InvestSMART

5 types of investment properties to avoid

Not every investment property is a winner. Here are five types that can bring more risk than reward.
By ·
2 Jul 2026 · 5 min read
comments Comments

Your first investment property doesn't have to be perfect, but it does need to be sensible. One way to reduce risk is to write a list of potential issues to look out for when you're viewing properties. Here are some we're always cautious about.

1. Small studio apartments in high-rise buildings

Studios can look attractive on yield. The rent looks high compared with the price. The problem is that many of these properties have had almost no capital growth in 15 years or more and some are still selling for less than their original purchase price. Lenders can also be stricter with small apartments, which limits your buyer pool in the future.

2. Off-the-plan high-rise apartments

Buying off the plan can involve an 18- to 24-month - or longer - build window. Your 10% deposit is tied up while you earn little or no return and a lot can change in that time. Interest rates, lending rules, your job, your health or the broader market can all shift before settlement. You also can't rely on a standard preapproval for an off-the-plan purchase. Pre-approvals generally last around three months, which is useless for an 18-month build. For a first-time investor, the added complexity and risk are rarely worth it.

3. Properties with major known headaches

For a first investment, be cautious about buying places that come with obvious high maintenance or structural risks, such as:

  • large, old retaining walls that already show signs of movement
  • private swimming pools and spas
  • old fibro shacks that haven't been updated and may contain asbestos
  • fireplaces that may not meet current rental safety rules in your state.

All properties have some maintenance, but if you can avoid obvious dramas on property number one, you'll make your life much easier.

4. Single-industry or speculative locations

Be very cautious about towns that rely on a single industry, particularly mining towns where yields look incredible on paper. Everything looks great until it isn't. If you want your first property to be a relatively low drama stepping stone, you'll usually want a location with multiple industries and a stable underlying population.

5. Large new estates where almost everyone is an investor

A new pocket inside an established suburb can be fine, but a brand new suburb where almost every buyer is an investor can be risky. You might end up competing with hundreds of similar properties for tenants, and rents may soften if too many investors try to undercut each other.

Overall, your first investment property should be as 'turn key' and boring as possible. Ideally, you want a property that someone can move into tomorrow. It might be an existing home with a long-term tenant already in place, or a new build that's finished and ready to lease, not a speculative off-the-plan purchase or a half-finished renovation that depends on your weekends and a miracle.



This is an edited extract from The Quick-Start Guide to Your First Property (Wiley, $34.95), republished with permission. 

 

 

 

Google News
Follow us on Google News
Go to Google News, then click "Follow" button to add us.
Share this article and show your support
Free Membership
Free Membership
Glen James & Rachelle Kroon
Glen James & Rachelle Kroon
Keep on reading more articles from Glen James & Rachelle Kroon. See more articles
Join the conversation
Join the conversation...
There are comments posted so far. Join the conversation, please login or Sign up.

Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…

Small studios can show attractive rental yield on paper, but many have experienced little or no capital growth for 15 years or more. Lenders are often stricter with small apartments, which can limit your future buyer pool and make resale harder.

Off-the-plan purchases can involve an 18–24 month (or longer) build period during which your 10% deposit is tied up and you may earn little or no return. Interest rates, lending rules, your job, your health or the broader market can change before settlement, adding complexity and risk for a first investor.

Standard pre-approvals generally last around three months, which is usually useless for an 18–24 month build. That means you can’t rely on a standard pre-approval to guarantee finance at settlement for an off-the-plan purchase.

Avoid properties with obvious high-maintenance or structural risks such as large, old retaining walls showing movement, private swimming pools and spas, old fibro shacks that may contain asbestos, and fireplaces that may not meet current rental safety rules in your state.

Towns that rely on a single industry (for example, some mining towns) can show great yields on paper but are vulnerable if that industry weakens. For a lower-drama first investment, choose locations with multiple industries and a stable underlying population.

In brand new suburbs dominated by investors you may compete with hundreds of similar properties for tenants. That oversupply can lead to softer rents if investors undercut each other trying to secure tenants.

'Turn-key' means the property is ready for a tenant to move in tomorrow. For first-time investors this could be an existing home with a long-term tenant or a finished new build ready to lease—avoiding off-the-plan purchases or half-finished renovations that demand time, money and risk.

Make a checklist of potential issues to look out for (e.g., building type, maintenance needs, location stability, investor saturation). Aim for a sensible, low-drama property that’s turn-key and avoids the specific pitfalls discussed—small high-rise studios, off-the-plan buys, obvious maintenance headaches, single-industry towns and investor-heavy new estates.