America puts the heat on Chinese solar

America has met expectations by imposing a tariff on solar imports from China, but will Beijing fight back?

The United States hit Chinese solar companies with punitive import tariffs of 30 per cent or more on Thursday, ruling they had dumped cut-price solar panels into the US market.

In the latest salvo in a series of ongoing trade disputes between Beijing and Washington, the US Commerce Department said it sided with US-based solar companies that had complained a wave of Chinese imports had wrongly undercut their pricing and forced several renewable players out of business.

With Thursday's move, Washington set tariffs on shipments from most of the top Chinese exporters, including Suntech Power Holdings Co Ltd and Trina Solar Ltd, at about 31 per cent.

Several of the Chinese companies and a solar trade group opposed to the tariffs denounced the duties, and said they would drive up costs for the clean energy source, stunting its fast growth.

The new tariff was "a heavy blow to America's solar industry," Jigar Shah, head of the anti-tariff Coalition for Affordable Solar Energy, said.

Shah said he hoped the tariffs would be reduced before they are finalised later this year, since they would likely cost thousands of jobs in the nascent industry.

The new US ruling stems from a complaint filed last October by t he US subsidiary of Germany's SolarWorld AG , and six other US companies that alleged unfair competition and had sought duties well above 100 per cent.

China will criticise the move, according to White & Case trade attorney Scott Lincicome, "but it's unlikely to further enflame bilateral trade tensions because high anti-dumping duties were widely expected."

China's solar companies, which hold more than 60 per cent of the global market, have largely relied on subsidised markets in Europe and the United States in recent years for purchases of their products, prompting criticism that huge loans from Chinese state-run banks and low-ball pricing gave the Chinese companies an unfair advantage.

Under the decision, 59 Chinese solar companies that petitioned the US government in the case will also face an import duty of about 31 per cent, including Yingli Green Energy , LDK Solar, Canadian Solar, Hanwha Solar One, JA Solar Holding and Jinko Solar .

Other Chinese companies could now face a 250 per cent tariff, although those levels could be altered before the final ruling is issued from the Commerce Department in the coming months.

"Today, SolarWorld and the many industry players who embrace the sustainable efficiency gains and price declines that come from fair competition can take heart that the US government is standing up against Big China Solar," Gordon Brinser, president of SolarWorld Industries America, said in a statement.

The US ruling, retroactive to cover imports dating back 90 days, comes two months after Washington set more modest tariffs of less than 5 per cent o n imports from China because of what it deemed Beijing's unfair support for its solar industry.

Chinese solar companies and critics of the SolarWorld complaint say global competition has been crucial to bringing down the cost of renewable power, which still relies on government subsidies to compete with fossil fuels such as coal and natural gas.

Suntech, the world's largest manufacturer of solar panels and which also operates a panel plant in Arizona, denied it had sold its products below its cost of production and said it opposed any trade barriers.

"All leading companies in the global solar industry want to see a trade war averted. We need more competition and innovation, not litigation," Andrew Beebe, Suntech's chief commercial officer, said in a statement.

Shares of US-based solar companies rose on the news, with First Solar Inc gaining 6.7 per cent and Sunpower Corp gaining 10 per cent. Sunpower Corp was already rallying after Apple Inc said it would use the company's solar panels for its solar farm.

US-listed shares of Chinese solar companies dipped, particularly Yingli Green Energy, which was off 13 per cent, while Suntech dropped 5.8 per cent and Trina fell 7.9 per cent.

Sparring on trade

President Barack Obama, running for re-election in November, has promised to crack down on what he said were unfair Chinese trade practices. In March, Washington challenged China's export restrictions on critical ‘rare earth’ industrial materials in a complaint, together with the European Union and Japan, to the World Trade Organization.

Chinese government officials have previously threatened to impose trade duties on US shipments of polysilicon, the key material used in solar panels, if the US moved to penalise Chinese solar companies.

Solar panel prices tumbled by more than 50 per cent since the beginning of 2011 amid a glut of supplies triggered by declining subsidies in Europe and rapid global growth in the production capacity of solar wafers, cells and panels.

That steep solar price drop forced many companies in Europe and the United States into bankruptcy and decimated the once-lucrative margins across the industry.

Among those casualties was Solyndra, the California-based start-up that shuttered operations last year after taking more than $500 million in US loans, prompting criticism that the Obama administration was favouring uncompetitive renewable power.

Morningstar Equity Research analyst Stephen Simko said new duties would not halt the drop in solar panel prices, predicting that the US market will attract imports from Japan, Europe and even Chinese-owned factories in other countries.

"The United States is not a large enough portion of the market to alter those dynamics," he said.

The US solar market doubled in size last year, but remains less than 10 per cent of the overall global demand, and is likely to be overtaken this year by purchases in China for the first time.

Lawyers for SolarWorld have said Chinese exports of solar cells and modules swelled to $2.8 billion in 2011 from $1.2 billion in 2010, exceeding even the sharp growth that saw US solar installations double last year.

Still, Chinese companies have not been immune to the pain. Market analysts have said many smaller, less competitive Chinese solar companies have closed, and share prices for Suntech, Yingli and Trina have plummeted by more than 75 per cent over the past year.

This article was originally published by Reuters. Republished with permssion.

InvestSMART FORUM: Come and meet the team

We're loading up the van and going on tour from April to June, with events on the NSW central & north coast, the QLD mid-north coast and in Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney and Canberra. Come and meet the team and take home simple strategies that you can use to build an investment portfolio to weather any storm. Book your spot here.

Want access to our latest research and new buy ideas?

Start a free 15 day trial and gain access to our research, recommendations and market-beating model portfolios.

Sign up for free

Related Articles