InvestSMART

Palmer calls for pause on coal seam gas development

Eccentric businessman Clive Palmer has called for a pause on new coal seam gas developments, despite one of his businesses relying on the controversial form of energy for many years.
By · 2 Aug 2013
By ·
2 Aug 2013
comments Comments
Eccentric businessman Clive Palmer has called for a pause on new coal seam gas developments, despite one of his businesses relying on the controversial form of energy for many years.

Now a political aspirant as well as a businessman, Mr Palmer issued a statement on Wednesday urging the coal seam gas industry to slow down until more was known about its impact on people and the environment.

"Let's take a breather," he said. "Lives are a lot more important than the extraction of coal seam gas."

His comments came after NSW chief scientist Mary O'Kane released a report this week that said it had been found that coal seam gas drilling could pose health and environmental challenges and more research was needed.

Mr Palmer is running for Federal Parliament under the banner of the Palmer United Party, and his comments are likely to be a pitch to rural voters in NSW who are concerned that Queensland's coal seam gas boom could be repeated in their regions.

"This report raises serious questions about human health, the effects on the environment, water in particular, landholders' legal rights, and industry regulation and compliance," Mr Palmer said.

"All governments and companies involved should put their personal interests on hold and support a thorough investigation into these concerns."

But Mr Palmer's comments seem at odds with some of his business plays, most notably his nickel refinery near Townsville.

The refinery has used coal seam gas for power since BHP Billiton owned it in about 2006, and its reliance on coal seam gas has increased under Mr Palmer's ownership.

In a statement published in September 2012, Mr Palmer's company announced that a roaster at the refinery would be converted from heavy fuel oil to coal seam gas in a move said to reduce the refinery's carbon footprint, reduce its energy costs and improve its nickel recoveries.

When asked how his call for the industry to "take a breather" sat with his company's use of coal seam gas, Mr Palmer said the comparisons were irrelevant.

"It's to do with coal seam gas development; that's an already developed area," he said.

Mr Palmer has a history of investing in companies with exposure to onshore oil and gas. He sought to take control of ASX-listed Central Petroleum in 2012. He ultimately sold down his stake after failing to take control earlier this year.

Central Petroleum is developing a shale oil and gas business, which is similar to coal seam gas drilling, in central Australia and Texas.

While shale is considered less risky for groundwater than coal seam gas drilling, it has been plagued by similar concerns over its impact on seismology and chemical use.

Mr Palmer also has ambitions to develop a business exporting conventional coal from central Queensland, as well as iron ore interests in Western Australia.
Google News
Follow us on Google News
Go to Google News, then click "Follow" button to add us.
Share this article and show your support
Free Membership
Free Membership
InvestSMART
InvestSMART
Keep on reading more articles from InvestSMART. See more articles
Join the conversation
Join the conversation...
There are comments posted so far. Join the conversation, please login or Sign up.

Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…

Clive Palmer is a businessman and political aspirant running for Federal Parliament under the Palmer United Party. He has called for a pause on new coal seam gas (CSG) developments, urging the industry to "take a breather" until more is known about CSG's impact on people and the environment.

Palmer's call followed a report from NSW chief scientist Mary O'Kane that flagged potential health and environmental challenges from coal seam gas drilling and recommended more research. Palmer said the report raises serious questions about human health, water, landholders' legal rights, and industry regulation and compliance.

Yes. Palmer's nickel refinery near Townsville has used coal seam gas for power since about 2006 and increased its reliance after he acquired it. In September 2012 his company said it would convert a roaster from heavy fuel oil to CSG to reduce carbon footprint, cut energy costs and improve nickel recoveries.

The article notes the call appears at odds with Palmer's business use of CSG. Palmer responded that the comparison is irrelevant because his refinery operates in an "already developed area," implying his concerns target new CSG development rather than existing operations.

Palmer’s public call and the NSW chief scientist's report could increase political and public scrutiny on CSG, especially in rural regions. Everyday investors should be aware that heightened scrutiny can prompt regulatory reviews, reputational risk for companies, and debate among local communities and policymakers.

Central Petroleum is an ASX-listed company developing shale oil and gas projects in central Australia and Texas. Palmer tried to take control of Central Petroleum in 2012 but ultimately sold down his stake after failing to gain control earlier. The article notes shale projects share some similarities and concerns with CSG drilling.

The NSW chief scientist's report raised potential health and environmental challenges for coal seam gas drilling, with particular concerns about water. The article also notes shale gas is considered less risky for groundwater than CSG but has faced concerns over seismic activity and chemical use.

Investors should monitor government and industry responses to the NSW chief scientist's report, any investigations or regulatory changes, statements from companies that use or develop CSG, and Palmer’s political campaign activity with the Palmer United Party—especially in rural NSW where the issue is politically sensitive.