Decline takes contractors by surpise

Mothballed resource projects take toll on mining services firms, writes Philip Wen.

Mothballed resource projects take toll on mining services firms, writes Philip Wen.

Gina Rinehart's indignant edict imploring governments to stop treating miners like "ATMs" could just as well be aimed at the sector's mining contractors. For them, the easy cash is drying up, and at a much faster rate than expected.

Andrew Wood, the chief executive of global engineering firm WorleyParsons, said he saw the slowdown in Australian mining investment coming, but was surprised by the rapid rate of "deterioration" as the big miners pulled the pin on big projects and wound back costs.

Wood had thought the group's diverse range of global operations would help insulate it against country-specific risk. But instead, the downturn, predominantly in Western Australia, forced the perennially solid performer built by industry veteran John Grill into a rare profit downgrade.

Similarly, UGL chief executive Richard Leupen was among the first to call the end of the resources boom and has been rebalancing his group's portfolio of businesses toward the steadier, if less spectacular, returns of property management and maintenance services.

Earnings from UGL's property division are expected to make up about half the group's total within a couple of years, but that has not come soon enough to insulate against what Leupen described as the indefinite deferral of "$80 billion of projects" in the years ahead.

Chief among the megaprojects hitting a wall is Woodside Petroleum's abandonment of its $45 billion-plus Browse LNG development at James Price Point in WA because of rising costs.

BHP Billiton boss Andrew Mackenzie used his first major investor presentation as chief executive this week to flag severe cuts to capital spending. He said the miner would cut capital and exploration expenditure by 18 per cent to $US18 billion for the next financial year, down from $US22 billion the year before. Ominously for contractors banking on a recovery in mining investment, Mackenzie said BHP's spending would continue to "decline substantially" in subsequent years.

Rio Tinto is also in the middle of a belt-tightening exercise, looking to cut $5 billion in costs, including $1 billion from its exploration budget, by the end of next year.

The wave of project delays and cost-cutting has seen the share prices of the large contractors servicing the mining industry savaged.

Shares in WorleyParsons fell by as much as 15 per cent on Friday, eventually closing $2.79 or 12.5 per cent lower at $19.50.

And having long prided himself in avoiding the spectacular implosions seen at fierce rivals Leighton Holdings and Downer EDI, Leupen has now been forced to take the bitter pill of two significant profit downgrades in the space of four months. Shares in UGL fell 17 per cent on Wednesday, and then fell a further 5 per cent the next day before a modest recovery on Friday.

Shares in smaller engineering firm Sedgman also fell after it flashed a profit warning, while large contractors Transfield and Monadelphous have also been sold off heavily for fear that they will be the next to reveal bad news.

"What's important to note is the impact is really threefold in the business," Wood told reporters on Friday. "It's a multiplying effect in the business when projects get cancelled or deferred.

"First of all there's the loss of income that's coming from it ... we've had to look at further restructuring, and there's restructuring costs that come through. And then as a result of that further restructure, we have additional floorspace and overheads in the business that we have to get rid of."

The pressure contractors are now under is apparent. What is less clear is how the situation will improve.

Mr Wood said cost pressures in WA was a big issue, but declined to use stronger language when pushed on the subject.

"The position in WA is one of creating a level of certainty and also trying to help the industry get to a point of improving productivity of the workforce," Mr Wood said.

"It's probably a question best addressed to the resource companies in their own right."

The big miners and the Minerals Council of Australia have all been vocal in their demands for improved productivity, labour measures and smoother environmental approval processes. But possibly none are as vocal as Rinehart. "It needs to keep reminding Australians this - that without mining and its related industries, this country has no hope of repaying our record debt without facing the problems Greece and other countries faced with overspending and consequent debt traumas," she says. "The industry needs to keep repeating this."

Want access to our latest research and new buy ideas?

Start a free 15 day trial and gain access to our research, recommendations and market-beating model portfolios.

Sign up for free

Related Articles