Waterhouse looks part but ...
Australia's most-hated bookmaker, Tom Waterhouse, sure seems to be doing well.
His suits are nicely tailored and his shirts look made of fine cotton. His marriage took place in a picturesque Sicilian village.
And his bookmaking operation, part-owned by dad Robbie, has been splashing cash around, reportedly becoming the highest-spending advertiser in the sports betting industry. His inescapability has made him a voodoo doll for anti-punt activists, but has it paid off?
It's difficult to say. While he's reportedly been offered $500 million for the business, Tom Waterhouse NT, which holds his bookie ticket, doesn't file financial accounts.
But it is possible to say that despite the advertising blitz (and free publicity due to mum Gai's blow-up with well-seasoned adman John Singleton) he doesn't lay claim to a huge slice of punters' money. Totalisator giant Tabcorp still dominates the $25 billion a year wagering market, with about 44 per cent. The rest of the totes hold about 25 per cent, betting exchange Betfair has 6.3 per cent and corporate bookies, of which Tom Waterhouse is just one, hold about 24 per cent.
Industry estimates are that Waterhouse has about 10 per cent of the corporate bookie market, giving him just 2.5 per cent of the total market. This despite spending a reported $10 million - too much for his much larger rivals to spend - on the infamous marketing deal with the Nine Network that catapulted him into lounge rooms, and infamy, as a pseudo-commentator.
Canny fund manager Geoff Wilson has emerged as kingmaker in a newly reignited stoush between former Ausbil Dexia workmates Paul Xiradis and Reub Hayes over undervalued investment company Emerging Leaders Investments (ELI).
Hayes, who was one of Ausbil Dexia's owners back in the day, last month tried to turf ELI's board, including Xiradis, but the company rejected his call for a shareholder meeting as "invalid".
On Monday, Hayes said he would call his own meeting at which he would ask shareholders to evict Xiradis, John Evans and John Skippen from the boardroom and replace them with himself, fellow Treasury Group director Peter Kennedy and investment banker Matthew Stubbs. Hayes, who owns 5.7 per cent of ELI through his super fund Solhurst, complained that an $8.2 million capital-raising last month was priced at 82¢, a steep discount to ELI's net tangible asset backing of about $1.01 at the time.
Interestingly, the one-for-four share issue was partly underwritten by Ausbil, which is run by Xiradis and manages ELI's investments. However, despite a shortfall in the capital-raising Ausbil had to lay out less than $200,000 because Xiradis generously put his hands in his own pockets and stumped up an extra $850,000, above his entitlement, to buy more shares. He now owns 4.3 per cent of ELI.
Hayes also complained that shareholders who didn't take up their entitlement have been diluted and Ausbil given a 20 per cent rise in its base management fee.
In addition to changing the board, Hayes wants to declare a special dividend and offer shareholders a buyback at the company's net tangible asset backing. "I've had lengthy dialogue with the board over the past four months and been stonewalled," Hayes told CBD. "All we're really seeking is for the board to recognise that the shareholders want value out of it."
Given scrip is trading at about 82¢ and NTA is around 97.2¢, Hayes' proposal would seem very attractive for Wilson's Wilson Asset Management, which has bought as much of the stock as it can - 19.9 per cent.
Wilson was inscrutable on Monday when CBD asked his intentions. "What I find is the best thing is to see clearly what their [Solhurst] proposition is and clearly what the ELI proposition is," he said. Pressed, he admitted that if there was a franked special dividend, "we'd enjoy that", and that it would "be tough" to resist a buyback at a premium.
Got a tip?
Waterhouse looks part but ...
Want access to our latest research and new buy ideas?
Start a free 15 day trial and gain access to our research, recommendations and market-beating model portfolios.Sign up for free