'Shaggers' crank up the heat on Planet Platinum
As they filed into a dim, red-walled room decorated with shaded chandeliers, wood panelling and pictures of scantily clad women, shareholders in the King Street club's owner, Planet Platinum, were confronted with the news that the company had been suspended from the stock exchange - again.
Minority shareholders, who have formed a shareholder action group called the "Shaggers", used the annual meeting to deliver some of their own bad news to the company's controlling shareholder, John Trimble.
They overwhelmingly voted down the remuneration report, earning Planet Platinum a second strike and forcing a spill of the board at a meeting within 90 days.
Mr Trimble will be allowed to vote his 80 per cent of the company at that meeting, so the spill will almost certainly fail.
And there is not much of a board to spill. Planet Platinum was suspended from the stock exchange on Friday because ASX rules require three directors and one, Nick Pitliangas, resigned from the board the previous day, leaving the company with only Mr Trimble and former St Kilda mayor John Callanan.
The company, which is also the landlord of the Daily Planet brothel in Elsternwick, resumed ASX trade just last month, after being suspended for four months, when it filed an overdue financial report.
Those finances also gave little cheer to shareholders and management.
Profit dived 74 per cent in the six months to the end of December, to just $63,000, and auditor Melanie Leydin raised doubts the business was a going concern.
But Mr Trimble, who is the nephew of the late crime figure Robert Trimbole and Planet Platinum's chairman and chief executive, refused to wilt at Friday's meeting despite the heat, the angry shareholders and the bad financial news.
He said the company had "another horrid year", thanks to a long-running stoush with Victoria Police. The club's liquor licence was revoked in May 2011, but the decision was overturned by the Victorian Supreme Court two months later.
"We've taken a hell of a slam ... but we're back on track," he told shareholders.
"The past three years have been chaotic nonsense - not from a business perspective, from outside avenues."
A consistent theme of Shaggers' questioning was a $2.6 million loan, owed by Mr Trimble's private company Metropolis City Promotions and secured against his personal assets.
Did the board give permission to refinance the loan when Mr Trimble's company Clover Dale, dipped into insolvency in 2011?
"I dunno," Mr Trimble said. "Did we? Nope."
Shareholders put pressure on Mr Callanan to call in the loan, which was first made in 2003 so that Mr Trimble could pay out the mortgage over the Daily Planet and which has been repeatedly extended until it now falls due in 2014.
"The only way we're going to get it paid back is to pay a dividend," Mr Trimble said.
What are the prospects of a dividend?
"There's no prospect of a dividend."
In a small victory for the Shaggers, Mr Callanan agreed to review the loan's due date at the next board meeting.
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
Planet Platinum was suspended because it no longer met ASX rules requiring at least three directors after director Nick Pitliangas resigned, leaving only chairman John Trimble and director John Callanan on the board. The company had also been suspended previously and only resumed trading last month after filing an overdue financial report.
Shareholders overwhelmingly voted down the remuneration report, giving Planet Platinum a 'second strike.' That triggers a requirement for a spill resolution — a vote to re-elect the board — to be held within 90 days. However, the company's controlling shareholder, John Trimble, owns about 80% of the stock and will be allowed to vote, so the spill is very likely to fail.
The 'Shaggers' are a minority shareholder action group formed by Planet Platinum investors. They have used the annual meeting to challenge management, vote down the remuneration report, question the company's finances and the $2.6 million loan to John Trimble’s private company, and press the board to take action on those issues.
The company's profit plunged 74% in the six months to December to just $63,000, and auditor Melanie Leydin raised doubts about whether the business is a going concern. Those results suggest notable financial stress and elevated risk for investors.
The $2.6 million loan is owed by John Trimble’s private company Metropolis City Promotions and is secured against his personal assets. It was originally made in 2003 to help pay out the mortgage over the Daily Planet property and has been repeatedly extended, now falling due in 2014. Shareholders pressed the board to call in the loan; director John Callanan agreed to review the loan’s due date at the next board meeting.
According to CEO and chairman John Trimble, there is 'no prospect of a dividend' in the near term. He also said the only realistic way to repay the large related-party loan would be via a dividend, which the company does not expect to pay.
Key governance risks include heavy ownership concentration (Trimble owns about 80%), recent board departures leaving the company non-compliant with ASX director requirements, conflicts related to a large related-party loan to the CEO’s private company, and the board facing a forced spill vote after the second strike — all of which can limit minority shareholder influence and increase uncertainty.
Planet Platinum has faced regulatory challenges: the club’s liquor licence was revoked in May 2011 but that decision was overturned by the Victorian Supreme Court two months later. Management says a long-running dispute with Victoria Police contributed to a 'horrid year' and disrupted trading, which has weighed on revenues and profitability.

