platform to individuals through intermediaries, including the Australian Medical Association and the Australian SMSF Members Association.

Between these high-end products and the likes of CommSec, there is a lot of blue sky for entrepreneurs with low-cost portfolio-management solutions for committed investors.

Cloud pleaser

A new kid on the block, Mclowd.com, has launched a free portfolio-management service based on the Google business model. Founder Ashley Porter says he is able to offer the service free, thanks to a combination of cloud technology and crowd sourcing.

Mclowd.com allows self-managed super funds to manage all their investments, liabilities, income and expenses. It will also generate year-end reports for accountants and tax compliance.

The site was given a soft launch two months ago to get feedback from users and aims to be fully functional early next year with the ability to handle multi-member funds. Until then, Porter says a single-member fund with a basic asset profile could start using the service today.

"Cloud computing has changed the rules of the game," Porter says. "We can put our software in the cloud and give it away for free because it costs us nothing."

The site also includes a directory of accountants and other service providers that pay for listing. Because the service is internet-based, rates are typically well below those charged by financial services firms with office space in metropolitan areas.

"In the past, you put an ad in the paper and hired someone to get a job done," Porter says. "In the future, work will be distributed around the world based on the lowest cost. This is already very common in IT but not in financial services.

"We are disaggregating the marketplace using a free accounting platform alongside a crowd-sourced services marketplace."

Google News
Follow us on Google News
Go to Google News, then click "Follow" button to add us.
Share this article and show your support
Free Membership
Free Membership
InvestSMART
InvestSMART
Keep on reading more articles from InvestSMART. See more articles
Join the conversation
Join the conversation...
There are comments posted so far. Join the conversation, please login or Sign up.

Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…

Many self-managed super fund (SMSF) trustees still use Excel because the super system is complex and commercial software often doesn’t match their needs. The article quotes Graeme Bottrill of the Australian Investors Association saying he couldn’t find commercial software that did what he wanted, so he gives his accountant a customised spreadsheet. In short, gaps in functionality for multi-asset SMSFs and the cost or complexity of professional tools push some investors back to spreadsheets.

There are several categories: free broker trading platforms for share tracking (for example CommSec and E*Trade); share-focused products such as MAUS Stockmarket Plus; property-tracking services like realestate.investar.com.au; full accounting packages for SMSFs such as BGL’s Simple Fund and Simple Ledger; professional portfolio platforms offered via intermediaries from providers like OneVue; and new cloud, crowd‑sourced services such as Mclowd.com.

Prices vary widely. The article lists MAUS Stockmarket Plus at about $299, realestate.investar at about $249 a month, BGL’s Simple Fund costing $649 in the first year (including training and support) and $431 in subsequent years, and BGL’s Simple Ledger at $275. Mclowd.com is positioned as a free cloud-based option in soft launch.

Yes. The article notes new regulations require SMSF investments to be at market value when starting a pension, and portfolio-tracking software can help manage that. BGL’s Simple Fund can produce a paper tax return with calculations done for trustees, and services like Mclowd say they will generate year‑end reports for accountants and tax compliance.

Mclowd.com is a new cloud-based, crowd-sourced portfolio-management service that aims to be free. Founder Ashley Porter says it lets SMSFs manage investments, liabilities, income and expenses and generate year‑end reports. It had a soft launch and is currently suitable for single‑member funds with a basic asset profile, with plans to support multi‑member funds early next year. The site also hosts a paid directory of accountants and service providers.

BGL supplies accounting software to around 75% of Australia’s SMSFs, including more than 1,000 individual trustees. Its Simple Fund package features double‑entry accounting, can handle shares, property and fixed interest, and produces tax paperwork for trustees. BGL’s typical customer is often a former accountant or engineer who wants more control over administration.

For simple share portfolios, free trading platforms from online brokers such as CommSec and E*Trade can handle tracking and management. However, most broker tools aren’t designed to deal with SMSF accounting, multi‑asset holdings, tax differences between accumulation and pension accounts, or the reporting obligations of multi‑member funds—so many trustees still need specialist SMSF software or accountant support for full compliance.

Yes. The article highlights a market gap between high‑end professional software and DIY spreadsheet users. Many committed individual trustees want affordable, easy-to-use portfolio management that handles multiple asset classes and SMSF tax issues. Cloud computing and crowd‑sourced business models (as used by Mclowd) are lowering costs and creating room for entrepreneurs to build low‑cost SMSF solutions.