www.investsmart.com.au

Search
Investment News

Investment News

  Print

Article Type:
Date Range:
Search keywords:
Companies in:   My Watchlist      My Portfolio
Search Tips
  • Use a comma to search for multiple keywords
  • Search keywords can contain free text, company names and stock codes
  • You will be prompted to log in before viewing news for companies in your Watchlist or Portfolio
Most Popular Articles
26th Jul 2010 Melbourne raining on our property parade
21st Jul 2010 From the boom times to bust
28th Jul 2010 Bank war all for show
21st Jul 2010 CFDs an explosive bet
22nd Jul 2010 Men from Metcash get ready to spar

Join InvestSMART for FREE
Trade Shares Online

Joyce warns of 'economic Armageddon'


Comment on this article  |  See what others are saying

TONY Abbott's new finance spokesman, Barnaby Joyce, believes the American government may default on its debt, triggering an "economic Armageddon" that will make the recent global financial crisis pale into insignificance.

The Age - 11th Dec 2009 - By MARK DAVIS NATIONAL EDITOR

TONY Abbott's new finance spokesman, Barnaby Joyce, believes the American government may default on its debt, triggering an "economic Armageddon" that will make the recent global financial crisis pale into insignificance.

He has also proposed that the Federal Government should introduce laws allowing it to break up the assets of the four main banks  and use them to force banks to hold down interest rates.

"You don't even have to break them apart," he said. "But you have to suggest to them that those powers could be in place to do that if they aren't more diligent in how they respect the Australian community."

Senator Joyce came under attack from several ministers, including Treasurer Wayne Swan, who said he had been elevated "straight from the reactionary fringe of our economic debate to the second most senior economic policymaking job in the alternative government".

In an interview with The Age, Senator Joyce said he did not want to alarm the public, but there needed to be a debate about Australia's "contingency plan" for a sovereign debt default by the US or even by an Australian state government.

"A default by the US means complete economic collapse around the world and the question we have got to ask ourselves is where are we in that?" he said.

He said the chances of a US debt default were distant but real, and politicians were not doing the electorate a favour by refusing to acknowledge the risk.

Senator Joyce first warned of America defaulting at a Senate estimates hearing in October where he asked Treasury secretary Ken Henry for his views.

Dr Henry warned then that public figures had to be careful about discussing "hypotheticals that are that extreme" because such discussions could be misinterpreted in the community.

Rather than tempering his language since his promotion, Senator Joyce has stepped up the rhetoric, saying he also had concerns that some states would have trouble repaying their borrowings.

"The first thing you tell a new client is exactly where they are. We have to tell the Australian people precisely where they are," said the former accountant from the Queensland town of St George.

"The Federal Government has $115.7 billion in debt, Australian government securities, notes and bonds on issue, and the states have another $170 billion in debt," Senator Joyce said.

"We have to ask whether the states have the capacity to repay that. I would say in some instances they do not  particularly Queensland."

Senator Joyce said that if the US recovered, global funds would flow back into North America. He said the only way Australia could keep capital flowing into the country would be to increase interest rates.

"That is the first scenario, which is extremely bad for Australia.

"The worse scenario is where the United States doesn't repay their debt  the $US2 trillion in debt they owe to the Chinese, the $US1 trillion in debt they have to the Japanese and the $US1 trillion in debt to others  and then we are really nailed." That would result in a shift from the US dollar to the yuan, "and China becomes an immensely powerful player overnight".

"If America collapses there will be no more sale of Chinese products to America and therefore very little purchase of Australian resources by China."

"The whole pulse of trade is compromised because people say, 'Why would I trade with the US when it might not pay its debt back?' "

He said this "real financial crisis will mean this preamble we have just had pales into insignificance".

Asked what sort of contingency plan he would advocate, Senator Joyce said it was like trying to prepare for a tidal wave, but the local economy should have more self-reliance.

"Things you look for in that economic Armageddon are the capacity to feed ourselves, the capacity to provide the fundamentals in medicines and basic fundamental requirements for our nation."

His comments about the banks were made later in the day on Sky TV. He said the Government had stood back and watched the centralisation of the sector, resulting in interest rates being hiked "under the cover of darkness".


Find a Managed Fund  100% Entry Fee Rebate

 

Have your say...


Submit your comments regarding this article
Email  (your email will not be displayed)
Nickname  (your "nickname" will be displayed)
Comment
  Type the characters as shown in this image. If you can't clearly read the characters please click on the 'Change Image' link to display a different set of characters.   Change Image (if it is too hard to read)
Please type the characters in the image above
 
All fields are mandatory

What others are saying...


 Submitted by alcatraz  on Friday, 11th Dec 2009 at 11:58 AM
Barnaby could not be more wrong. The US borrows in US dollars. They can print US dollars. They literally cannot default on their debt. He's a loopy, ill-informed scaremonger and it was a huge mistake by Tony Abbott to appoint him to a role requiring a bit of financial intelligence.
 Submitted by Jishin  on Friday, 11th Dec 2009 at 12:33 PM
A real problem would be a massive earthquake in Tokyo causing massive destructive which would force the Japanese to cash in their U.S. treasuries to pay for reconstruction. Unfortunately the US may not be able to repay.
 Submitted by genii6  on Friday, 11th Dec 2009 at 2:06 PM
Finally, someone talking sense I can understand. I may not be educated in economics but my gut feeling is that the financial system is one big ponzi scheme and what are we going to do about it IF it all falls apart.
 Submitted by Yep, seems likely  on Friday, 11th Dec 2009 at 8:06 PM
I tend to agree with Minister Joyce. Unfortunately the average person, has no idea how
bad things really are. I think the comment by Alcatraz reflects this. The real affect of
things that are in motion now haven't filtered through yet, and is a lot worse that what we
just experienced. (in case you're wondering - I have an economics degree and I trade
on the currency markets). Currently the whole system is artificially being propped up by
politicians who know that if it all goes belly up they loose their jobs. Hence the so called
"bail out". However Rudd/Swan have made a horrible mistake here in Australia doing it.
We will pay for that action in the near future. That is why Rudd will be having an early
election in February, as he the timing of an election in 2011 (the economy will be bad by
then) wont go well for Labor. So to extend out Labor's years in power he needs to have
en election now when the Liberals really don't look like a alternative government yet.
(2010 will be an interesting year indeed).
 Submitted by Mark Smith  on Friday, 11th Dec 2009 at 8:33 PM
Maybe shooting from the hip but a definite bullseye through the spinning US dollar and the illusion our politicians and administrators who got us into this mess, through their incredible economic incompetence, actually can devise a system and make changes which makes this economic catastrophe less likely in the future.

Barnaby Joyce's dire warning is not without substance. Why?

The complete divergence of world input and output prices and the significant lack of demand.

Increasing household debt to income ratios without the appropriate increase in GDP to support real value.

More importantly sovereign credit default swap (CDS), after rallying in tandem with the corporate market and the improving global economy, have widened significantly in recent weeks, indicating growing concerns about government credit worthiness.

Cheap US & UK money simply replacing cheap Chinese money to fuel asset price increases – real value?

Chinese refusal to accept its actions are pure economic vandalism.
Etc

In other words the fundamentals are becoming worse not better. What Barnaby Joyce and the rest of us, who do not believe the smoke and mirrors policy on the run stacks up against the actual numbers we are seeing want to reasonably know – What are the policy mechanisms in place to deal with the any number of imminent economic schisms – complete collapse in confidence in the US dollar, input & output price crunch, consequence of sharply falling commodity prices, a collapse of confidence in Government debt, you name it,..

Desperately shifting the economic load to the other side of the ship tends to only delay the inevitable.
 Submitted by The audience  on Friday, 11th Dec 2009 at 10:09 PM
For the first time since moving away from the gold standard there
is a real threat that the dollar being the international currency of
choice may be in jeopardy. I think it is fair to consider the risks in a
pragmatic way so as not to add fuel to the fire but it is a necessary
balancing act to concern ourselves with our own interests and the
risks that we face. So I think it is right for this argument to be
brought to the fore.
 Submitted by coops  on Friday, 11th Dec 2009 at 11:38 PM
Joyce is a fruit cake. Abbott needs to get rid of him asap
 Submitted by Bernard  on Friday, 11th Dec 2009 at 11:49 PM
In the end US only have one option. To monetize their debt by
printing more US dollars to pay back their massive debt!

This result in great devaluation of US dollar Zimbabwe style! When
this happen, USA is finished! No country in the world will accept US
dollar anymore, the ones who still have it will dump them. USA will
receive a massive tidal wave of US dollars coming back to them
from around the world which will result further devaluation of value
of US dollar.
 Submitted by Cheryl@MyCalifornia  on Saturday, 12th Dec 2009 at 6:33 AM
Y Outlook by The IMF finds a mammouth eyeful by Sydney's springfling to the glacier surmounting American headlines by online developing warside, at Obama!
 Submitted by gold coast john  on Saturday, 12th Dec 2009 at 9:21 AM
Blind Freddy can see that the situation as is cannot continue,if not mr.Joyce's solution then itll be another equally disasterous scenario,but collapse it will.
 Submitted by Soothsayer  on Saturday, 12th Dec 2009 at 9:42 AM
He's the only one in the political landscape that has spoken the truth on this subject so far. I hate doom and gloomers in general but the band aid approach taken by the major economies so far will only keep the boat afloat for a little while longer. . .Re printing money ( comment left by abbot or costello who know's ) you can print all the money you like. If the money has no real value its worth nothing. It is worth only the paper it is printed on.
 Submitted by Rahm  on Saturday, 12th Dec 2009 at 10:58 AM
I believe US will definitely default on its debt repayment in near future, there is no question about that. The more money the feds print the less value the US dollar will become. Australia should think beyond selling resources, if it has to maintain higher standard of living, if not atleast should not encourage Australians to load with more debt.
 Submitted by WanderingWhy  on Saturday, 12th Dec 2009 at 11:37 AM
Joyce is simply wrong by not thinking this through. If the USA collapsed then China and India will take the brakes off internal demand.
The situation would be simliar to what happened in the USA after WWII. All their armament factories switched from bombs and bullets to household appliances. And created the greatest burst in prosperity (for the western world) the world had ever seen.
The manufacturers in China and India are not going to sit idle when they have a total internal market of 2.2billion people. People who are looking forward to the same level of prosperity that the western world enjoys.
Yes, there will be disruptions. And a massive swing in the centre of power to China and India. Get used to the concept - it's going to happen in either the short or long term.
Joyce is a loose cannon who Abbot will regret appointing to such an important role.
 Submitted by haterofqueuejumpers  on Saturday, 12th Dec 2009 at 11:41 AM
"Barnaby could not be more wrong. The US borrows in US dollars. They can print US dollars. They literally cannot default on their debt. "

what if the us starts printing money?
zimbabwe
hyperinflation
when taxes cant cover interest (already about $3000) per us citizen or they have to refinance and nobody wants to, thats when they start getting into trouble
that is when they start printing money.
the us dollar goes to about 2c against the A$...
the world economy collapses.
 Submitted by xuewen  on Saturday, 12th Dec 2009 at 1:55 PM
alcatraz, printing money to pay off the foreign debt has effectively the same result as a default - sieze up the US economy - who would accept dollars or dollar denominated debt as payment when most of its value could disappear literally overnight?
 Submitted by Dingo  on Saturday, 12th Dec 2009 at 3:51 PM
I think Barnaby Joyce needs to go back to Kidergarden, I don't where he learnt his economy from. I believe he is really a very foolish loud mouth backward looking fool from countryside. You can don go into default son, if you print the stuff peopel want. US is printing USD, China and Japan have trillion of it, I believe our reserve is full of it, so is Barnaby foreign account.
Yes, one thing is for sure, it will devalue, but default.
This correction, Barnaby if you are listening aim to help US to reduce debt. They in fact paying much less, no interest rate and discounting in exchange, it make it easy to pay back. Why pay if you can print. So all US is doing now, just print, how much you need just give them a bell.

I am sorry for Tony, newly elected, but got his team all mix up. Eh, Barnaby is only good with herding sheeps and milking cow.

Give him a position where he an used his talent to the full, that is herding sheep and milking cows.

See you later.

Dingo
 Submitted by pablo  on Saturday, 12th Dec 2009 at 4:36 PM
Joyce may be inarticulate and incoherent but he's on to something...it's just a shame someone brighter than him can't explain it better.
 Submitted by Doom&Gloom  on Saturday, 12th Dec 2009 at 5:55 PM
It sure is a ponzi scheme !
The US Treasury usually create and sell new bonds so they can pay out the older
maturing bonds. If the Bond market collapses, guess what happens with no buyers!
Cranking up the printing presses to print money is futile, it would simply pay of the
debts with worthless money, resulting in total and complete system melt down.
All the other world currencies are also backed only by market confidence, so guess
what would then happen to those currencies?
Now you can understand why gold is currently the flavour of the month.
Funny thing though, when the stuff really hits the fan, useless dollars won't buy fuel for
the farmers tractors, and when the food starts running out, you can't eat gold !
 Submitted by gcgil  on Saturday, 12th Dec 2009 at 10:23 PM
The key word here is *may*. The US American government *may* default on its debt. What are the implications of such an event, and what is the risk of it occuring? Those elected into government should be able to provide an answer.
 Submitted by eddy  on Sunday, 13th Dec 2009 at 6:35 AM
All the blessings to Barnaby. Let him hold on to his shadow ministerial position and later on make the best ever govt, under Tony Abbott's leadership, pushing away the evil forces of global social-ism and communism, irrelavance, false "environment religion" and fascination with China.
 Submitted by Vincent  on Sunday, 13th Dec 2009 at 11:05 AM
By aggresively printing money they are already effectively defaulting - they will never actually defalt i.e. refuse to pay a coupon - but the purchasing value of the dollar repaid will be substantially reduced.
 Submitted by bombshellshocka  on Sunday, 13th Dec 2009 at 1:48 PM
alcatraz, you could not be more wrong! If ever country can just print more money, exchange it with US dollars (or what ever currency their debt is in, EURO, Yuan etc) on the international monetary market and pay off their debt, there would be no reason to go into debt in the first place. This is the exact way a country goes into complete financial meltdown. Once apon a time a country needed gold to 80% of the value of thier currency in circulation but now it is 10% plus a whole lot of other variables else the country is bankrupt. If you don't have the asset your money has no value. Barnaby is spot on with hi views and we should all start learning to speak Chinese as they, in every right, are groomed by the US's greed & stupidity, to become the next financial 'super-power'.
 Submitted by mack  on Sunday, 13th Dec 2009 at 5:42 PM
What is this guy trying to do - wreck confidence that is at the core of the economic recovery?
The liberals are in a mess. God help us if they regain power with the likes of this character as a minister.
 Submitted by think  on Sunday, 13th Dec 2009 at 7:00 PM
If the US prints more $ then the currency becomes worthless . ( Germany pre war and
Zimbabwe today ) I think all scenarios are to be looked at and for this we need good open
government not lightweight look at me idiots . Similar to what we have in place now . Open
up and discuss all alternatives and always be prepared be proactive not reactive.
 Submitted by terry2  on Sunday, 13th Dec 2009 at 7:03 PM
What alcatraz said.
US will just create more of its own currency to pay the debt.
The US dollar will be devalued in the process, and the US Fed is fine with this.
 Submitted by A_Greenspan  on Monday, 14th Dec 2009 at 12:28 AM
How can the United States default on it's debt? @alcatraz is right, the US debt is denominated in dollars, which are then printed by the United States. The treasuries, which are ownedin large amounts by Japan and China are similarly denominated in dollars.
The US will always be able to pay it's debts, although it might devalue its currency in doing so.
 Submitted by mickey_maoist  on Monday, 14th Dec 2009 at 8:02 AM
Barnaby is the true prophet for the people. The banksters MUST be destroyed for the good of real Australians.
 Submitted by Investment Banking Money  on Monday, 14th Dec 2009 at 11:15 AM
Joyce is an absolute idiot and his comments are grossly irresponsible. God forbid if he ever made those comments as the actual Treasurer - Australia will not only lose its trade relationships but possibly become an instigator to the second financial crisis. Does he know how volatile the markets are at the moment to any bad news? Does he even know how sensitive consumer confidence is at the moment?

Although the US has taken on a lot of debt to fund its stimulus packages, its public debt levels remains comparable to most European countries as a % of GDP (87% US VS 83% Europe) and is substantially lower than Japan (190% of GDP). Japan's public debt levels have been above 160% of GDP (2x US levels) for at least half a decade and has yet to default – in fact, its credit rating is AA according to S&P.

Trust me Mr Joyce, please take some professional advice before opening your mouth – you risk looking irrelevant if you continue. More importantly, you're making the rest of us look bad.

The Investment Banking Money
 Submitted by A_Greenspan  on Monday, 14th Dec 2009 at 12:00 PM
It's technically correct for those who are saying that a massive devaluation of the dollar that can result if America's debts are suddenly called upon will result in disaster.
That is the reason why it is nearly impossible for it to happen. The countries who hold the largest amount of US treasuries will not dump their holdings in the open market, precisely because it will only result in a devaluation of their value.
As for those who are saying that the wold will soon abandon the dollar, one has to remember that the US is still the largest economy in the world. Largest in terms of real value, GDP, and not just in paper value. The US dollar is thus backed by real production even if not by gold anymore.
As the recent financial crisis has shown, the rest of the world is largely dependent on the US economy simply because it drive so much of the global world trade.
Don't bet your hopes on China over the US. A slight drop in disposable income among the Americans results in a massive factory closures in China because of lowered demand.
Search for Managed Funds, Superannuation Funds and Retirement Funds Find a Managed Fund Reduce your fees and save money on your Managed Funds with our 100% Entry Fee Rebate 100% Entry Fee Rebate

Login
Email
Password
     Log me in automatically in future
Forgotten password? | Secure Login | Terms & Conditions
Free Membership

Membership benefits...

  • 100% entry fee rebates
  • Cash back on your managed fund investments with our innovative TrailCap™ program
  • Independent research on...
    • over 1,000 managed funds
    • over 300 ASX-listed Companies
    • top performing suburbs/postcodes
  • Access to IPOs/floats & other investment offers
  • Superior investment tools...
    • Portfolio manager
    • Watchlists
    • Alerts
  • Regular investment e-newsletter

Advertisement

Portfolio / Watchlist

Start a new portfolio / view your existing portfolio.
Track all your assets and manage your investments easily.

Trade Shares Online from $19.95^

eNewsletter

Keep up to date with new investments and important news - subscribe to our FREE weekly eNewsletters. Sign up now!



Advertisement