Court to settle Hancock dispute
West Australian Supreme Court judge Rene Le Miere in Perth has rejected Hancock's request to dismiss without trial the lawsuit claiming ownership of half of the company's stake in a mine being built in Western Australia.
"I am unable to reach the required level of certainty that the defence will succeed," Justice Le Miere wrote in his decision on Tuesday.
Wright Prospecting is seeking 50 per cent of Hancock Prospecting's stake in three tenements, known as Hope Downs 4, 5 and 6, according to a copy of the writ filed on September 24.
Hancock Prospecting and Rio Tinto jointly own the Hope Downs assets under a 2005 agreement.
"Wright Prospecting welcomes the judge's decision," the company said in a statement. "Wright Prospecting now intends to resume proceedings in this matter."
Hancock Prospecting's chief financial officer, Jay Newby, was not immediately available for comment.
The $1.6 billion Hope Downs 4 project, owned 50 per cent by Rio, will have annual capacity of 15 million tonnes when it starts production this year. It will be Mrs Rinehart's second operating mine after the $1 billion Hope Downs 1.
Wright Prospecting was founded by Peter Wright, who discovered the iron ore deposits with Mrs Rinehart's father, Lang Hancock. Mrs Rinehart inherited the mining assets and is chairman of the company Mr Hancock founded.
Wright Prospecting's lawsuit was "curious" as Mrs Rinehart, Asia's richest woman, announced a mining partnership for the properties with Rio Tinto more than seven years ago, Mr Newby said after the lawsuit was filed.
Wright Prospecting "waited until now, when construction of the Hope 4 mine is nearing completion, and has provided none of the significant funding required for such, to lodge such an unusual bid for unearned late participation", he said.
Wright Prospecting accused Hancock Prospecting of breach of trust for selling the property without its consent and breaches of fiduciary obligations.
Wright Prospecting sought an accounting of all profits earned by Hancock Prospecting from those assets and compensation for the breaches. It also asked the court to declare Hancock Prospecting held half the property in trust for Wright Prospecting, and to award it any proceeds from the sale and royalties.
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
The lawsuit is a mine ownership dispute in which Wright Prospecting is claiming 50% of Hancock Prospecting's stake in three Hope Downs tenements (Hope Downs 4, 5 and 6). The main parties are Wright Prospecting and Hancock Prospecting, which jointly own the Hope Downs assets with Rio Tinto under a 2005 agreement.
A West Australian Supreme Court judge, Justice Rene Le Miere, rejected Hancock Prospecting's request to dismiss the case without a trial. The judge said he could not reach the required level of certainty that Hancock's defence would succeed, so the matter will proceed to trial.
Wright Prospecting is seeking 50% of Hancock Prospecting's stake in the three tenements known as Hope Downs 4, 5 and 6, and it has also asked the court to declare Hancock held half the property in trust for Wright Prospecting.
Wright Prospecting is seeking an accounting of all profits Hancock Prospecting earned from the contested assets, compensation for alleged breaches (including breach of trust and breaches of fiduciary obligations), and any proceeds or royalties from sales of the property if the court finds in its favour.
Hancock Prospecting, through CFO Jay Newby, described the lawsuit as 'curious,' noting Wright Prospecting waited until construction of Hope Downs 4 was nearing completion and provided none of the significant funding for the project. Hancock had no immediate additional comment available.
Rio Tinto jointly owns the Hope Downs assets with Hancock Prospecting under a 2005 agreement. The disputed tenements (Hope Downs 4, 5 and 6) are part of that joint ownership structure, and Hope Downs 4 is a project owned 50% by Rio.
Hope Downs 4 is a $1.6 billion project that, according to the article, will have annual capacity of 15 million tonnes when it starts production this year. It is described as Gina Rinehart's second operating mine after Hope Downs 1.
Wright Prospecting was founded by Peter Wright, who discovered the iron ore deposits together with Lang Hancock, Gina Rinehart's father. Gina Rinehart inherited the mining assets and is chairman of the company her father founded, Hancock Prospecting.
Call 1300 880 160
Start a chat
Schedule a call
