Don't risk a DIY will
What appears to be a cost-effective solution can be financially and emotionally draining for those you leave behind should a home-made will go wrong, and there are plenty of examples of that happening. The legal dispute over the assets of car-racing identity Peter Brock springs to mind.
Other examples, involving relatively small estates, have been just as protracted. In one case, the Supreme Court had to rule on the validity of a home-made will covering an estate of just a property and a boat. Courts have also been involved when multiple home-made wills were found. Such proceedings are costly and potentially cut into the estate.
Here's why you should seek legal advice on writing a will.
1 Your affairs are more complex than you think Drafting a will can be complicated, no matter the size of the estate. Nearly all of us have superannuation but this isn't automatically dealt with in a will. Put young children into the equation and more intricacies are involved.
2 Your words can be misconstrued Using your own words rather than legal terminology might create ambiguity.
3 You can have more control over who you exclude If you decide to omit someone from your will, it might not be as simple as making a statement in the will regarding the person and reason. Such statements might make the person more likely to challenge.
4 More control over your wishes Allegations of duress or mental incapacity in relation to you after you die will generally be more difficult to rebut if a qualified lawyer has not been engaged in the will-making process.
5 Signing and witnessing will be done correctly Each jurisdiction in Australia has specific legislation in relation to the signing and witnessing of wills. This is commonly done incorrectly in many home-made wills.
6 You'll receive advice on who is the best executor and trustee Receiving advice in relation to the role of the executor and trustee of your will is important. Simply appointing a family member is not necessarily appropriate. Does this person have the time and expertise, or even want to assume the role? What if they pass away first?
7 Your beneficiaries may be better off A properly drafted will can create tax and asset-protection advantages for beneficiaries.
Using a lawyer to prepare your will and advise on estate planning is a small price to pay to protect your wealth and ensure your wishes are adhered to after you pass away.
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
No — while DIY will templates can seem cost-effective, home-made wills often create ambiguity and can lead to costly legal disputes. The article highlights real cases (including the Peter Brock dispute) showing that mistakes in a DIY will can be financially and emotionally draining for your beneficiaries, so seeking a qualified lawyer is recommended.
A qualified lawyer can help because drafting a will can be more complex than it looks: superannuation isn’t automatically dealt with in a will, children add complications, legal wording avoids ambiguity, signing and witnessing must meet jurisdiction rules, and a lawyer can advise on the best executor and beneficiary protections. Paying for legal advice is a small price to protect your wealth and ensure your wishes are followed.
Using your own words rather than legal terminology can create ambiguity about your intentions, which increases the chance of a will being disputed or interpreted differently in court. The article warns that unclear wording and statements about excluding people can actually encourage legal challenges.
Yes — courts have had to rule on the validity of home-made wills covering relatively small estates (for example, just a property and a boat), and multiple home-made wills found after death have led to protracted proceedings. These legal actions are costly and can reduce the value passed to beneficiaries.
No — the article notes that nearly everyone has superannuation, but it isn’t automatically dealt with in a will. You should get legal advice to understand how superannuation interacts with your estate planning and to ensure your wishes are implemented.
Each Australian jurisdiction has specific rules for signing and witnessing wills, and many home-made wills get this wrong. Incorrect signing or witnessing can make a will invalid or easier to challenge, so having a lawyer ensure the formalities are done correctly is important.
A lawyer can advise on who is best suited to be an executor or trustee — simply naming a family member may not be appropriate if they lack time, expertise, willingness, or if they might predecease you. Professional advice helps make sure the appointed person can properly manage the estate.
Yes — the article states that a properly drafted will can create tax and asset-protection advantages for beneficiaries. Using a lawyer for will preparation and estate planning can therefore help protect wealth and improve outcomes for those you leave behind.

