Sale time: Facebook frenzy puts shares at a premium Eager would-be shareholders in Mark Zuckerberg's Cashbook, er, Facebook, have pushed its worth past the $US100 billion ($108 billion) barrier for the first time.

Sale time: Facebook frenzy puts shares at a premium

Eager would-be shareholders in Mark Zuckerberg's Cashbook, er, Facebook, have pushed its worth past the $US100 billion ($108 billion) barrier for the first time.

An auction last night of an interest in Facebook's Class B common stock effectively priced the shares at $US44 each - compared with the $US29.73 internal valuation in the social network's filing last week for its intended listing.

All up, that values Facebook at a nominal $US102 billion as investors race to position themselves in what they hope will be a bumper initial public offering (IPO).

The private capital markets group SharesPost sadly rejected Insider's application to participate in auctions of stocks such as Facebook and Zynga on the flimsy grounds that our net worth is less than $1 million.

But it still taunts Insider with what might have been by email updates on sales. Technically, you cannot buy Facebook shares through SharesPost. You instead buy units in an investment vehicle that owns the shares, run by a subsidiary of SharesPost.

That is not a million miles removed from the structures developed by clever mainland China-based companies and their investment bankers to allow foreign investors to buy indirect stakes in those companies via public listing in outfits registered in North America and the Virgin Islands that actually own the Chinese assets.

Insider can only assume that investors in Facebook and similar companies will be able to crystallise their investments after the IPO.

At any rate, Insider has been watching the SharesPost/Facebook market for over a year now, and pretty much all of the stock has been going off at the equivalent of $US32 to $US34 a share - until the end of January when news of the impending $US5 billion IPO broke.

Since then the stock has climbed to yesterday's $US44 peak - keeping in mind that only 150,000 of SharesPost's pseudo-equity, or $6.6 million, was auctioned. That is a fraction of the company's total.


PaperlinX, which can only dream of being a sought-after stock like Facebook, has set March 23 as the day when industry entrepreneur Andrew Price gets his showdown with its embattled board.

Having spent months being beaten up by its distribution-deprived preference shareholders, PaperlinX's board is now under challenge from Price, who has requisitioned a meeting to try to unseat chairman Harry Boon.

Insider has been pointing out since mid-2011 that PaperlinX's value destruction for investors has been embarrassingly massive, finally resulting in long-term chairman David Meiklejohn departing last September, to be replaced by Boon.

Price is enjoying the support of existing shareholders, not just because they want to see the paper merchant pulled quickly out of its horrendous performances of recent years, but because his mere presence has already buoyed the shares - so much so that PaperlinX yesterday had to respond to a speeding ticket from the ASX.

The company neatly suggested that the 26 per cent rise in its stock, to a weighty 8.7? a share, might be Price fulfilling public statements that he intended buying shares. They traded up to 9.3? each yesterday, but setled for an 8? close.

Since Price, and a handful of like-minded investors, requisitioned the meeting last Friday, about 40 million PaperlinX shares, or 6.5 per cent of the equity, have changed hands. Most of the buying has been done through Commonwealth Securities, with UBS a close second, which means it could just be punters speculating on the outcome.

At least they know who is selling, because Maple-Brown Abbott revealed late in the afternoon that it had ditched almost 7 million shares since late January for the princely return of $455,000.

Insider tried to contact Price but has yet to hear back. PaperlinX was also unable to confirm the provenance of a leaked memo published on website.

Insider is pretty certain the document, signed by London-based chief executive Toby Marchant and dated last Friday, is the real thing - if for no other reason than it it starts "Dear PLG", management-speak for PaperlinX leadership group.

Insider was most amused by Marchant's apparent annoyance with the concept of continuous disclosure, the letter attributing to him the view that "as a public company, it forces us to disclose so much information that we inevitably attract more attention than we would like, and this is yet another classic example of this".

Yup, far better those darned shareholders keep out of running the business, and leave managers to run it as a black box.

Want access to our latest research and new buy ideas?

Start a free 15 day trial and gain access to our research, recommendations and market-beating model portfolios.

Sign up for free

Related Articles