BHP call makes baby-boomer sense
There are two ways of looking at the rates BHP Billiton has offered to secure $US5 billion in pocket money in a global placement of three-year, five-year, 10-year and 30-year debt.
The first view is short term. Like other top corporations, BHP is paying more for debt that it did a year ago, or even a few months ago. You might like to blame the US Federal Reserve, but in fact you shouldn't blame anybody: rising rates are an appetiser on an economic recovery menu, as long as they don't get out of hand.
The second view is long term, and by long term I mean baby-boomer long term. Boards are stuffed with baby boomers. They remember what steep borrowing costs look like, and know they don't look anything like this.
They know too that five years from now the markets will probably be rewarding companies that took advantage of the cheap money while it lasted, and are carefully backing their intuition. BHP's latest raising is, for example, loaded with long-dated debt that locks in lower debt-servicing costs.
BHP is issuing $US500 million worth of three-year floating-rate notes that will yield a quarter of a percentage point more than the 90-day US-dollar London interbank (Libor) lending rate. The US-dollar Libor rate is currently 0.25 per cent, so that dough has a start-up debt-service cost of 0.5 per cent a year.
It has raised another $US500 million with five-year notes priced at 2.05 per cent, and has raised $US1.5 billion with 10-year notes that pay 3.85 per cent.
By far the biggest whack, $US2.5 billion, or 50 per cent of the total amount raised, has been slotted away for no less than 30 years, at a rate of 5 per cent.
Corporate debt is more expensive than it was recently. In February last year, for example, BHP raised $US5.25 billion, including $US1 billion of 10-year money at 2.875 per cent, and another $1 billion of 30-year funding at a rate of 4.125 per cent.
Comparisons become more difficult when money is raised in different currencies because it costs money to swap it, but the group also paid 3.23 per cent for 750 million Canadian dollars over 10 years in May this year, and 3.125 per cent over 10 years in April for €750 million.
The increase basically reflects the fact that the global economy is in better shape. Concern that Europe's sovereign debt crisis would reignite the global crisis were escalating when BHP approached the debt markets in February last year, and did not peak until late July, when European Central Bank President Mario Draghi delivered his "what it takes" statement, the market's equivalent of Dirty Harry's "go ahead - make my day" line.
The US Federal Reserve's warnings since April that it is preparing to phase out its $US85 billion-a-month quantitative easing program is a component of the recovery trend. The QE taper didn't begin this month as most expected, but it will start soon; and when it does, liquidity will tighten. Yields and rates have already moved up in anticipation.
Boardroom baby boomers know, however, that corporate loan money is still cheap by historical standards. Since the global crisis hit, top-grade corporations have been a lending safe harbour.
BHP's latest 10-year rate of 3.85 per cent compares, for example, with a Spanish 10-year government debt yield of 4.28 per cent, and a yield of 3.88 per cent on AAA-rated 10-year Australian government debt (BHP 's 10-year tranche would cost half a percentage point more than that if it were swapped from US dollars to Australian dollars, but it probably won't be).
Corporate borrowing rates are back to where they were in the 1950s, and about a third of what they were as central banks struggled to squeeze inflation out of the global system in the wake of the OPEC oil price shocks in 1973 and 1979.
A blended corporate bond yield index run by Moody's moved above 4 per cent in 1958, and was above 9 per cent going into the 1973 oil price shock. It went above 10 per cent in 1979, and peaked at 15.49 per cent in 1981. It was back down below 6 per cent by 2003, hit a low of 3.47 per cent in October last year, and is currently 4.54 per cent.
Maybe rates will stay low. History tells us these are unusual times and that money supply injections are inflationary. The global crisis has resulted in the mother of all money injections, and highly rated companies such as BHP are borrowing over longer terms to lock in low rates while they are available. In doing so they buttress profits and the economic recovery.
In February last year, BHP raised $US1 billion over 10 years and $US1 billion over 30 years. Each tranche equated to 18 per cent of the $5.25 billion total raising, and at June 30 this year BHP's debt portfolio had an average term of 7.4 years.
In its latest $US5 billion raising, it has lifted the 10-year tranche to $US1.5 billion, but it is the leap from $US1 billion to $US2.5 billion over 30 years that is the big call: by the time it is embedded, the average tenure of BHP's debt will have risen to almost nine years.
The Maiden family owns BHP shares.
InvestSMART FORUM: Come and meet the team
We're loading up the van and going on tour from April to June, with events on the NSW central & north coast, the QLD mid-north coast and in Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney and Canberra. Come and meet the team and take home simple strategies that you can use to build an investment portfolio to weather any storm. Book your spot here.
Want access to our latest research and new buy ideas?
Start a free 15 day trial and gain access to our research, recommendations and market-beating model portfolios.Sign up for free