InvestSMART

Financiers lose patience with Tinkler

A prop was knocked out from underneath the sprawling empire of troubled businessman Nathan Tinkler on Wednesday, when his financiers seized control of a $600 million stake in coalminer Whitehaven.
By · 20 Jun 2013
By ·
20 Jun 2013
comments Comments
A prop was knocked out from underneath the sprawling empire of troubled businessman Nathan Tinkler on Wednesday, when his financiers seized control of a $600 million stake in coalminer Whitehaven.

The move ends months of speculation about the future of Mr Tinkler's 20 per cent stake in the company, which has weighed on the Whitehaven share price.

The loss of control of the shares comes hard on the heels of his move to Singapore, where he has established a corporate base. It also comes as he has been seeking to liquidate assets such as his horse stud assets held through Patinack Farm, and property held through his Buildev company.

The Whitehaven stake was sold out from under him at $2.96 a share, well above the company's ruling share price, but significantly less than Mr Tinkler thought the shares were worth

This standoff over the share price resulted in Mr Tinkler seeking to hang onto his Whitehaven stake for as long as possible.

"His lenders lost patience with him some time ago," one source close to Mr Tinkler's financiers said. "It was only a question of when - not if - they would seize control.

"If his empire was a house of cards, as some have suggested, then removing this cornerstone support may destabilise" control of the remaining assets.

The loss of his Whitehaven stake marks the departure of Mr Tinkler from the public company sphere, although he holds a range of private assets such as Patinack Stud, a royalty stream from the Middlemount mine of $1 a tonne of coal produced, which is split with a business associate. He also holds an interest in copper exploration in central Queensland.

With the Whitehaven stake gone, the focus has shifted to whether Mr Tinkler can raise the $12 million he needs to settle litigation with Blackwood Corporation. Under a settlement, this amount is due by June 30.

Mr Tinkler is believed to have received some cash from the sale of the Whitehaven stake, which may go some way towards settling the Blackwood liability, although he also has an ongoing liability to Farallon.

In a statement to the sharemarket, Farallon said the Whitehaven deal was to "partly repay debt", with a further payment to Mr Tinkler likely if the Whitehaven share price averages more than $2.96 over the two months to mid-March 2014.

Mr Tinkler and Farallon have had dealings for many years, which continue, sources close to Mr Tinkler said. Farallon bought a 10 per cent slice of Whitehaven, giving it a 16.63 per cent stake in the coalminer, with the other 10 per cent of the Tinkler holding spread across existing shareholders.

"Selling this stake was a difficult decision," Mr Tinkler said in a statement. "However, we believe [it] will benefit all shareholders.

"Whitehaven's asset base ... provides for a strong future."

Whitehaven's share price closed on Wednesday at $2.20, up 9¢. Analysts have valuations of as much as $4 a share on Whitehaven and now that the stake has been sold, the shares may be re-rated.

"This ticks one box of the issues overhanging the stock," one analyst said. "The prospect for a re-rating may depend on the coal market."
Google News
Follow us on Google News
Go to Google News, then click "Follow" button to add us.
Share this article and show your support
Free Membership
Free Membership
InvestSMART
InvestSMART
Keep on reading more articles from InvestSMART. See more articles
Join the conversation
Join the conversation...
There are comments posted so far. Join the conversation, please login or Sign up.

Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…

Financiers seized control of Nathan Tinkler's roughly $600 million holding — about a 20% stake — in coalminer Whitehaven, selling the shares at $2.96 each. Sources quoted in the article say lenders "lost patience" after a prolonged standoff over the share price and decided to take control to partly recover debt.

The Whitehaven stake was sold at $2.96 a share. After the sale, Whitehaven's share price closed at $2.20, up 9 cents. Analysts quoted in the article value Whitehaven as high as $4 a share, and the removal of the Tinkler overhang could prompt a re‑rating depending on the coal market.

Farallon bought a 10% slice of Whitehaven as part of the sale, which gave it a reported 16.63% stake in the coalminer. Farallon said the deal was to "partly repay debt" and that a further payment to Mr Tinkler could be made if the Whitehaven share price averaged more than $2.96 over the two months to mid‑March 2014.

Mr Tinkler is believed to have received some cash from the Whitehaven sale. The article says that cash may go toward settling a $12 million litigation liability to Blackwood Corporation that is due by June 30, although he still has an ongoing liability to Farallon.

Even after the Whitehaven sale, Mr Tinkler retains a range of private assets mentioned in the article: Patinack Stud (horse stud assets), property held through his Buildev company, a royalty stream from the Middlemount mine of $1 a tonne of coal (split with a business associate), and an interest in copper exploration in central Queensland.

Sources in the article warned that if Tinkler's empire was "a house of cards," removing this cornerstone stake could destabilise control of his remaining assets. The sale also marks his exit from the public company sphere, which could change how his wider holdings are managed or financed.

The article suggests investors should watch the coal market and Whitehaven's share price because the prospect of a re‑rating may depend on coal market conditions. Also watch any corporate actions and analysts' valuations that could follow the removal of the Tinkler overhang.

According to Mr Tinkler's statement in the article, selling the stake was difficult but believed to "benefit all shareholders" by removing the uncertainty around his large holding. One analyst said the sale "ticks one box" of issues overhanging the stock, potentially clearing the way for the shares to be reassessed.