CBD
IN HIS wild and woolly attack on Whitehaven Coal last year, Singaporean bogannaire Nathan Tinkler famously complained that boss Tony Haggarty's "cows at Gunnedah see more of him than his management team".
On Thursday, after announcing his retirement, Haggarty finally responded: "They will now!"
Haggarty owns about 3.3 per cent of Whitehaven, worth $98 million, and sounded relieved to be finally quitting his last executive role. After he reaped $220 million from his sale of Excel Coal in 2006, he joined the board of Whitehaven as a non-executive.
Haggarty says when he took over the managing director's job in 2008 it was meant to be a temporary arrangement. Oops: "It's been 4.5 years," he said.
And there won't be any largesse on the way out - Haggarty is on a 30-day contract. Chairman Mark Vaile was full of praise yesterday, saying Haggarty had even knocked back a pay rise last year despite a recommendation from the remuneration consultants. "That's Tony," said Vaile.
APN drops out
EVEN Rupert Murdoch manages to shuffle to the end of a scratchy old phone line when he needs to communicate with mere mortals, but not even the quiet hiss of digital static greeted long-suffering investors in troubled media group APN who tried to tune in to the company's results webcast on Wednesday.
CEO Brett Chenoweth and independent directors Melinda Conrad, John Harvey and John Maasland self-defenestrated earlier this week following a stoush with major shareholders Independent News & Media and Allan Gray.
With chief financial officer Jeff Howard only a few months into the job, apparently no one was qualified to give the usual riveting corporate presentation to analysts or media.
Both briefings were canned, with the group instead dropping word that it had lost $456 million
in 2012 (about 10 times more
than in 2011) at 8.30am and retreating behind a wall of dignified silence.
"The issues going on in this company are very unusual and I don't think they're going to conduct themselves like this in the future," BBY analyst Mark McDonnell told CBD.
He said the standard of disclosure in the media sector had improved dramatically in recent years, singling out Fairfax Media for praise.
"But it's not just Fairfax - if you look at Seven West, Seven used to be absolutely appalling in terms of the information they provided to the market."
Guarding the rage
CBD'S boss of bosses, Fairfax Media chief executive Greg Hywood, was disclosing strong and long on Wednesday as he announced the company's latest financial results.
The target of his ire: Pommy rag The Guardian, which has climbed into bed with millionaire Wotif founder Graeme Wood to establish a cybernetic beachhead in Australia. "The Guardian is an extremely good brand in some suburbs of London, it's not a strong competitive brand in Australia," Hywood told analysts. "The brands that dominate the public agenda in this country are Fairfax brands and, to give our direct competitors credit, News Ltd brands."
Wood will no doubt be hoping that the Australian Grauniad does better than his last effort, The Global Mail, which appears to be scrolling sideways into the sunset.
Village opens up
IN A move as dramatic as some of the movies they produce, the triumvirate that rules Village Roadshow has relaxed its grip on the notoriously closely held entertainment group, with managing director Graham Burke and directors Robert and John Kirby reducing their controlling interest on Wednesday.
Deutsche Bank spent the day hawking 11 million shares, representing about 7 per cent of the company, in a bookbuild worth at least $46 million that attracted between 20 and 30 institutional investors.
Burke and the Kirbys hope that by reducing their interest in Village from 51 per cent to 44 per cent, the company will become eligible for membership of the ASX 300 index and attract institutional investors.
It's a remarkable change in approach from a group that has in the past left observers wondering why it bothers with an ASX listing.
The three were reluctant to drop below 50 per cent but "otherwise institutions won't enter the register because it's too tightly held", Burke told CBD. He was keen to talk up the prospects of the company, which also announced an 18 per cent increase in profit to $33.4 million for the half-year.
Apparently the theme park business is going great guns and the coming film adaptation of The Great Gatsby is "ready for release".
"We've seen the movie, it's fantastic," Burke said.
"Leonardo DiCaprio hasn't looked as good since Titanic in a romantic lead role."
Got a tip?
bbutler@fairfaxmedia.com.au
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
Tony Haggarty announced his retirement after serving as Whitehaven Coal's managing director (a role he took on in 2008 that was meant to be temporary). He’s on a 30-day contract with no special exit payment and was praised by chairman Mark Vaile. Investors should note the orderly nature of the exit and the board’s positive comments, but watch for any further management announcements from Whitehaven Coal.
According to the article, Tony Haggarty owns about 3.3% of Whitehaven Coal, which was valued at roughly $98 million. The piece also notes his earlier windfall of $220 million from the 2006 sale of Excel Coal.
APN cancelled its scheduled briefings after a management shake-up: CEO Brett Chenoweth and several independent directors resigned following a dispute with major shareholders (Independent News & Media and Allan Gray). With a recently appointed CFO only a few months into the role, the group delivered the results via announcement instead of a live webcast. For shareholders, that means relying on the formal financial release and watching for follow-up communications as the company stabilises its board and executive team.
APN reported a loss of $456 million in 2012, which the article says is about 10 times larger than the loss recorded in 2011. That sharp deterioration is a key point for investors monitoring the media group’s recovery prospects and governance changes.
Fairfax CEO Greg Hywood was dismissive of The Guardian’s Australian push, saying The Guardian isn’t a strong competitive brand in Australia and arguing that Fairfax and News Ltd brands dominate the public agenda. Investors may care because competitive dynamics and brand strength in the Australian media market can influence advertising revenue, market share and strategy for Fairfax Media and rivals.
The controlling trio at Village Roadshow (Graham Burke and directors Robert and John Kirby) reduced their stake from 51% to about 44% by selling around 11 million shares (roughly 7% of the company) via a Deutsche Bank bookbuild that raised at least $46 million and attracted 20–30 institutional investors. The move is intended to make Village eligible for ASX 300 inclusion and to broaden the institutional investor base, which can increase liquidity and investor interest.
Village Roadshow reported an 18% increase in profit to $33.4 million for the half-year. The company highlighted strong performance in its theme-park business and optimism around upcoming film releases, including the film adaptation of The Great Gatsby.
Yes — BBY analyst Mark McDonnell told CBD that disclosure standards in the media sector have improved dramatically in recent years. He singled out Fairfax Media for praise and said other major players such as Seven West (and News Ltd by implication) have also lifted their information practices compared with the past.

