JV partners play mining shell game with Intrepid
INTREPID Mines has a jumbo gold project on the island of Java.
According to documents obtained by Fairfax Media, Intrepid's joint-venture partners in Indonesia have sold the giant Tujuh Bukit project to somebody else. Right out from underneath their noses.
A shareholding approval from the head of government of Banyuwangi Regency shows a change in ownership for the company that holds the project's mining licence. The licence is no longer held by Intrepid's joint-venture partner, Indo Multi Niaga but by another company, Bumi Sukses Indo.
Contacted for comment, Intrepid chief executive Brad Gordon said he was not aware of a change of ownership and questioned the authenticity of the document.
"We get reports regularly from the Law and Human Rights Department. We have had nothing official from the department," he said.
Intrepid had already lost control of the project in July when, in dramatic circumstances, a helicopter set down in the jungle clearing at Tujuh Bukit and ordered all 460 workers to down tools and evacuate the site.
Its joint-venture partners, Indonesian couple Maya Ambarsari and Reza Nazaruddin and their company IMN, had introduced new investors to the project and simply cut the Australian explorer out of the picture.
It came as more than just a shock for Intrepid, which had already spent $95 million proving up the resource and its 25 million ounces of gold, 80 million ounces of silver and 7 million tonnes of copper.
There were also questions over disclosure. Although the company rejected suggestions that it might not have fully met its obligations under the continuous disclosure regime, it was not obvious, at least until the project was seized in July, that Intrepid's stake in Tujuh Bukit was "economic" rather than legally enforceable.
As the Intrepid share price tanked, Gordon moved quickly to salvage the venture.
Joint-venture partners Reza and Maya avoided all communication, however, and left him with little option other than to put a brave face on things and try to pull some strings in Indonesia.
So, Gordon struck a deal with an influential Jakarta businessman and television network owner, Surya Paloh. Paloh was issued 5 per cent of the company's stock, with options over another 10 per cent, on account of his "vast experience in navigating the waters of Indonesian business".
Yet even with the inducement of 15 per cent of the company's stock, Paloh has been unable to get Maya and Reza and the IMN joint-venture partner back to the negotiating table.
A month before the project was seized by Intrepid's partners, Maya and Reza, the couple had registered a change of ownership of their company IMN. They transferred 80 per cent to new investors. In July, they transferred the mining licence from their company IMN to a 51 per cent-owned subsidiary of IMN called Bumi Sukses Indo. Via this transfer, Intrepid still had a claim to the gold project as its contracts were held with IMN and IMN still held 51 per cent.
The most recent disclosures, however, show that Intrepid's partners IMN, and IMN principals Maya and Reza, are no longer shareholders of the company that holds the mining licence. The new shareholding is PT Alfa Sukses Indo (5 per cent) and PT Merdeka Serasi Jaya (95 per cent).
The type of mining licence held by Intrepid's JV partner (PT Indo Multi Niaga) is known as an "IUP" and could not be held by foreigners, so the company had been running some legal risk all along, since it struck the deal with IMN in August 2007.
Ironically, Intrepid has just fielded a lawsuit from its former partner, Paul Willis, who claims that he had been cut out of Tujuh Bukit in 2007, just as Maya and Reza had cut Intrepid out of the picture this year.
Willis and his company, IndoAust, have filed a suit in the South Jakarta District Court seeking to have the agreements between Intrepid and IMN declared null and void because they were the direct product of an act of duress.
Willis alleges that he was intimidated by thugs acting for Maya and Reza into relinquishing his stake in the project at a hotel room in Jakarta.
Intrepid last week responded to the claim: "The company believes the action brought is totally without foundation and suffers from material legal deficiencies and will vigorously defend the action."
Willis says he is also bringing a class action against Intrepid for failing to inform the market of its lack of legal rights to the project.
There is no doubt some tactical benefit to be gained by Willis in running a pincer movement with the two legal claims.
For it's part, Intrepid has dismissed claims of failure of disclosure. But it is also difficult to find relevant disclosure of ownership risk in the statutory materials until February 2009. Even then, it seems to be buried in quarterly management reports rather than displayed prominently in the likes of Joint Ore Reserves Committee statements, which are more widely viewed by investors.
Before Intrepid came on the scene, Paul Willis had begun working the Tujuh Bukit area armed with some old Placer Dome data. He and partner Sam Garrett had struck a deal with Maya and Reza. Under Indonesian law, foreigners could not legally own shares in Indonesian companies so their private company, IndoAust, had an arrangement with Maya and Reza's company IMN. IMN held the mining licence, which was then known as a KP.
The drilling results were promising so Willis went looking for a partner to fund the project. He found Emperor Mines in 2007, which changed its name to Intrepid.
By the following March the alliance agreement between IndoAust and the then Emperor Mines had fallen apart.
IndoAust and its workers were forced to evacuate the Tujuh Bukit site in April 2008 in the same dramatic fashion as Intrepid in July this year.
InvestSMART FORUM: Come and meet the team
We're loading up the van and going on tour from April to June, with events on the NSW central & north coast, the QLD mid-north coast and in Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney and Canberra. Come and meet the team and take home simple strategies that you can use to build an investment portfolio to weather any storm. Book your spot here.
Want access to our latest research and new buy ideas?
Start a free 15 day trial and gain access to our research, recommendations and market-beating model portfolios.Sign up for free