Construct your own portfolio
As the name suggests, model trains are the usual priority but on the first Monday of September the main attraction was Meccano.
Two significant collections were listed for sale, including some sets in mint condition in the original packaging. These, which still had stickers from the David Jones store in Elizabeth Street where they were bought in the 1950s, were apparently never used. They were being sold by descendants of the original owner.
The sale of mint-condition Meccano was rare enough for three Sydney collectors to book rooms overnight at a nearby hotel.
Meccano sets were originally numbered one to 10, with value and rarity increasing numerically.
Nos.1 to 5 are the ones most likely to be found in junk shops, usually incomplete and overpriced. They fetch $50 or less at auction. No.10 is the holy grail for collectors, and one of these in mint condition sold for $6000 through TPA before the global financial crisis came along to spoil the fun.
Keith Mentiplay from TPA says a mint No.10 would now be worth about $4000. He estimates that overall, prices for vintage toys are down 60 per cent on pre-GFC values but reckons a mint-condition Meccano No.10 is still a handy investment.
That's if you can find one.
None were at this month's auction but a No.9 was, and it sold for $650, considered a real bargain by other collectors. A No.8 in very good condition also sold for $650. Estimates for both were about the $1000 mark but the vendors who inherited this collection were still delighted, and probably surprised, with the results.
A No.8A set sold for $600. The A-prefix sets were sold as additions to an existing set. For example, the 8A upgrades the standard No.8 set to a No.9.
Also valuable are special-edition kits and Meccano after-market accessories such as electric motors and transformers. A 20-volt electric motor sold for $60 and a transformer for $80. These are needed to transform the larger Meccano models into spectacular working machinery.
According to the 1950s hierarchy, only spoilt brats would have working models in their bedrooms. The railway service crane, as featured on the lids of the more expensive boxes, is the best-known example. Spoilt brats could also build an Eiffel Tower, cargo ship and a working boom bridge.
These days, however, the vintage sets that are bought at auction are more likely to remain unused.
"Most of the older buyers collect them just to have them," Mentiplay says. "Only the younger people tend to build them."
The Meccano concept was patented in 1901 by Frank Hornby, an inventor from Liverpool, England, who also gave the world Hornby model trains. Meccano is still produced today - made in China - although the majority of collectors prefer examples from the classic "red and green" period. The colours changed to yellow and black in 1964, and these definitely affect value. A No.8 in yellow and black sold for $300 this month, half that of an equivalent red-and-green set.
TPA's monthly auctions attract a core group of Australian online bidders plus regulars from Britain, the US, Brazil, Argentina and New Zealand. A collector from the Netherlands snapped up the No.8A set that other bidders thought was a steal at $600.
Mentiplay says he now has 4000 collectors registered for online catalogues and about 100 regulars follow the auctions. The second tranche of the larger collection of Meccano listed this month will appear later this year. Most of the items are in exceptional condition.
The cultural significance of Meccano should not be underestimated. Mentiplay says it was responsible for producing a generation of mechanically advanced young men (and we assume some women). He's noticed that many of those now investing in retro Meccano have had successful careers in engineering and mechanics.
For details of the auctions, see antiquetoys.com.au.
For a gallery of highlights from the Meccano auction, see theage.com.au/money
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
Value is driven by rarity (the original No.1–No.10 hierarchy), condition (mint in original packaging is worth much more), original colours (classic red-and-green are preferred to post-1964 yellow-and-black), completeness (including A‑prefix upgrade kits), special‑edition kits and after‑market accessories (motors, transformers), and provenance (original store stickers or family ownership).
According to Trains, Planes & Automobiles (TPA), a mint No.10 that sold for about $6,000 before the global financial crisis would be worth roughly $4,000 today — reflecting a wider vintage toy market that Mentiplay estimates is around 60% down on pre‑GFC values.
Meccano can be a collectible investment if you focus on rarity and condition — mint No.10s and classic red‑and‑green sets remain sought after. TPA’s specialist says a mint No.10 is still a ‘handy investment,’ but overall vintage‑toy prices have fallen since the pre‑GFC peak, so collectors should weigh rarity, condition and long‑term demand.
TPA (Trains, Planes & Automobiles) runs monthly auctions from an Anglican church hall in Mount Victoria and has shops across the road and at Annandale in Sydney’s inner west. Online catalogues and auction details are listed at antiquetoys.com.au, and TPA reports about 4,000 registered collectors for its online catalogues.
Smaller/common sets (Nos. 1–5) often fetch $50 or less. In the recent TPA sale a No.9 and a very good No.8 both sold for about $650 (estimates had been near $1,000). An 8A sold for $600. After‑market items: a 20‑volt electric motor went for $60 and a transformer for $80.
Collectors generally prefer the classic red‑and‑green Meccano produced before 1964. Sets made after the colour change to yellow‑and‑black typically command lower prices — for example, a No.8 in yellow‑and‑black recently sold for $300, about half the price of an equivalent red‑and‑green set.
A‑prefix sets were sold as additions to upgrade an existing set (for example, an 8A upgrades a standard No.8 to a No.9). Collectors value A‑prefix kits because they help complete a set and increase its desirability and often its auction price.
TPA notes a mix of older buyers who collect Meccano to preserve it and younger people who still build models. Culturally, Meccano (patented in 1901 by Frank Hornby) is credited with inspiring generations of mechanically skilled people, and many of today’s retro‑Meccano investors went on to careers in engineering and mechanics.

