Falling market opportunity 2: Get sold off shares into your DIY fund

Looking for a potential win in this bleak market? Time to reacquaint yourself with in-specie transfers into super.

Summary: The state of the market at the start of 2016 makes this the perfect time to revisit the concept of in-specie transfers into super. An in-specie transfer allows you to move certain asset classes held outside super into your super fund, reducing capital gains tax and moving your assets into a lower tax environment. Transferring shares into super also means dividends are taxed at the relevant rates in your super fund – this is 15 per cent, or zero per cent if your account is in pension mode.

Key take out: In-specie transfers must fit within the concessional and non-concessional contribution limits – consult your accountant about your situation.

Key beneficiaries: SMSF trustees and superannuation accountholders. Category: Superannuation.

If there are any rays of sunlight poking through this stock market, then they haven’t been particularly bright.

The odd stock here and there has sparkled. But so many perpetual favourites have been smashed. So much blood on the floor.

In adversity, there is always opportunity. And there is a way to potentially take advantage of the massive downturn in the market and the “paper” losses that have come with it.

It’s time to reconsider transferring some of your precious shareholdings into super, via “in-specie transfers”.

An in-specie transfer is the act of shifting assets you hold outside of super into your super fund, that is not a cash transfer. A warning: Not all assets can be transferred into super. The two main exceptions are listed shares and business real property (this is a separate topic I’ll return to at another time).

What are the advantages of in-specie transfers? Here are the main five:

1. With share values down, you could minimise capital gains tax in your own name.

2.  You could transfer those favoured or precious assets into super, where they could enter a tax-free environment for both capital gains and income now, or in the future.

3. If not tax-free, then most likely they will be transferred into a tax environment much lower than paying your own marginal tax rate.

4.  You’re not “out of the market” while the shares are sold, as money is transferred into super and assets are repurchased.

5. Transfer fees are minimal.

Why should in-specie transfers be reconsidered now?

Because share markets have come off, so have your capital gains. And superannuation is a low-, or no-, tax environment.

If your windfalls have reduced, there’s less capital gains tax to pay now. If the asset is then transferred into super – and your SMSF is in pension phase – then you can transfer the assets into a zero-tax environment.

An example: In your own name, you bought 5000 shares in Company XYZ five years ago, for $20 a share. In about April last year, they peaked at $30, but have since fallen back to $25 a share.

You paid $100,000 for them initially. They peaked at $150,000. And they’re now worth $125,000.

If you in-specie transferred those shares into super now, you would be facing a gain of $25,000 (on which you would have to pay tax under the normal CGT rules). The gain is crystallised, and the CGT becomes payable, at the point of transfer.

But it is considerably better than paying tax on their sale at the peak of the market 10 months ago.

If those shares returned in value, eventually, to $30 a share and you sold them, then you wouldn’t have had to pay tax on the second half of that increase, if your super fund was in pension phase.

Now, let’s take an extreme example.

You spent that $100,000 buying a parcel at $20 a share, but they increased to $200 a share in April last year, before falling back to $25 again.

Had you sold them at the top of the market, you would have been dealing with a gain of $900,000. And a whopping CGT bill in your own name.

If you were able to now to transfer them into super, at $25 a share, in the belief that they would again return to $200 a share, then you would pay a relatively piffling amount of tax now, with the potential that no CGT would be paid if they did return to $200 a share and sold while your fund was in pension phase.

This applies to any asset that you believe has significant potential capital growth, or income growth, about it in the future.

Why hold an asset in your own name where you pay full tax, where it could be transferred into super and face much lower tax rates?

Then there are the dividends…

On top of the potential for paying lower CGT now, as shares have fallen in value, transferring your shares into super will also mean that future dividends will be taxed at superannuation tax rates, which are generally far better than marginal tax rates.

Super income tax is 15 per cent, unless the asset is in a pension fund, in which it pays tax at zero per cent. And that could mean the return of all franking credits. Beats paying tax at marginal tax rates of up to 49 per cent.

Restriction – in-specie transfers are contributions

Anything you put into super needs to go in as a contribution. So, you need to be eligible to contribute to super and the contributions need to fit into your contributions limits.

Depending on your circumstances, in-specie transfers could be put into super as either concessional contributions (CCs) or non-concessional contributions (NCCs), so they will need to fit into those caps – speak to your accountant about your situation.

For CCs, the cap is $30,000 for the under-50s and $35,000 for the over-50s. The NCC cap is $180,000 a year, or $540,000 under the three-year pull forward rule.

Is there a cost?

Both Computershare and Link Market Services, the main providers of share market services, currently charge $55 for this service.

Some argue that this cost makes the hassle of making in-specie transfers not worthwhile. If you are transferring in small parcels, this might be the case.

But if you are transferring larger parcels, the $55 could be seen as risk reduction to avoid the cost of not being out of the market. If you are out of the market for 5-10 days, and the market for those shares moves against you even 2 per cent on a $100,000 transaction, you’ve lost $2000.


The information contained in this column should be treated as general advice only. It has not taken anyone’s specific circumstances into account. If you are considering a strategy such as those mentioned here, you are strongly advised to consult your adviser/s, as some of the strategies used in these columns are extremely complex and require high-level technical compliance.

Bruce Brammall is managing director of Bruce Brammall Financial. E: bruce@brucebrammallfinancial.com.au . Bruce’s new book, Mortgages Made Easy, is available now.