CANBERRA has been urged to spend more sensibly rather than search for new and creative ways to tax Australian businesses, according to a panel of top Australian business leaders.
Speaking at a Fairfax Media event, ANZ chairman John Morschel said governments in Australia could reduce their tax take if they were more frugal with taxpayers' funds in the first place.
"We seem to be focused on raising increased taxes and putting more impediments in the way of business when I think the focus should be on restricting our expenditure," he said.
"I think the focus needs to come back on what we are spending the money on, whether we are subsidising industries, whether we are looking at increased social benefits, whether we are looking at increased public service.
The comments come despite the Gillard government's fight to keep the federal budget in surplus.
It recently cut spending on initiatives including some baby bonuses in a bid to balance the books.
Westpac and Transurban chairman Lindsay Maxsted last year described the relationship between the government and the business community as "probably the most difficult" he had seen in his career.
He said there is still a gulf.
"There has been a massive disconnect, what concerns me most is a lack of understanding within governments that business can be, and should be, and in successful economies is, the engine of all growth."
Mr Maxsted said government typically hit the right note with its white papers and broader commentary, but rarely put those words into action with legislation.
Mr Maxsted, who also is a director of BHP Billiton, said 2012 may be remembered as the year that Australia woke up to its poor performance on productivity.
He said the mining boom created many inefficiencies in the economy, but now that the peak of the boom was behind us, "room for other players" was starting to open up.
QBE chairman Belinda Hutchinson said there also was room for governments to consider widening fringe benefits taxes that help female workers to remain in the workforce after becoming mothers.
She said there were tax incentives for large companies to install childcare facilities for working mothers, and those terms should be broadened to help small and medium enterprises.
Ms Hutchinson said that despite 55 per cent of university graduates in Australia being female, women occupied less than 10 per cent of senior management roles.
"I just think that's a crying shame and I think it's a huge waste of resources," he said.
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
How can government spending and taxation policy affect Australian businesses and everyday investors?
According to business leaders in the article, government decisions on spending and taxation can influence the cost environment for companies and the overall investment climate. ANZ chairman John Morschel urged Canberra to be more frugal with taxpayers' funds rather than continually seeking new business taxes, arguing that restricting expenditure may reduce the need to raise taxes or impose more impediments on business.
What did ANZ chairman John Morschel recommend about managing the federal budget and taxes?
John Morschel told a Fairfax Media event that the focus should shift from raising taxes to restricting expenditure. He suggested examining what governments spend on—such as industry subsidies, social benefits and public service costs—so the tax burden on businesses could be reduced by spending more sensibly.
What recent budget actions did the Gillard government take that investors should know about?
The article notes the Gillard government has been fighting to keep the federal budget in surplus and recently cut spending on some initiatives, including parts of baby bonuses, as part of efforts to balance the books. These kinds of policy moves can signal fiscal tightening and may affect consumer-facing companies and social programs.
How do business leaders describe the relationship between government and the business community?
Westpac and Transurban chairman Lindsay Maxsted described the relationship as 'probably the most difficult' he had seen, saying there is a 'massive disconnect' and a lack of understanding within government that business is the engine of growth. He also warned that governments often produce strong white papers but do not always follow through with legislation.
What did leaders say about productivity and the mining boom's impact on the economy?
Lindsay Maxsted suggested 2012 might be remembered as the year Australia woke up to poor productivity. He argued the mining boom created inefficiencies in the economy, and with the peak of the boom behind us there is 'room for other players'—a point investors may monitor as sectors reallocate capital and competition changes.
What changes to fringe benefits tax (FBT) or childcare incentives were proposed to help working mothers?
QBE chairman Belinda Hutchinson proposed widening fringe benefits tax arrangements that support female workers staying in the workforce after becoming mothers. She noted existing tax incentives for large companies to provide onsite childcare and suggested similar terms should be broadened to help small and medium enterprises.
What does the article say about women's representation in senior management and workforce participation?
The article cites Belinda Hutchinson observing that while 55% of Australian university graduates are female, women occupy less than 10% of senior management roles. She described this as a wasted resource and suggested policy incentives could help retain skilled women in the workforce.
What should everyday investors watch in light of the issues raised by these business leaders?
Based on the article, investors should watch government fiscal policy (spending cuts or tax changes), progress on productivity reforms as the mining boom recedes, shifts in industry incentives such as childcare or FBT changes that affect employers, and how effectively governments turn policy ideas into legislation—each can influence sector performance and corporate profitability.