Packer doubles down on Barangaroo wager with a surprise exit from Echo
The sale of Crown's 10 per cent stake in rival casino operator, Echo Entertainment, on Thursday evening crystalised a loss as high as $38 million, according to analysts. But it sent a clear message - Crown is taking one shot at Barangaroo with its direct application for a casino/hotel complex, and Echo was not a plan B.
The media focus has been on the logical juncture for Crown to make a decision about the sale of its Echo stake - namely the NSW government's decision next month on whether Crown gets a licence for its development at Barangaroo. If Crown lost, the plan B was then expected to be a takeover bid for Echo.
It would have meant Crown could decide the future of its stake as Echo's share price rose to reflect a potential takeover premium, although this would have had its own complications once it became clear Crown was a seller.
The rationale for Crown selling now was "difficult to understand", said Mark Bryan, an analyst at Bank of America Merrill Lynch.
Crown's confidence in its submission was about the best reason most analysts could muster.
"We do not believe one can read too much into the implications for Crown's proposed casino in Sydney from this decision as submissions are due June 21, however, it does appear as though Crown is optimistic that its proposal will be successful," Deutsche Bank analyst Mark Wilson said.
What has not been mentioned, and will be more difficult to gauge, is the pressure on the NSW government to make sure Packer's deal gets approved if it does not want to risk watching him walk away.
Crown sources say the company had maintained it would decide the future of its Echo stake once its application to the NSW and Queensland casino regulators had been determined.
The Queensland regulator finally followed its NSW counterpart on Monday in raising the cap on Crown's stake in Echo from 10 per cent to 23 per cent.
The Crown board met Thursday and made its decision to sell its shares that night.
On Friday, Crown issued a statement from Mr Packer saying it had sold its stake in order to "pursue the Crown Sydney hotel resort without speculation surrounding its Echo shareholding".
Mr Packer said, "Crown Sydney is a once-in-a-lifetime project for our company," and "we are working as hard as we can to make this goal a reality".
The market seems to be treating the Crown sale as a permanent retreat from Echo. The would-be target watched its shares plunge more than 10 per cent during trading on Friday, falling below the $3 mark for the first time.
Asian casino group Genting is still applying to raise its stake in Echo to 25 per cent but, given it is not even halfway to its 10 per cent ownership cap, no one is making any assumptions about its potential as a suitor for Echo.
When it comes to the NSW government's final decision over the unsolicited proposals from Echo and Crown, victory would not come without concerns from the financial markets.
Crown's interest in Echo was expected to protect Echo investors from the prospect of the company overpaying to effectively extend its casino monopoly in Sydney, according to Commonwealth Bank gaming analyst Ben Brownette.
But a win could pressure Crown to address concerns about how it would justify the economics of its Barangaroo project. Crown has insisted the VIP gaming rooms were needed to underpin the economics of the luxury hotel and has since added apartments to the project.
Analysts are not sure that even this would be enough. "We do not believe Crown Sydney will make an economic return as the anticipated capex has increased to $1.2 billion to $1.5 billion, notwithstanding that the costs could be defrayed by the sale of 80 apartments," Mr Wilson said.
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
Crown sold its 10% stake in rival casino operator Echo Entertainment. According to the company, the stake was sold so Crown could “pursue the Crown Sydney hotel resort without speculation surrounding its Echo shareholding.” Analysts also say the move signals Crown is focusing directly on its Barangaroo proposal rather than using Echo as a plan B.
Analysts estimated the sale crystallised a loss as high as $38 million for Crown, based on the article’s reporting.
The market treated the sale as a permanent retreat by Crown. Echo’s shares plunged more than 10% during trading the following day, falling below the $3 mark for the first time that session.
Crown’s sale appears to show confidence in its direct application for the Barangaroo project. Deutsche Bank analyst Mark Wilson said submissions were due June 21 and suggested the decision indicates Crown is optimistic its proposal will be successful. The article also notes potential political pressure on the NSW government around approval decisions.
Before the sale, analysts expected that if Crown lost the Barangaroo licence it might mount a takeover bid for Echo. Selling the Echo stake removes that straightforward takeover route, and some analysts described the timing of the sale as difficult to understand.
Regulators influenced ownership caps. The Queensland regulator followed its NSW counterpart by lifting the cap on Crown’s stake in Echo from 10% to 23%. Crown had previously said it would decide the future of its Echo stake after casino regulator rulings in NSW and Queensland were determined.
Asian casino group Genting is applying to raise its stake in Echo to 25%. However, the article notes that Genting is currently not even halfway to the 10% ownership cap, so market participants were not assuming Genting would emerge as a clear suitor.
Analysts warned the economics of Crown Sydney are uncertain. Crown says VIP gaming rooms and the addition of 80 apartments help underpin the project, but Deutsche Bank’s Mark Wilson noted projected capex has increased to $1.2–$1.5 billion and questioned whether the project would make an economic return even with apartment sales helping to defray costs.
Call 1300 880 160
Start a chat
Schedule a call
