InvestSMART

CBD

Downgraded but not downcast
By · 18 Jun 2013
By ·
18 Jun 2013
comments Comments
Downgraded but not downcast

When is a downgrade not a downgrade? When it's a "solid result in line with market expectations", of course.

On Monday developer Lend Lease said it reckoned the construction market has "softened", sending its share price down 7.5 per cent.

Nonetheless, chief executive Steve McCann, pictured, appeared chuffed. "It is pleasing to be on track to deliver a solid result in line with market expectations in a tough market environment," he said.

The company reckons it will have no trouble making up the difference from other divisions. And analysts came to McCann's party late in the day, with JP Morgan and Morgan Stanley issuing fresh "buy" reports.

No doubt McCann's sunny disposition would be even further improved if top-tier accounting company PwC, said to be looking for new digs, would call up and book in as anchor tenant for the proposed third tower at Lend Lease's multi-billion dollar Barangaroo South development.

Quest for NZ gold

It's gold, gold, gold for Australia with former Sydney Olympics bid boss Rod McGeoch set to seize control of New Zealand's airwaves.

McGeoch, who spearheaded Sydney's winning 2000 games bid, and other investors are set to take over MediaWorks, which owns radio stations and the TV3 and Channel 4 television networks.

However, the history of the Kiwi media group, which collapsed on Monday, is littered with the corpses of Aussie business types.

Australian private equity outfit Ironbridge paid $NZ740 million to privatise MediaWorks in 2007, loading it up with debt.

The structure didn't survive the GFC, leaving banks, including Australia's Westpac, locked in argument with Ironbridge about refinancing the stricken company.

Also a loser was the Ten Network, which last year foolishly laid out large amounts of money to import TV3 "star" Paul Henry to host its ill-fated breakfast show.

However, there is one Australian winner in the saga: KordaMentha, which has picked up the gig as receiver.

Power struggles

Could control of troubled electricity and gas retailer EnergyAustralia move from Hong Kong to the Cayman Islands?

CBD hears talk that Hong Kong's China Light and Power, which owns EnergyAustralia, is considering a trade sale, possibly to Alinta Energy.

The Alinta business was taken over by its lender, private equity group TPG, in 2011. It's now owned by Alinta Holdings, which gives its address as Ugland House, in Cayman capital George Town.

A China Light and Power spokeswoman said the company's position on floating EnergyAustralia remained the same as last year, when it canned the idea due to "operational imperatives and [the] general economic environment".

But she was less emphatic about a trade sale. "We have consistently said that we do not rule out any options but we have no current plans on a trade sale," she said.

If control does pass to TPG, decision-making power won't make the trip all the way to the Caymans. TPG's Asia Pacific boss, Steve Schneider, who is on the Alinta board, lives right there on Hong Kong island.

Mystery money

It seems Sydney Institute boss and Fairfax Media columnist Gerard Henderson is rather less keen on answering questions than he is on asking them.

Last Wednesday, CBD sent Henderson a list of questions about the institute's 2012 financial accounts, which were filed (overdue) that day. CBD was keen to know the source or sources of $859,000, described in the accounts as "contributions received". Not from members, clearly - the accounts show "membership subscriptions" brought in just $82,677.

So who are these mysterious contributors? And how many members does the institute have, anyway? Readers may be unsurprised to learn that Henderson has yet to say.

Got a tip?

bbutler@fairfaxmedia.com.au
Google News
Follow us on Google News
Go to Google News, then click "Follow" button to add us.
Share this article and show your support
Free Membership
Free Membership
InvestSMART
InvestSMART
Keep on reading more articles from InvestSMART. See more articles
Join the conversation
Join the conversation...
There are comments posted so far. Join the conversation, please login or Sign up.

Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…

Lend Lease said the construction market has "softened," which pushed its share price down about 7.5%. CEO Steve McCann said the business is still "on track to deliver a solid result in line with market expectations," and the company expects to make up any shortfall from other divisions. Analysts from JP Morgan and Morgan Stanley later issued fresh "buy" reports on the stock.

Not necessarily. The article describes the situation as a downgrade "but not downcast": management signalled results are in line with expectations and major brokers issued buy recommendations. Everyday investors should weigh the construction market softness against management's guidance and analyst views, but the coverage in the article suggests concern rather than an outright crisis.

The article says top-tier accounting firm PwC is said to be looking for new office space and could book in as anchor tenant for Lend Lease's proposed third tower at Barangaroo South. That kind of anchor tenant would be positive for the project's leasing prospects.

MediaWorks collapsed on Monday and investors led by Rod McGeoch (the former Sydney Olympics bid boss) are set to take control. The group's history includes a 2007 privatisation by Australian private equity firm Ironbridge for NZ$740 million that left it heavily indebted and vulnerable during the Global Financial Crisis. Banks, including Australia's Westpac, were then locked in disputes over refinancing. For investors, this highlights risks around leveraged takeovers and media businesses under heavy debt.

The article points to winners and losers: KordaMentha picked up the role as receiver (a clear winner), while previous investors and some Australian media players suffered. The Ten Network is mentioned as a loser for spending heavily to import TV3 personality Paul Henry for an ill-fated breakfast show.

CBD reported talk that Hong Kong's China Light and Power (CLP), which owns EnergyAustralia, is considering a trade sale — possibly to Alinta Energy. A CLP spokeswoman said the company's position on floating EnergyAustralia remained the same as last year (when the idea was canned because of "operational imperatives and [the] general economic environment") and added that while they "do not rule out any options" they have "no current plans on a trade sale."

The article notes that if control passed to TPG (the private equity group that previously took over Alinta), decision-making wouldn't necessarily move to the Cayman Islands. TPG's Asia Pacific boss, Steve Schneider, who sits on the Alinta board, lives on Hong Kong island, implying regional management could remain in Asia even if ownership is structured offshore.

The institute's 2012 financial accounts show $859,000 described as "contributions received," while membership subscriptions were only $82,677. CBD asked Sydney Institute boss and columnist Gerard Henderson for details about the source(s) of the contributions and membership numbers, but Henderson had not responded by the time of the article.