The myth of pay for performance

Executive pay has nothing to do with shareholder returns in Australia’s top companies. So when will industry funds do something about it?

Over the past 15 years, Commonwealth Bank shares have gone from $16 each to $74, an increase of $58, while NAB shares have gone up by $12, from $19 to $31. In that time, CBA has paid $35.19 in dividends and NAB has paid $22.29.
 
That works out to be additional wealth of about $93 per share to CBA owners and $34 to NAB, or 13.7 per cent compound return per annum for CBA and 7.2 per cent for NAB. Big difference. (By the way, the compound annual return of the all ordinaries accumulation index, including dividends, has been 8.75 per cent per annum – CBA has killed it, NAB has done worse).
 
Over that same period, NAB has paid its succession of chief executives $108 million and CBA paid its CEOs $98 million.
 
In other words, the pay of the CEO made no difference to shareholder returns; in fact the bigger payer between those two banks performed the worst.
 
A few months ago, investment bank CLSA plotted the executive pay of Australia’s top 200 companies against total shareholder return. Here’s the rather amusing result:

Graph for The myth of pay for performance

{{content.question}}

Mastercard

{{ twilioFailed ? 'SMS Code Failed to Send…' : 'An SMS verification code has been sent ...' }}

Hi {{ user.FirstName }}

Looks like you have already taken a free trial

Email is required.
Email must be a valid email.
Password is required.
First name is required.
Last name is required.
Mobile phone number is required.
You must accept the terms and conditions.

OR

We have sent you a code via SMS to {{user.DayPhone}}

please enter this code below to complete your SMS verification

We cannot send you a code via SMS to {{user.DayPhone}}

If you didn't receive SMS code please

SMS code cannot be sent due to: {{ twilioStatus }}

Please select one of the options below:

Looks you are already a member. Please enter your password to proceed

You have entered an incorrect email or password

Email is required.
Email must be a valid email.
Password is required.

Please untick this box when using a public or shared device


OR

Verify your mobile number to proceed...

Please check your mobile number below and press the Send Verification Code button. This will be used to complete your verification in the next step.

Please sign up for full access

Mastercard

Updating information

Please wait ...

Trial

Mastercard
{{ productPrice }} / day
( GST included )
Price $0
Discount -{{productDiscount}}
GST {{productGST}}
TOTAL   (inc. GST) {{productPrice}}
  • Mastercard
  • Visa

Please click on the ACTIVATE button to finalise your membership

Mastercard

The email address you entered is registered with InvestSMART.

Login or to reset your password, select Forgotten password

You have entered an incorrect email or password

Email is required.
Email must be a valid email.
Password is required.

Please untick this box when using a public or shared device


OR

Related Articles