Conroy's broadband take-up hash-up

While arguing Australia's FTTP take-up is unique in the world, Stephen Conroy admits nowhere that any success is due to his harshly anti-competitive broadband policy.

In this light, is a penetration rate of 25 per cent of households after 12 months of NBN fibre availability really such a triumph? Isn’t the real story that after a year (and a deluge of taxpayer-funded advertising of the NBN) 75 per cent of users in these districts haven’t been persuaded that fibre offers anything worth switching over to ahead of the last possible moment when they have no other choice?

And his frank admission that around the world the demand for fibre has so far not justified widespread investment – other than where costs are very low such as in Hong Kong and Singapore – is a spectacular own goal.

Senator Conroy is somehow trying to make the argument that what makes Australia unique is not the cost of supply – it’s the strength of our demand. Remember that as of September 30, take-up on the NBN’s fibre as a whole was 12.2 per cent of households passed.

Of course, we could remind Senator Conroy of unique factors specific to the Australian situation which should have led to even higher uptake, such as:

– A huge marketing budget. In two years to June 2013 the government has committed (external to the NBN Co’s own budget) $40 million to advertising on the NBN – almost $6000 for each household signed up to the NBN’s fibre product. NBN Co itself spent $11.2 million on advertising in 2011-12 alone.

– Free ‘trial periods’ where the product was given to consumers free of charge.

– As mentioned, the stated intention that at a specified date, all alternative fixed-line networks will be switched off.

But I welcome Senator Conroy’s first foray into noticing broadband deployments around the world. His contribution is the type of analysis that would have been useful three years ago, at the time in early 2009 when he should have committed to a cost benefit analysis of each of the options for achieving a broadband upgrade, rather than committing to a particular technical solution (GPON FTTP) regardless of cost.

I can’t help but note that he drew the wrong conclusions from some of the statistics he cited, however. For instance, he quoted well respected telco analyst Rob Kenny for take-up in Europe (I would refer Senator Conroy to a particularly strong piece of work completed by Robert Kenny online here).

Perhaps if he had read the full post, he would have come across the main point that Kenny was making:

"This analysis does suggest that unless there is some radical change, FTTH is something of a sideshow for the EU's superfast target. If policy makers have serious ambition to meet that target, they will need to focus on cable or FTTC solutions.”

This type of cherry-picking is not new to Senator Conroy or the NBN. Last week an NBN spokesman wrote:

"We are also happy with the rate of activations to date. For instance, it took the UK four years to achieve an FTTH/B take-up rate of 2 per cent of homes passed.”

I have not been able to find any source which supports the information the NBN spokesman was referring to – however, it should be noted there has been no substantial FTTH/B rollout in the UK at all. OECD data shows that fibre counts for around 1.9 per cent of total connections in the UK Perhaps the NBN can provide a reference to support this claim.

{{content.question}}

{{ twilioFailed ? 'SMS Code Failed to Send…' : 'SMS Code Sent…' }}

Hi {{ user.FirstName }}

Looks like you've already taken a free trial

Please enter your payment details

We have sent you a code via SMS to {{user.DayPhone}}

please enter this code below to activate your membership

We cannot send you a code via SMS to {{user.DayPhone}}

If you didn't receive SMS code please

SMS code cannot be sent due to: {{ twilioStatus }}

Please select one of the options below:

Looks you are already a member. Please enter your password to proceed

Please untick this box when using a public or shared device


Verify your mobile number to unlock a FREE trial

Please sign up for full access

Updating information

Please wait ...

  • Mastercard
  • Visa
Mastercard

The email address you entered is registered with InvestSMART.

Please login or select "Don't know password"

Please untick this box when using a public or shared device


Register as a new member

(using a different email)

Related Articles