The strategy To keep my self-managed super fund out of trouble with in-house assets and related-party transactions.
Do I need to do that? These things keep cropping up in the Tax Office's compliance program and this year it will be paying particular attention to non-arm's length transactions in pension funds. It says pension income (which is tax exempt) does not include non-arm's length income, so some funds are getting their claims wrong. The head of technical services at SuperIQ, Kate Anderson, says non-arm's length income is taxed at 45 per cent.
Broadly speaking, Anderson says, income is regarded as non-arm's length if it comes from a scheme or investment in which the parties weren't dealing with each other at arm's length, and if it is more than the fund might have expected to get if those parties had been dealing with each other at arm's length.
For example, she says income received by a self-managed fund as a beneficiary of a discretionary trust is non-arm's length income and would be taxed at the higher rate.
The Tax Office says it will contact 3000 pension funds this year to encourage voluntary amendments.
So I'm OK if my fund isn't a pension fund or isn't receiving this sort of income? Not at all. As a general rule, all super funds are required to invest on a commercial, non-arm's length basis. The Tax Office says it will also review 100 self-managed funds this year to ensure they are complying with this requirement. Anderson says there are specific rules in the super laws relating to related-party transactions and in-house assets that all funds must comply with.
What are the rules? Unless an exception applies, the Tax Office says self-managed funds generally can't lend money or provide financial assistance to related parties or buy assets from them.
A related party is any person, including the member themselves, who is related to you out to second cousins or any entity that is controlled by a related party, such as the fund's employer sponsor.
Anderson says an exemption to the ban on related-party transactions allows super funds to buy listed securities or widely held trusts at market price or business real property (a technical term meaning the property must be used solely for business) from related parties, so long as the purchase is made on commercial terms.
Business real property can also be leased to a related party at a commercial rent. For assets that don't fit the exemption there is a provision for a small amount of the fund's value to be invested in in-house assets.
OK, I'll bite. What is that? This limits assets bought from related parties, along with investments in or loans to related parties and assets that are leased to related parties, to no more than 5 per cent of the total fund's assets.
Those exempt assets referred to earlier are also exempt from this rule.
The problem with the in-house assets test, Anderson says, is that it applies on a daily basis. So if your fund also owns shares and those shares fall in value, you could inadvertently breach the 5 per cent limit without changing your investments.
This caused problems for many self-managed funds during the global financial crisis.
She says funds also need to be aware of the sole purpose test - an overarching requirement that all investments made by the fund be made solely for the purpose of providing retirement benefits.
So if you enter into a transaction because you want to help your business or free up funds for personal use, you'll run foul of the super rules even though you may be under the 5 per cent limit.
Twitter: @sampsonsmh
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
What is non-arm's length income and how does it affect my self-managed super fund (SMSF)?
Non-arm's length income is income the fund receives from a transaction where the parties weren't dealing at arm's length and the result is better than what would be expected on commercial terms. For SMSFs, non-arm's length income is not treated as tax-exempt pension income and is taxed at the higher rate (45%), so it can have a major tax impact on pension-phase funds.
Are pension payments from an SMSF always tax free, even if they include related-party income?
No. While pension income is generally tax-exempt, income that is non-arm's length is excluded from that exemption. If a pension fund receives non-arm's length income it cannot claim it as tax-free and that income may be taxed at 45%.
What counts as a related party for SMSF related-party transactions?
A related party can be a person related to you out to second cousins, the member themselves, or any entity controlled by a related party—examples include the fund's employer sponsor. Related-party rules are broad and apply to loans, financial assistance and purchases from those parties unless a clear exception applies.
What related-party transactions are allowed for SMSFs and what are the exceptions?
Exceptions allow an SMSF to buy listed securities or widely held trusts from related parties at market price, and to buy or lease business real property (property used solely for business) on commercial terms. Business real property can also be leased to a related party at a commercial rent. Other related-party dealings are generally prohibited unless another specific exception applies.
What is the in‑house assets 5% rule for SMSFs and why does it matter?
The in-house assets rule limits the value of assets acquired from related parties, loans to related parties, or assets leased to related parties to no more than 5% of the fund's total assets. Exempt assets (like listed securities bought on market) are excluded. The rule is applied daily, so falls in the value of other assets can push a fund over the 5% limit unintentionally.
Why does the daily testing of in‑house assets matter for everyday investors?
Because the 5% in-house assets test is calculated every day, normal market declines in other holdings (for example, share price falls) can increase the in-house assets proportion and cause an inadvertent breach. This was a common issue for many SMSFs during the global financial crisis.
What is the sole purpose test and how can it cause compliance problems for SMSFs?
The sole purpose test requires SMSF investments to be made only to provide retirement benefits. Transactions entered into to help your business or to free up funds for personal use—rather than to benefit members' retirement—breach the sole purpose test even if the fund stays within the 5% in-house-assets limit.
Is the ATO increasing compliance checks on pension funds and SMSFs, and what might that mean for me?
Yes. The Tax Office plans to contact about 3,000 pension funds this year to encourage voluntary amendments where required, and will review about 100 self-managed funds to check compliance with commercial, arm's-length investing rules. If contacted, funds may be asked to correct declarations or make voluntary amendments to avoid penalties.