InvestSMART

Foreign investors unhappy

Big foreign investors are turning up the heat on Australian regulators over a controversial stalled mining project in the nation's east.
By · 18 May 2013
By ·
18 May 2013
comments Comments
Big foreign investors are turning up the heat on Australian regulators over a controversial stalled mining project in the nation's east.

Korean steel company Posco and Japanese conglomerate Mitsubishi have joined Nippon Steel and Sumitomo in warning that foreign investors are "alarmed" by a recent saga in NSW where Rio Tinto has lost its licence to expand a coalmine.

Rio's plan to expand the Warkworth coalmine was overturned in the NSW Land and Environment Court last month after campaigners from Bulga successfully argued that the expansion would have an unreasonable impact on their town.

The group of large foreign investors - who all hold stakes in the Warkworth mine - have written to NSW Premier Barry O'Farrell, describing the decision as a "dangerous precedent" for industry in the state.

"Unfortunately, the decision regarding the Warkworth extension project brings the risk and uncertainty in NSW to unacceptable levels," they wrote. "It is a major disincentive for foreign investment and will impede the state's economic development."

The companies said the issue had become a matter of "state significance" and was being "watched closely by resource companies around the world".

"It is essential that the NSW government restores certainty to the state's planning system."

The residents of Bulga - who were concerned the expanded mine would come within less than three kilometres of their town - have already seen the NSW Planning Minister Brad Hazzard declare he will side with Rio Tinto and the foreign miners in this dispute.

Rio has vowed to go to the Supreme Court in a bid to have the ruling overturned.

The dispute comes at a time when more than 30 per cent of Australia's thermal coalmines, and more than 40 per cent of the nation's coking coalmines are unprofitable, according to coalminer Xstrata.
Google News
Follow us on Google News
Go to Google News, then click "Follow" button to add us.
Share this article and show your support
Free Membership
Free Membership
InvestSMART
InvestSMART
Keep on reading more articles from InvestSMART. See more articles
Join the conversation
Join the conversation...
There are comments posted so far. Join the conversation, please login or Sign up.

Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…

A NSW Land and Environment Court overturned Rio Tinto's approval to expand the Warkworth coalmine after campaigners from Bulga successfully argued the expansion would have an unreasonable impact on their town.

Korean steel company Posco and Japanese conglomerate Mitsubishi joined Nippon Steel and Sumitomo in warning they are alarmed by the Warkworth ruling; all four hold stakes in the Warkworth mine and wrote to NSW Premier Barry O'Farrell.

The group wrote that the court decision increases risk and uncertainty in NSW, creates a major disincentive for foreign investment and could impede the state's economic development, calling the issue one of state significance watched by resource companies worldwide.

Residents of Bulga argued the expanded mine would come within less than three kilometres of their town and would have an unreasonable impact; their campaign led the court to overturn the expansion approval.

Rio Tinto has vowed to go to the Supreme Court in a bid to have the Land and Environment Court ruling overturned.

NSW Planning Minister Brad Hazzard has declared he will side with Rio Tinto and the foreign miners in the dispute, while the concerned investors have written directly to NSW Premier Barry O'Farrell asking for restored certainty.

The episode highlights regulatory and community risk in resource projects: investors say it raises uncertainty for projects in NSW, is being closely watched by global resource companies, and could affect investment decisions in the sector.

According to coalminer Xstrata cited in the article, more than 30% of Australia's thermal coalmines and more than 40% of the nation's coking coalmines are currently unprofitable.