Morgan Stanley sued over $5m super losses
Investment bank Morgan Stanley Smith Barney is being sued after losing more than $5 million from the super accounts of two private clients with a series of "aggressive, highly speculative and high-risk" trades using derivatives and share options.
Court documents reveal that Morgan Stanley reaped more than $1.1 million in fees across two funds, controlled by 74-year-old Helen Sedman and her business partner, 61-year-old Sally Middleton
After a series of losing options trades and fees were deducted, more than 97 per cent of the balance of Ms Middleton's $1.2 million super account with Morgan Stanley was wiped out.
Ms Middleton was left with just $34,000 in the account.
The balance of a second fund, in Ms Sedman's name, fell from $4.8 million to $950,000 in just two months, after losing options trades, mainly in mining stocks.
The losses have put the retirement security in doubt for both claimants, who have filed two suits against Morgan Stanley in the Supreme Court of Victoria. In statements of claim, the pair allege that the investment bank and stockbroker Kate Kearney engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct by trading heavily on options and derivatives, against instructions, for the "primary purpose" of generating fees and concealing losses in the portfolios.
"The defendant engaged in high-volume risky trading which put at risk the entire or a substantial amount of the funds within the super fund, yet it never adequately advised the super fund trustee of the nature of those financial derivatives or explained the degree of risk," Ms Sedman claims.
The plaintiffs also allege Morgan Stanley did not stop Ms Kearney's increasingly aggressive trades despite the volume of activity being flagged by Morgan Stanley's risk management division.
At one stage, Ms Kearney had allegedly allowed exposure on Ms Sedman's $4.8 million account to blow out to $7 million. Within two months, the value of the account had fallen $3.89 million to just $950,000, court records show.
Trader David Waterhouse - one of the biggest private writers of options trades in the country - described betting an individual's retirement savings on the options market as "an act of insanity".
"About one per cent of the population have the knowledge and the risk appetite to be able to trade options effectively," he said. "It's a high-risk market. I always say, when it comes to retirement investing, it's horses for courses. Some people can afford risk, but the majority should bet safe. Options trading is not a safe bet."
Following the steep losses, Ms Sedman and Ms Middleton met Ms Kearney and the broker allegedly said her investment strategies were "low risk".
But when Ms Sedman instructed Ms Kearney to stop trading in options the following month, Ms Kearney reportedly said "she could not get out of the investment exposure the super fund was in and it was not the time to get out". "Everything is under control," Ms Kearney reportedly said.
Ms Middleton, who liquidated her account in December 2011, has estimated her losses at $1.15 million. Ms Sedman believes she lost about $4.2 million.
The writs claim that only a "broad estimate" of the loss and damage can be provided as Morgan Stanley has refused to provide a complete record of trading.
"Kearney provided in her own format monthly trading statements to the super fund trustee ... which conflicted with summary statements provided by [Morgan Stanley's] accounting system," Ms Middleton also alleges.
Kate Kearney and Morgan Stanley could not be reached for comment.
email@example.com Twitter: @chrisvedelago
InvestSMART FORUM: Come and meet the team
We're loading up the van and going on tour from April to June, with events on the NSW central & north coast, the QLD mid-north coast and in Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney and Canberra. Come and meet the team and take home simple strategies that you can use to build an investment portfolio to weather any storm. Book your spot here.
Want access to our latest research and new buy ideas?
Start a free 15 day trial and gain access to our research, recommendations and market-beating model portfolios.Sign up for free