Small shareholders fear for their Careers

The former Takeovers Panel member Trevor Rowe has found himself in the middle of his first shareholder kerfuffle since the melodramatic listing in 2008 of BrisConnections, the toll-road company he chairs.

The former Takeovers Panel member Trevor Rowe has found himself in the middle of his first shareholder kerfuffle since the melodramatic listing in 2008 of BrisConnections, the toll-road company he chairs.

Investors in the Rowe-chaired unlisted public company Careers Australia, which pulled its plans to list on the ASX last year, are questioning the tactics being used by the company's largest shareholder in order to lift its stake.

In a matter taken to the Takeovers Panel last week, shareholders have sought to block the private equity group White Cloud Capital pushing ahead with its unorthodox 66? a share offer, which is conditional on the company's shareholders being lowered from 80 to less than 50.

"The applicants submit, among other things, that White Cloud/Cirrus have intentionally undertaken a strategy of reducing the number of Careers Australia shareholders to below 50 for the purposes of avoiding the requirements of Chapter 6 of the Corporations Act 2001," a statement from the panel said.

There have also been claims that White Cloud, which now has a 45.3 per cent stake after converting some notes last year, has only selectively announced its offer to smaller shareholders.

It has been left up to shareholders to take the matter to the panel, with the deal appearing to have the blessings of the Rowe-chaired Career Australia board.

White Cloud's nominees on the Career Australia board include the former Allco Finance Group director who chaired the Airline Partners Australia private equity consortium and its failed $11.1 billion bid for Qantas, Bob Mansfield.


Meanwhile, one of the aircraft leasing whiz-kids behind the failed APA bid for Qantas, the 38-year-old ex-Macquarie and Allco banker Greg Woolley, has also hit some turbulence of his own.

Shareholders in the Real Estate Capital Partners USA Property Trust are up in arms over the trust's plans to make Woolley's private company Frost Holdings the sole underwriter of the group's heavily-discounted 0.98 for 1 ($20 million) renounceable rights issue. This could potentially see Woolley, who also once managed the investments of Melbourne's billionaire Liberman family, lift his stake from 19.8 per cent to 59 per cent.

Yesterday, the responsible entity of the fund, The Trust Company, was handed a rival proposal from the advisors Moelis that would allow the other substantial shareholders (including the Intelligent Investor, Regal Funds Management and Acorn Capital) to also participate as underwriters.

The offer is priced at 40? a share, a 61 per cent discount to the former Mariner managed fund's net tangible asset backing after the raising.

"Our proposal is that we put an alternative underwriting proposal forward whereas no shareholder will go above 20 per cent of the trust and that no one will gain control by stealth," the chief investment officer at the Intelligent Investor, Steve Johnson, said.

The responsible entity was sticking to its guns late yesterday. The Trust Company issued a notice saying it would press on with its plans. Last night, it is believed the matter was taken to the Takeovers Panel.


The former Australian Securities and Investments Commission chairman Tony D'Aloisio (aka Mr D) was toasted yesterday for his winemaking skills when he was appointed the next president of the Winemakers' Federation of Australia.

Mr D, who bought his Oakridge winery in the Yarra Valley just months after he become ASIC chairman in December 2007, said in a statement he was "looking forward with the [federation] board and CEO to deal with the key challenges which confront winemakers and this industry, an industry which is so important for Australia for jobs and export earnings".

The details of Mr D and his wife Ilana Atlas's purchase of the Oakridge winery from the failed wine company Evans & Tate were never publicly disclosed.

This is because, without any involvement by Mr D, ASIC granted a special exemption to financial reporting requested by Ferrier Hodgson, which at the time was Evans & Tate's administrator.

That exemption was granted just 39 days after administrators were appointed on August 21, 2007, and less than three months before the Oakridge winery was sold to Mr D.

Got a tip?

InvestSMART FORUM: Come and meet the team

We're loading up the van and going on tour from April to June, with events on the NSW central & north coast, the QLD mid-north coast and in Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney and Canberra. Come and meet the team and take home simple strategies that you can use to build an investment portfolio to weather any storm. Book your spot here.

Want access to our latest research and new buy ideas?

Start a free 15 day trial and gain access to our research, recommendations and market-beating model portfolios.

Sign up for free

Related Articles