Commission backs reform of approvals
The commission also calls for "evidence-based" controls over coal seam gas activity where controls have been in a state of "flux".
The report comes as explorers have been cutting spending amid declining commodity prices and rising economic uncertainty, with many operators complaining of the amount of "red tape" and duplication between state and federal governments when seeking exploration approvals.
And spending on new export gas projects in Queensland and northern Australia is close to peaking, prompting concerns this will lead to an economic slowdown. This, in turn, has put the focus on the exploration sector to begin picking up some of the slack.
Much of the duplication can be resolved if an earlier agreement by federal and state governments to coordinate in areas of "national environmental significance" is implemented.
"Progress towards achieving this reform has halted," the commission notes.
It also calls for an end to duplication in offshore exploration, with the National Offshore Petroleum Safety and Environmental Management Authority to be given full control over environmental assessment, instead of it being shared by two agencies as is the case now. State governments should also cede their control in this area to the agency, it says.
The commission highlights the need for an "evidence-based" approach in coal seam gas exploration. "Regulation of [coal seam gas] exploration activities should be directed towards maximising the economic, social and environmental benefit of the use of the land for the whole community," it notes, taking aim at those opposed to such developments.
"Scientific uncertainty should not lead to poor regulatory processes or decisions," the commission says. "A precautionary approach should be adopted where there is concern of substantial or permanent damage.
"A lack of certainty should not be used to justify a lack of action to mitigate or prevent such damage."
The report notes that after a period of poor community involvement, some exploration companies are now more than meeting government requirements in an attempt to gain the "social licence" to explore.
Twice as many people work in exploration now than a decade ago, the commission says, although the absolute number peaked in 2008 and declined after the global financial crisis, with growth resuming at long-term rates.
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
The Productivity Commission said greater coordination and higher transparency are needed between federal and state governments for resource exploration approvals, and urged implementation of an earlier agreement to coordinate in areas of "national environmental significance" to reduce duplication and delay.
The report notes that duplication and "red tape" between state and federal approvals has led many explorers to cut spending amid falling commodity prices and economic uncertainty — a factor that can slow project timelines and affect investor confidence in exploration assets.
The Productivity Commission recommends giving the National Offshore Petroleum Safety and Environmental Management Authority full control over offshore environmental assessment (instead of split responsibility across two agencies) and having states cede control, which could reduce duplication and provide clearer, more predictable approvals for offshore projects.
The commission called for "evidence-based" controls for coal seam gas exploration, saying regulation should aim to maximise economic, social and environmental benefits for the whole community; it also urged a precautionary approach where there is risk of substantial or permanent damage and warned scientific uncertainty should not lead to poor regulatory decisions.
Yes — the report flags that spending on new export gas projects in Queensland and northern Australia is close to peaking, raising concerns about a broader slowdown, and suggests the exploration sector may need to pick up some of that slack as larger project spending moderates.
The report says that after a period of poor community involvement, some exploration companies are now exceeding government requirements to win a "social licence" to explore — meaning good community engagement can help secure approvals, reduce opposition-related delays and support project viability, which matters to investors assessing project risk.
According to the commission, there are now twice as many people working in exploration as a decade ago, although the absolute number peaked in 2008, fell after the global financial crisis, and only later resumed growth at long-term rates.
If reforms are implemented — such as better federal-state coordination, reduced duplication in offshore assessment, and clearer evidence-based CSG rules — investors could see faster, more transparent approvals and less regulatory uncertainty, which may improve project timelines and investment clarity.

