Fresh offer not enough to lift ailing Billabong
It did little for the market's mood, with the shares falling more than 13 per cent to 85¢ - well below the conditional $1.10-a-share offer from Mr Naude's consortium - due to uncertainty over the bid, and a profit downgrade announced on Wednesday that could halve the company's earnings this year.
Adding to the misery was news from Billabong that asset value write-downs are being considered for the half-year. This could lead to yet another loss this year.
It is believed the earnings target for the four-year turnaround plan of new chief executive Launa Inman is also under review for the half-year result in February.
It could have been worse. Billabong came close to losing its third potential bidder in as many months after details of the latest offer were made public on Monday. Along with Wednesday's profit downgrade, this breached conditions of the offer from the consortium that consists of Mr Naude, New York-based Sycamore Partners, and Bank of America Merrill Lynch, which will arrange debt-financing if the proposal succeeds.
A letter from Mr Naude to Billabong on Wednesday afternoon confirmed the deal was still on the table despite the breaches.
"The Billabong board will be considering the proposal and its terms and will update the market as soon as possible," the company said in a second release to the ASX that day.
Credit Suisse analyst Grant Saligari said the bid "in hindsight, is quite well timed" but the price indicated "quite a substantial turnaround assumption" for Billabong.
Mr Naude, a 14-year veteran at Billabong who was overlooked in favour of Ms Inman, took leave to pursue a bid for the company last month.
Billabong said it cut its earnings forecasts for the year because of a weaker-than-expected performance in October and November in Europe and the Americas. The latter business was overseen by Mr Naude until last month.
The company now expects full-year underlying earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA) to be in a range of $85 million to $92 million, down from its previous forecast of $100 million to $110 million.
One-off costs are expected to lead to statutory EBITDA falling to between $53 million and $63 million for the year ending June 30.
This includes company transformation costs, expenses associated with assessing bids for the company, and a loss on its option to buy out the highly successful online retailer SurfStitch. The company could also incur impairments on the value of its assets.
Billabong said a review of all its assets would be conducted at the end of the month because of the sharp fall in the company's market value. This fell to as low as $354 million last month. It has intangible assets valued at $796 million.
Ms Inman presented a turnaround plan to the market this year, aiming for a return to sales growth in four years and EBITDA of $210 million. The company would not comment on Wednesday on the target, which is understood to be under review.
The bid from Mr Naude's consortium is the latest in a series of offers in the past year, punctuated by profit downgrades, a partial sale of a business, shop closures and job losses.
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
Billabong’s board confirmed it still has a $527 million takeover proposal to consider from a consortium led by long-time Billabong executive Paul Naude. The consortium includes New York-based private equity firm Sycamore Partners and Bank of America Merrill Lynch, which has agreed to arrange debt financing if the proposal proceeds.
The market reaction was negative: Billabong shares fell more than 13% to 85¢ after the takeover details became public and the company announced a profit downgrade that could roughly halve earnings for the year. The share price is well below the conditional $1.10-per-share offer indicated by the consortium.
Billabong reduced its forecasts because trading in October and November was weaker than expected in Europe and the Americas. The company said this weaker performance, along with associated costs and potential asset impairments, led it to lower its expected full-year results.
Billabong now expects full-year underlying EBITDA of $85 million to $92 million, down from a prior forecast of $100 million to $110 million. One-off costs mean statutory EBITDA is expected to fall to $53 million–$63 million for the year ending June 30.
One-off costs include company transformation expenses, costs associated with assessing bids for the company, and a loss on Billabong’s option to buy online retailer SurfStitch. The company also warned it could incur impairments on the value of some assets and is reviewing asset values because of a sharp fall in market value.
Chief executive Launa Inman presented a four-year turnaround plan earlier in the year targeting a return to sales growth and EBITDA of $210 million. The article says that the turnaround earnings target is believed to be under review and will be reassessed at the half-year result in February.
The consortium’s offer was conditional and was breached when Billabong disclosed the profit downgrade and other developments. Despite those breaches, Paul Naude confirmed in a letter that the deal was still on the table. Credit Suisse noted the bid assumes a substantial turnaround, so the offer relies on achieving improvement in the business and arranging debt financing via Bank of America Merrill Lynch.
Investors should watch for formal updates from the Billabong board to the ASX on the takeover proposal outcome, the company’s half-year results in February (when turnaround targets and earnings will be reassessed), the end-of-month asset review for possible impairments, and any further announcements about costs or changes to forecasts.
Call 1300 880 160
Start a chat
Schedule a call
