IF 2011 can be summed up as the year of buybacks in the listed property trust sector, this year is shaping up as the year the $75 billion sector got its mojo back.
After years of bringing on debt and going on wild expansion forays, the sector has cleaned itself up and is selling or recycling assets, conducting share buybacks and maintaining a high payout ratio of 80 per cent. It goes a long way to explaining the solid performance of the listed property trust sector, A-REITS (Australian Real Estate Investment Trusts), in the past 18 months: up almost 10 per cent in the year to December 31, versus minus 9.7 per cent for equities, and up 12 per cent since January, compared with a fall in the market of 1 per cent.
Renewed interest in the listed property trust sector comes as the spread between property yields and bonds has blown apart. The widening gap has been helped largely by the Reserve Bank's move to reduce the official interest rate by 75 basis points in the past two months.
A-REITs are trading on a yield of more than 6 per cent, compared to the 10-year bond rate of 3 per cent. This gap is twice the long-term average, according to REIT analyst John Kim at CLSA Asia Pacific Markets. On a global stage, this puts Australia's listed property trusts on one of the highest yields and has attracted interest from self-funded retirees, wealthy individuals and super funds chasing defensive stocks with high-dividend yields.
And while global equity markets continue their roller-coaster ride and a series of M&A deals have been postponed due to a drying up of credit markets and lack of appetite for risk, the property sector sits and waits.
In the past year consolidation in the sector reduced the number of REITs from 24 to 19 and in a recent report Standard & Poor's suggests that further rationalisation is likely, given the discount to net tangible assets that most trusts continue to trade.
Industry talk is that when Europe settles down after the Greek elections on June 17, a number of big property deals will come to fruition, including the sale or break-up of FKP Property Group and its retirement village assets the sale of the newly listed Centro vehicle the sale of Dexus Property Group's remaining $500 million of US and European assets and a takeover of Mirvac or Commonwealth Office Property Trust.
The big listed property trusts, with cleaned-up balance sheets, are under pressure to get bigger to become more relevant and show a solid earnings growth profile in the next 12 months.
But not all segments of the property market are doing as well as others. The star of the sector is industrial, while office and consumer-linked REITs (residential and retail exposed) are facing some headwinds. In the case of retail, a number of projects are expected to be deferred due to retailers not having the capacity to expand.
For instance, CFS Retail Property Trust deferred a $130 million development project at Castle Plaza and $35 million at Eastlands. The deferral was attributed to retailers in these centres having reduced capacity to participate in redevelopments, given the difficult retail conditions. Given retail has not improved, with recent downgrades in David Jones, Myer and others, the retail development pipeline is likely to be curtailed.
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
Why have listed property trusts (A-REITs) bounced back recently?
The sector has cleaned up balance sheets, sold or recycled assets, run share buybacks and paid high dividends (around an 80% payout ratio). Those moves, plus falling bond rates, helped A-REITs deliver solid returns — the sector was up almost 10% to Dec 31 and up about 12% since January while the broader market slipped.
How do A-REIT yields compare to bond yields and why does that matter for investors?
A-REITs are trading on yields above 6% while the 10-year bond rate was about 3%, creating a gap roughly twice the long-term average. That wide spread makes listed property trusts attractive to retirees, wealthy individuals and super funds looking for defensive stocks with high dividend yields.
What role have share buybacks and high payout ratios played in the property trust recovery?
Share buybacks and an industry-wide high payout ratio (around 80%) have returned cash to investors and supported earnings per share metrics, helping explain much of the sector’s improved performance over the past 12–18 months.
Is consolidation happening in the REIT sector and which deals are being talked about?
Yes — the number of listed REITs fell from 24 to 19 in the past year and Standard & Poor’s expects further rationalisation. Market talk points to possible deals including a sale or break-up of FKP Property Group, sales involving Centro and Dexus’s remaining US/European assets, and potential takeovers of Mirvac or Commonwealth Office Property Trust.
Which types of property trusts are outperforming and which are facing headwinds?
Industrial REITs are the star performers. Office and consumer-linked trusts (residential and retail-exposed) are facing headwinds, with retail particularly affected by weaker conditions and reduced retailer capacity to support expansions.
Why are some retail development projects being deferred?
Developers are deferring projects because retailers have reduced capacity to participate in redevelopments amid difficult trading conditions. For example, CFS Retail Property Trust deferred a $130 million project at Castle Plaza and $35 million at Eastlands for this reason.
How have Reserve Bank rate cuts influenced the listed property trust sector?
The Reserve Bank’s cuts (about 75 basis points over two months) helped push bond yields lower, widening the yield gap between property trusts and bonds. That has increased investor demand for A-REITs seeking higher income relative to fixed income.
What should everyday investors watch in the listed property trust sector over the next 12 months?
Keep an eye on further consolidation and M&A activity, big trusts’ efforts to grow and show earnings improvement, asset sales (including overseas disposals), retail development pipeline changes, and macro factors like bond yields and developments in Europe that could affect deal timing.