THERE are not too many analysts with a buy recommendation on Telstra. Of late, there have been plenty downgrading it to hold or even sell. At the $4 level at which the company has been trading, this is no surprise.
Telstra needed to pull a rabbit out of a hat yesterday to justify a "buy" tag. It didn't.
It produced earnings that were a bit shy of analysts' expectations given the second half was a bit weaker than the first. The share price dipped 8? to $3.89 in response.
It's not that Telstra has done anything wrong. It is still performing well, churning out cash, and sucking up handouts from the government to compensate it for the building of NBN infrastructure.
But the strong growth in mobiles it has experienced over the past couple of years will start to taper off in 2013. Telstra still expects to increase its subscriber numbers but not at the same rate.
It will look to offset this by increasing prices, but has to manage this process carefully to avoid the previous mistakes of overpricing and losing market share.
The game is not up in mobiles, but having now reached 60 per cent market share there is a limit to the pace of growth.
There are some brighter spots in the pipeline in other Telstra businesses areas, such as Network Application Services, which provides communications solutions to large organisations.
The Hong Kong-based CSL put in a good performance, as did the global connectivity business. But in absolute terms they are small, relative to mobiles.
And then there are the troublesome businesses.
Sensis better known as the Yellow Pages directories business continued to go backwards, with print revenue falling 22 per cent and margins slipping by 9 percentage points.
The headwinds from the decline in revenue from the fixed copper network continue.
The latest numbers (although not provided by Telstra) say 14 per cent of households no longer have fixed line connections. The trend will continue and more likely than not it will accelerate.
As is always the case with Telstra, the emerging technologies are required to offset those in decline. In 2012, the company managed to post a modest rise in revenue of 1.1 per cent, and an equally modest improvement in earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA) of 0.8 per cent both of which were inside guidance.
The company's outlook statement paints a fairly similar outcome for 2013 low single-digit income and EBITDA growth.
One of the reasons these forecasts can be relied on is the stellar job Telstra is doing in managing its cost base, and we should expect to see more of this in 2013.
While these results are not the sort to generally excite the market, there are a series of other factors weighing in to Telstra's share price performance, which this year alone has risen 16 per cent more than 2? times the rest of the market.
Its a combination of a flight to yield and reliability.
And this is scarce commodity at the moment.
There will be other companies reporting bigger improvements in 2012 earnings, but none have quantified a near-guaranteed dividend.
Given the rise in Telstra's share price, the yield isn't as attractive as it was a year ago but it certainly not bad at just over 7 per cent.
The other solid bit of information is that the government will drip-feed billions into Telstra's coffers in upcoming years $420 million was received in 2012.
While analysts now take the view that on financial fundamentals Telstra is fully priced, the trouble for investors is that there are few solid options out there in the market.
Punters can make a bet and buy plenty of what appear to be cheap stocks trading on low price earnings multiples, but they run the risk that earnings won't improve or may even slide and dividends will fall.
With commodity prices falling, investors have been bailing out of the big stocks such as BHP Billiton and Rio Tinto.
There are myriad cyclical stocks, but most have risks associated with the broader economic environment.
Telstra is far less sensitive to the vagaries of consumer sentiment, although mobile revenue from the small business segment did suffer in 2012.
But where is the next growth driver?
There is no real suggestion from management that Telstra will spend up big on acquisitions.
Rather, it appears to be placing its bets (and $500 million of capital expenditure this year) on its new 4G mobile network. Right now this reaches only 40 per cent of the market.
But increasing capex is not always as popular with shareholders as it is with management.
While investors were not really expecting any capital management announcements yesterday, nor an increase in dividends, either one would have offset any earnings disappointments and resulted in Telstra's share price ticking up even further.
The author owns Telstra shares.
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
Why did Telstra's share price fall after its recent earnings report?
Telstra's shares dipped because the company reported earnings a little below analysts' expectations and the second half of the year was weaker than the first. The market reaction pushed the share price down about 8% to around $3.89 after the announcement.
Is Telstra still a reliable dividend stock for income investors?
Many investors view Telstra as a reliable yield play. The article notes the yield is just over 7% after the recent share price rise and that a combination of steady cash generation and government payments make the dividend appear near‑guaranteed. That perceived reliability has helped drive demand, even though analysts say Telstra may be fully priced on financial fundamentals.
What is Telstra's mobile growth outlook for 2013 and beyond?
Telstra expects mobile subscriber growth to continue but at a slower pace in 2013. The company has already reached roughly a 60% mobile market share, so the strong growth seen in prior years is likely to taper. Telstra plans to manage slower subscriber growth partly by carefully increasing prices without repeating past overpricing mistakes.
Which Telstra businesses are doing well and which are struggling?
Brighter spots include Network Application Services (communications solutions for large organisations), Hong Kong‑based CSL and Telstra's global connectivity business, although the latter two are small compared with mobiles. Troubling areas include Sensis (the Yellow Pages business), where print revenue fell 22% and margins slipped by about 9 percentage points, and ongoing headwinds from declining fixed copper revenue as household fixed‑line connections fall.
How did Telstra perform financially in 2012 and what is the 2013 outlook?
In 2012 Telstra reported a modest revenue rise of 1.1% and an EBITDA improvement of 0.8%, both inside guidance. For 2013 the company guided to low single‑digit income and EBITDA growth, reflecting a similar, modest outcome ahead.
What is Telstra spending on network upgrades like 4G, and how might that affect investors?
Management is prioritising investment in its new 4G mobile network, with about $500 million of capital expenditure planned for the year mentioned in the article. The 4G network currently covers roughly 40% of the market. While increased capex supports future growth, higher spending may not always be popular with shareholders seeking immediate returns.
What do analysts recommend for Telstra shares right now?
According to the article, few analysts have a 'buy' recommendation on Telstra; many have been downgrading the stock to 'hold' or even 'sell'. Some analysts consider Telstra fully priced on financial fundamentals, though investors continue to buy for yield and reliability.
How does Telstra compare with other large Australian stocks as an investment option?
The article suggests Telstra is less sensitive to commodity cycles and consumer sentiment than big miners like BHP Billiton and Rio Tinto, which have seen investor selling amid falling commodity prices. That relative stability, a near‑guaranteed dividend stream and strong cost management make Telstra attractive to yield‑seeking investors, though questions remain about where the next big growth driver will come from.
Call 1300 880 160
Start a chat
Schedule a call
