Saputo weighs higher offer for WCB
Trading in the 125-year-old company was halted on Friday after its board announced it was negotiating with Canada's biggest dairy processor, Saputo, about an increased offer. It came after Murray Goulburn attempted to trump Saputo's bid on Wednesday, firing in a $9 cash per share offer, valuing the Victorian dairy group at $505 million.
Saputo may make its offer unconditional, scrapping its main stumbling block of securing at least 50.1 per cent of WCB.
WCB secretary Paul Moloney said he expected an announcement from Saputo by Monday. The shares were trading at $9.10 a share before the trading halt.
Mark Topy, an analyst at Canaccord Genuity, said Saputo had the greatest financial power and could offer at least $9.50 a share.
"The fact that [WCB] have gone into a trading halt ... looks like they are going to really try and knock Murray Goulburn out of the game," Mr Topy said.
But Rivkin Securities director Shannon Rivkin said he was expecting a more modest offer.
"They are probably going to come in with a bid very close to the last bid. My guess is $9 or close to it," Mr Rivkin said. "On expected earnings, it is at a sky-high price now."
WCB's profit slid 51 per cent to $7.5 million in the year to June 30. It is being stalked by food companies because of its large export focus and potential to capitalise on the Asian agricultural boom.
Macquarie Bank has forecast Chinese dairy consumption to rise 13 per cent a year until 2017, while its appetite for high-end milk products will swell by 20 per cent annually. "This is a strategic asset for Saputo; they have no presence in Australia or this region and they want that, so overpaying doesn't really matter for them considering how big they are," Mr Rivkin said. "[But] for Bega and Murray Goulburn it's about staying relevant."
Bega, which is offering $2 cash plus stock, increased the scrip component of its offer from 1.2 to 1.5 Bega shares on Thursday, valuing its bid at $9.13 a share based on Friday's close.
The NSW-based company has approval from the competition regulator, unlike Murray Goulburn, which will lodge a formal submission to the competition tribunal at the end of the month.
Mr Rivkin expected Bega to become a takeover target if its bid was unsuccessful, while Murray Goulburn could become "a small fish in a big pond" if its bid failed.
Federal Treasurer Joe Hockey gave Saputo foreign investment approval on Tuesday, saying that "Australia is open for business".
Curdievale farmer Adrian Hoffmann, who has supplied WCB for the past 11 years, said he liked Saputo's bid but was concerned about it securing 50.1 per cent of the company's stock.
About 45 per cent of the company is owned by Bega (18.3 per cent), Murray Goulburn (17 per cent) and Japanese beer and dairy company Kirin (10 per cent).
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
The takeover battle for Warrnambool Cheese & Butter is heating up, with investors expecting offers to reach as high as $9.50 or even $10 per share. The company is currently in negotiations with Canada's largest dairy processor, Saputo, for an increased offer after Murray Goulburn made a $9 cash per share bid.
Saputo is interested in acquiring Warrnambool Cheese & Butter because it is a strategic asset with a large export focus and potential to capitalize on the Asian agricultural boom. Saputo currently has no presence in Australia or the region, making this acquisition an important step for their expansion.
Saputo is expected to make an offer of at least $9.50 per share, while Murray Goulburn has already made a $9 cash per share offer. Analysts believe Saputo has the financial power to offer more, potentially making their offer unconditional by removing the requirement to secure at least 50.1% of WCB.
Warrnambool Cheese & Butter's profit has recently slid by 51% to $7.5 million in the year ending June 30. Despite this, the company remains attractive to bidders due to its export potential and strategic value.
The competition regulator has approved Bega's bid for WCB, while Murray Goulburn is still awaiting approval and plans to lodge a formal submission to the competition tribunal. This regulatory approval is crucial for the success of any takeover bid.
If Bega's bid for WCB is unsuccessful, it could become a takeover target itself. On the other hand, if Murray Goulburn's bid fails, it risks becoming a 'small fish in a big pond,' potentially losing relevance in the industry.
Federal Treasurer Joe Hockey has granted foreign investment approval to Saputo, emphasizing that 'Australia is open for business.' This approval is significant as it allows Saputo to proceed with its bid for WCB without regulatory hurdles related to foreign investment.
Major shareholders like Bega, Murray Goulburn, and Kirin collectively own about 45% of WCB. Their stakes and decisions will significantly influence the outcome of the takeover bids, as Saputo needs to secure at least 50.1% of the company's stock to make its offer unconditional.

