High-stakes case for Tinkler
Liquidators have launched legal action against Nathan Tinkler after the coal baron allegedly allowed one of his companies to trade while insolvent, and for breaching directors' duties.
The action follows a decision by the NSW Supreme Court on Tuesday to approve a funding agreement between Blackwood Corporation and the liquidators of Mulsanne Resources - one of Mr Tinkler's failed companies - after Mulsanne failed to buy $28.4 million of Blackwood shares last year, despite agreeing to do so.
That decision cleared the path for liquidators to sue Mr Tinkler and Mulsanne's other directors.
The finding also meant Blackwood could provide the funds for liquidators Ferrier Hodgson to wind up Mulsanne and pursue Mr Tinkler for insolvent trading.
Late on Thursday, Ferrier Hodgson confirmed it had filed proceedings in the NSW Supreme Court against Mr Tinkler and two other former Mulsanne directors, Matthew Keen and Troy Palmer.
Blackwood said in a statement that if the court finds Mulsanne's directors liable for insolvent trading, it may make compensation orders against them personally.
"In this case, the liquidator has indicated that it will enforce the orders against any or all defendants," the Blackwood statement says. "Blackwood will continue to monitor the recoverability of the monies owed to the company under the [agreement] and will keep the market updated on further developments."
In a statement, Tinkler Group said: "The directors of Mulsanne strongly deny allegations of trading while insolvent and will strongly defend any legal action instigated by the liquidators."
The legal action dates to events of May last year, when Mulsanne agreed to acquire more than 94.6 million shares in Blackwood for $28.4 million. It failed to pay the money by the agreed date, and also missed a four-week extension for the payment.
Liquidators conducted a public examination of Mr Tinkler and Mr Keen in March this year.
Evidence was given by both men that, at the time Mulsanne agreed to buy the Blackwood shares, they believed funding for the deal would flow from the sale of a royalty stream controlled by the Tinkler Group.
But when Mulsanne failed to come up with the money on time, Blackwood filed an application to have the company wound up. Mulsanne did not defend the application to wind up.
In documents tendered in the NSW Supreme Court, Ferrier Hodgson said Mulsanne's directors had no reasonable grounds to believe the company could pay the $28.4 million when the time came to do so.
InvestSMART FORUM: Come and meet the team
We're loading up the van and going on tour from April to June, with events on the NSW central & north coast, the QLD mid-north coast and in Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney and Canberra. Come and meet the team and take home simple strategies that you can use to build an investment portfolio to weather any storm. Book your spot here.
Want access to our latest research and new buy ideas?
Start a free 15 day trial and gain access to our research, recommendations and market-beating model portfolios.Sign up for free