As the summer concert season approaches in the northern hemisphere, live music fans, and the concert industry that serves them, have a common enemy in New York. And in Russia. And in India.
That enemy is the bot.
"Bots", computer programs used by advanced scalpers, are a hidden part of a miserable ritual that plays out online nearly every week in which tickets to hot shows seem to vanish instantly.
Long a nuisance to the live music industry, these cheap and widely available programs are perhaps its most reviled foe, frustrating fans and feeding a multibillion-dollar secondary market for tickets.
According to Ticketmaster, bots have been used to buy more than 60 per cent of the most desirable tickets for some shows; in a recent lawsuit, the company accused one group of scalpers of using bots to request up to 200,000 tickets a day.
Ticketmaster and its parent company, Live Nation Entertainment, have stepped up efforts to combat bots, in part to improve the ticket-buying experience for concert-goers, but also to burnish the company's reputation with consumers. The result has been a game of cat and mouse between the company and the bots.
"As with hackers, you can solve it today, and they're rewriting code tomorrow," said Michael Rapino, Live Nation's CEO. "Thus the arms race."
In late 2011, Ticketmaster hired John Carnahan, a tech expert who fought online advertising scams at Yahoo!, to lead its anti-bot effort.
By monitoring the behaviour of visitors to Ticketmaster's site, the company can determine the likelihood of a customer being human or a machine. For example, a human might click a series of buttons at a range of speeds and in different spots on a screen, but bots can give themselves away by rapidly clicking on precisely the same spot.
Bots are not kicked off the system, but rather "speedbumped" - slowed down, sent to the end of the line or given some other means of interference, to allow a regular customer through.
"We're not trying to stop anybody from buying tickets," Carnahan said. "We're just trying to make sure that a fan can buy the tickets."
Ticket giant sends bots to the back of queue
As the summer concert season approaches in the northern hemisphere, live music fans, and the concert industry that serves them, have a common enemy in New York.
Want access to our latest research and new buy ideas?
Start a free 15 day trial and gain access to our research, recommendations and market-beating model portfolios.Sign up for free