Jail term for former Bell Potter adviser
Lawson Stuart Donald, 38, a former Bell Potter Securities client adviser, received a suspended 2-½ year sentence, with a two-year good behaviour bond, in April.
But the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions, after consulting with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission, appealed against the sentence, saying it was "manifestly inadequate".
Donald had pleaded guilty in August last year to using his position as an employee of the stockbroking firm to gain an advantage for himself worth about $1.8 million. He was a client adviser at Bell Potter from 2003 to 2008.
ASIC said Donald had transferred trades from one client account to accounts controlled by him, and then "sold those shares for a profit".
At the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal on Friday, the judges said in a decision that the original sentence "failed to reflect the gravity of the offence and failed in particular to serve as an effective deterrent to other similarly intelligent, competitive professionals in the financial markets".
The court added that was due in part to "the inherent leniency in a suspended sentence", and deterrence appeared more effective when a jail sentence was imposed.
"Notwithstanding judicial statements to the effect that a suspended sentence is a sentence of imprisonment, the community (including those in 'white collar' occupations) might be justifiably forgiven for thinking that an offender who is serving a bond in the community has escaped meaningful punishment," the court said.
The court also addressed the issue of a "rolled up" count, where Donald's offences, which ASIC said were carried out over 30 separate transactions between 2005 and 2008, were accepted as one offence.
Citing another case this year, the court noted Justice Peter Garling's observations that "there was a considerable advantage to an offender in a 'rolled up' charge, in that it restricts the maximum penalty to that for one offence, instead of what is in reality a number of discrete offences".
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
Lawson Stuart Donald is a former Bell Potter Securities client adviser who was jailed for a year after a Commonwealth appeal against his suspended sentence for dishonest conduct. He used his position to gain an advantage worth about $1.8 million.
Lawson Stuart Donald originally received a suspended 2-½ year sentence with a two-year good behaviour bond. However, this was appealed as 'manifestly inadequate' by the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions.
The Commonwealth appealed Lawson Stuart Donald's sentence because it was considered 'manifestly inadequate' and failed to reflect the gravity of the offence or serve as an effective deterrent to other professionals in the financial markets.
Lawson Stuart Donald transferred trades from one client account to accounts controlled by him and then sold those shares for a profit, which led to his conviction for dishonest conduct.
The court viewed the suspended sentence as inherently lenient and not an effective deterrent, suggesting that a jail sentence would serve as a more meaningful punishment.
A 'rolled up' count is when multiple offences are accepted as one offence, which restricts the maximum penalty to that for one offence. In Donald's case, his offences over 30 transactions were treated as one, affecting the severity of his sentence.
The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) consulted with the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions, which led to the appeal against Lawson Stuart Donald's original sentence.
This case highlights the importance of regulatory oversight and the potential consequences of dishonest conduct in financial markets, reinforcing the need for investors to be vigilant and informed about the integrity of their advisers.
Call 1300 880 160
Start a chat
Schedule a call
