The chief executive of the building products group Alesco Corporation, Peter Boyd, summed up the situation facing many corporates rather neatly yesterday when he said the coming year was likely to be tougher than the one his company has just come through.
Boyd was talking specifically about the difficulties facing the construction and building product sectors, most notably the weak residential housing market, but his comments about sliding consumer confidence can easily be extended to most other industries.
You'd have to be on another planet not to appreciate the problems facing the retail industry, issues which the Reserve Bank governor, Glenn Stevens, addressed in a speech yesterday in which he acknowledged that widespread pessimism was making life hard for many in the economy.
Stevens (who, of course, has been a contributor to that mood by increasing interest rates to choke off an outbreak of inflation) blamed tremors in financial markets, "increasingly bitter political debates" and a cooling-off in asset prices as reasons why consumers have stopped spending.
For large swathes of the listed corporate sector, that has meant revenue and earnings have been harder to come by in recent months. Hence the recent profit downgrades from a host of retailers and the cautious outlook statements which are emerging as the latest reporting season gets under way.
It was somewhat timely, therefore, that Tanya Branwhite's team at Macquarie Equities has just issued its latest 2011 earnings outlook report, which pulled few punches in terms of what investors can expect over the coming weeks.
In comparison to previous periods when the normal ebbs and flows of economy would determine who would do well and who wouldn't, Macquarie believes this year is different because of a "wrenching structural change" which is driving a "growth" gap between the likely winners and losers.
For the former, read the booming mining and wider resource industries, with most of the rest in the latter. With that in mind, immediate share price performance will be driven more by the delivery of earnings growth - high or low - rather than the normal valuation indicators, Macquarie says.
Not surprisingly, resource companies are likely to be the flyers, with Macquarie highlighting BHP Billiton, Rio Tinto, OZ Minerals, Atlas Iron and PanAust as those likely to deliver strong earnings surprises. They are set to be joined by defensive industrial stocks such as Amcor, Ansell, Resmed and Ramsay Health Care, given they are less exposed to those parts of the economy that are in the doldrums.
At the other end, it will be of little surprise that Qantas, Virgin, Leighton, Harvey Norman, CSR, Fairfax Media (publisher of the Herald), Ten, Bendigo and Adelaide Bank, and the Bank of Queensland are fingered on the list of those companies doing it harder.
All are exposed, one way or the other, to the fickle nature of consumer spending. But such problems are not just limited to domestically-focused companies. Globally-exposed operators such as the insurer QBE, gaming machine supplier Aristocrat, Billabong and News Corporation have their issues to deal with overseas, of which the high Australian dollar is just one.
POKER PLAYERS
It's not all bad news for the gambling industry. In the case of Woolworths, consumer staples are not the only sales still ringing strongly for Australia's largest grocer.
The consumer retail strike appears to have bypassed poker machines, according to Deutsche Bank. Good news for Woolies, which also happens to be one of the nation's largest pokie owners via its pubs business.
"Gambling expenditure has remained robust throughout the June quarter as consumers are still spending on recreational and entertainment pursuits," the broker said.
Poker machine revenues for June were up 6 per cent in Queensland, 4.1 per cent in Victoria and 3 to 4 per cent in NSW. Wagering and lottery performance was "sound", the broker noted. Deutsche favourably compared gambling's overall performance for the month with the rising household savings in the March quarter and recent profit downgrades from various retailers, including this week's trimming of Premier Investment's forecasts.
Deutsche says it prefers Crown and Tatts in the sector, particularly noting Crown's beneficial exposure to Macau's strong growth.
NO DEPOSIT
National Australia Bank appears to be keeping its own shareholders guessing, as well as Lloyds Banking Group, as to its intentions in Britain, where it continues to grapple with the future of its Yorkshire and Clydesdale Bank subsidiaries.
Lloyds is being forced to sell 632 branches in order to comply with European Union rulings on taxpayer aid after being bailed out by the British government during the global financial crisis. NAB had been tipped as a bidder, seemingly as part of a "bulk up or get out" plan that tends to get dusted down every so often at HQ back here. However, only two formal offers - neither involving NAB - were received for the Lloyds branches by the bank's deadline, which has now been extended to try to tease out further interest.
One hurdle is Lloyds's asking price, said to be #2.5 billion ($3.7 billion). Given the funding gap between the deposits held by the branches concerned and their lending requirements, NAB is an understandable reluctant would-be purchaser.
The price therefore will have to either come down quite substantially or NAB will have to team up with a partner or two to spread the load before its interest firms, which is probably why it didn't lodge an offer by this month's due date.
Additional reporting: Colin Kruger.
Ian McIlwraith is sick.
Frequently Asked Questions about this Article…
What does Macquarie mean by a “looming growth gap” and why should Australian investors care?
Macquarie’s 2011 earnings outlook warns of a “wrenching structural change” that will create a growth gap between clear winners and losers. For investors that means share price moves will be driven more by actual earnings growth than normal valuation metrics — resource and commodity-linked companies look set to outperform, while many consumer-exposed businesses may struggle if spending stays weak.
Which sectors and companies are likely to be the winners in the current Australian market according to the article?
The article highlights booming mining and resource industries as likely winners. Macquarie specifically names BHP Billiton, Rio Tinto, OZ Minerals, Atlas Iron and PanAust as companies that could deliver strong earnings surprises. It also notes some defensive industrials like Amcor, Ansell, Resmed and Ramsay Health Care may hold up because they are less exposed to weak consumer spending.
Which retailers and consumer-facing companies are expected to face the toughest conditions?
Companies exposed to fickle consumer spending are singled out as facing harder times. Macquarie’s list includes Qantas, Virgin, Leighton, Harvey Norman, CSR, Fairfax Media, Ten, Bendigo and Adelaide Bank, and the Bank of Queensland — many of which have faced profit downgrades or cautious outlooks as consumer confidence cools.
How is weak consumer confidence and higher interest rates affecting corporate earnings and retail profits?
The article reports sliding consumer confidence has made revenue and earnings harder to come by for many listed companies. Reserve Bank governor Glenn Stevens linked the slowdown to financial market tremors, bitter political debates and cooling asset prices — on top of interest rate increases aimed at slowing inflation — and brokers are already seeing profit downgrades and cautious outlook statements from retailers.
Is gambling revenue (pokies and wagering) holding up despite broader retail weakness, and which companies benefit?
Yes — Deutsche Bank notes gambling expenditure remained robust in the June quarter and poker machine revenues rose in key states (for example, up about 6% in Queensland). That supports companies with pokies exposure such as Woolworths (via its pubs business). Deutsche Bank also says it prefers Crown and Tatts in the sector, citing Crown’s exposure to fast-growing Macau.
Which globally exposed companies face challenges from overseas markets and a high Australian dollar?
The article points to globally-exposed operators that have issues overseas, including insurer QBE, gaming machine supplier Aristocrat, Billabong and News Corporation. A high Australian dollar is mentioned as one factor adding to their overseas challenges.
What’s the situation with National Australia Bank (NAB) and the potential purchase of Lloyds’ branches in Britain?
Lloyds Banking Group has been forced to sell 632 branches to comply with EU rules after its bailout. The asking price is reported at about £2.5 billion, and by the bank’s deadline only two formal offers were received — neither involving NAB — so the deadline was extended. NAB has been linked as a possible bidder in the past but appears reluctant because of a funding gap between deposits and lending in those branches; it may need partners or a lower price to pursue a deal.
How should everyday investors use this information when assessing their portfolios?
The article suggests investors should pay close attention to earnings delivery rather than relying solely on valuation ratios this reporting season. That means favoring companies likely to deliver real earnings growth (for example, resource names and some defensive industrials) and being cautious with heavily consumer-exposed or globally-vulnerable businesses until consumer spending and currency pressures become clearer.