InvestSMART

Extreme sport on the ASX

Market volatility and the prospect of companies being punished for poor results open opportunities for value investors and CFDs, says Rudi Filapek-Vandyck.
By · 16 Aug 2006
By ·
16 Aug 2006
comments Comments
Upsell Banner
PORTFOLIO POINT: A few months of volatility are likely to bring opportunities for investors who have an appetite for risk; contracts for difference are growing in popularity.

The markets could move sideways in the months ahead. If you're all cashed up and looking for the right opportunity, rest assured there is absolutely no need to rush into anything. In fact, staying on the sidelines for the time being may be the best option given the market’s current risks.

Ultimately it boils down to what type of investor you are. A few months of ongoing volatility are bound to deliver opportunities for the more speculative investors in the market, with the early stages of what looks like a potentially disappointing results season already generating some spectacular crashes, such as Downer EDI.

Trying to benefit from companies being punished by disappointed fellow investors is likely to become a more popular sport in the short term with highly leveraged investment instruments such as contracts for difference (CFDs) growing market share fast in the Australian retail market.

Highlight Stocks

Talent2 (TWO): Geoff Morgan and Andrew Banks, the founders of Morgan & Banks, are building another chapter to their successful joint endeavours. The main negative is a price/earnings multiple above 20, which within the current environment is likely to act as a headwind. Longer term, the prospects seem for strong growth supported by expansion into Asia. The company is not widely covered yet, but we suspect that too will change over time. This small-cap should be on everybody's radar.

Commonwealth Bank (CBA): The market didn't like the latest results by CommBank and doubts are emerging about whether management's targets will be achieved. We saw downgrades '” a few '” and not only regarding profit estimates. CommBank is currently rated minus 0.2 on FN Arena's Sentiment Indicator; at the bottom of all major banks. If the regional banks are included then only Bendigo Bank (BEN) rates worse at minus 0.3. Westpac (WBC) is still the highest ranked in the sector.

SAI Global (SAI): SAI Global is undoubtedly one of the few positive surprises we have seen lately. The average target price stands at $3.60, which is still double digits above the shares’ current price. Most brokers would agree the shares still deserve to be rated a buy. Its strong growth profile should last longer than 2006-07.

Billabong International (BBG): Billabong's share price is suffering from the serious headwinds consumers in the US (and elsewhere) are facing. Recommendation upgrades in May and June still give the shares a positive reading on the FN Arena Sentiment Indicator, but that can change at any time. Expect ongoing negative market sentiment and earnings expectations to likely come down.

Telstra (TLS): Despite the widely held belief that Australia's leading telco could only do better than subdued market expectations, chief executive Sol Trujillo and his team simply failed to deliver. FN Arena has held the view since last year already that telecommunication companies in Australia and New Zealand are facing the new paradigm of low growth and we strongly adhere to the view. Negative market developments are likely to persist for a while, placing targets and promises under pressure. And, yes, that includes future dividends.

Another type of investor that is having an absolute ball at the moment is the value seeker. Overall, risk appetite still seems relatively high, but it is receding. As fear has crept in, the US may now become a source of bad news; the market has started to undervalue stocks such as Rinker (RIN). Nobody knows how the US housing market will readjust to the post-boom era. The fact remains that Rinker is widely regarded as a very solid business led by highly regarded and experienced management. Ultimately, it will rise again. For investors with a longer time frame, of two or three years, buying Rinker shares at or below $13 are an absolute bargain. Few experts, if any, will dispute this.

The current average price target as set by the 10 leading domestic sharemarket experts monitored by FN Arena stands at $17.81, which is about 35% above Monday's closing price of $13.23. This probably explains why Rinker shares seem to have revived since late last week. Even at the lowest price target, $15.58 set by ABN-Amro, Rinker shares should still return about 20%, dividends included, over the next 12 months.

But Rinker is far from the only one. As of Monday this week, FN Arena's top 10 stocks of implied total returns in the year ahead is headed by Queensland based travel industry success story S8 (SEL) with an implied total return of more than 50%. Fear of more terrorist attacks hitting the global aviation industry is weighing on market sentiment, as is the fact that the company now bears integration risks following a series of takeovers.

Every broker who covers the stock rates it a buy, and the latest updates indicate they are quite confident the implied value will eventually rise to the surface.

On Monday, analysts at Citigroup Smith Barney again highlighted the huge potential that still resides within the rapidly expanding group: were S8 to increase its back-end commissions by just 1% (commissions paid out when booking volume targets have been exceeded) it would effectively double its pre-tax profit.

However, S8 is a highly speculative buy because the group has some significant branding issues to resolve. On August 9 its Queensland offices were raided by police as part of a wider investigation into commission payments at the group.

Separately, James Hardie (JHX) also offers turnaround potential with all brokers on the FN Arena list rating the shares a buy. Like S8, its implied total return is above 50%.

Others on the list are Macquarie Bank (MBL), Alumina (AWC), Challenger Financial (CGF), Hardman Resources (HDR), Perseverance (PSV) and Oceana Gold (OGD). The lowest recommended of these stocks is New Zealand-oriented Oceana Gold, which is in the midst of a merger that should see it become one of the largest gold producers across the Tasman.

Only two out of the top 10 carry sell ratings and not one single buy: Repco (RCL) and McGuigan Wines (MGW) indicating the reasons why these two stocks are trading so far below intrinsic value are of a much more severe nature. In fact, the risks associated with both opportunities are seen as extremely high (corporate activity excluded), which has caused several negative ratings.

It goes without saying that all of the above will change dramatically if interest rates will have to go higher still and risk pushing the US economy into recession next year. So far, however, only a small minority of experts is willing to support such a view. The coming months should provide investors with more insights on that danger.

Share this article and show your support
Free Membership
Free Membership
Rudi's View
Rudi's View
Keep on reading more articles from Rudi's View. See more articles
Join the conversation
Join the conversation...
There are comments posted so far. Join the conversation, please login or Sign up.